Culture Change

Emotions in Management: The Underestimated Power in the Background

Matthias Kolbusa3 min reading time

A strategy isn’t making progress. The usual reaction: even more presentations, even more alignment, even more communication. The result is rarely more followership. Usually, it’s more unnecessary complexity.

Fear makes things complicated

Complexity is actually a wonderful thing. Without it, many business models wouldn’t exist at all. It’s just that we humans don’t like it. Complexity makes us uncertain, and uncertainty creates fear, whether we notice it or not. Out of fear, we start planning in minute detail, checking more often, and documenting meticulously who said what and when. That creates internal complexity the market never asked for. The jungle turns into a witches’ cauldron.

High-performance organisations never get caught in this cycle in the first place. They can live with ambiguity, and they don’t hold conversations on the basis of “right or wrong”, but with the aim of gaining insight.

The technocracy fallacy

For a long time, I believed it myself: clarity creates enthusiasm, and whoever convinces with logic wins followers. Observation says otherwise. In the end, what triggers action is always an emotion. Meaning comes from doing, not from talking. If commitment is lacking and you simply explain even more, you dig yourself deeper into the technocracy corner.

Thrust and drag

Not every emotion has the same effect. Trust, passion, and curiosity drive us forward and last a long time. Shame, guilt, and despair slow us down; I call them the “dark side of the force”. And we often program them in ourselves: we go straight from the goal to planning activities, we monitor them, and because plans never work out, the steering committee turns into a courtroom. What’s left is justification instead of value creation.

Fear is ambivalent. Shortly before a deadline, it releases enormous energy. As a permanent tool, it ruins any performance.

A six-month focal length

Why does nobody get moving, even at five to twelve? Everyone has an emotional, anticipatory horizon; I call it the focal length. Only when a state lies within this horizon does it trigger emotions, and with them, action. On average, the focal length is about six months.

Anything further away is interesting, but it doesn’t move anyone. That explains why budget rounds in autumn are relaxed, and why panic suddenly breaks out in the third quarter of the following year. The consequence for strategy, projects, and change: break important initiatives into six-month portions, and describe what will be different by then so concretely that passion grows from it.

What’s in the issue

In “Emotions in Management” I describe how fear creates unnecessary complexity, why the technocracy fallacy is so widespread, how emotions can be mapped by thrust and drag, and what the focal length means for your management. Short and to the point, on eleven pages.

Download full paper (PDF)

Download full paper (PDF)

More in the Best of

Kein Erwartungsdruck, keine Agenda, keine taktischen Spiele.

Thirty models from twenty years of Secrets of Execution®, each with one thesis, one graphic and the tough questions. Plus a self-assessment with twelve sentences from executive boards.

Go to the Best of