Podcast
Debugged – The Truth Behind Leadership (in German)

An unscripted podcast for decision-makers who are ready to talk not about their successes, but about the decisions behind them. About setbacks, doubt, turning points. I lead the conversations as a debugger: not to expose, but to understand what truly sustains a system.
The trailer as a taster
An episode lasts between 60 and 120 minutes. No script, no time pressure.
Good talks show success. DEBUGGED shows the person behind it.
Most business podcasts revolve around success stories polished for LinkedIn. DEBUGGED does the opposite. In every episode, I talk with C-level personalities about the moments when nothing was clear: tough decisions, setbacks, personal turning points. No PR speak, no hunger for scandal. A space of equals where silence, reflection and uncomfortable questions have their place
In the case study, every decision looks logical. In the moment it was made, it rarely was. We talk about the trade-off behind it, when the clean option no longer held
Behind the job title stands a person with doubts, fractures and blind spots. I ask about the moments when the role ends and the person starts talking
A journalist chases every headline. I look for what lies beneath. That is why I ask the questions nobody else asks and hear what nobody else gets to hear
Five pillars and the debugger question.
Every episode follows the same architecture. I take my guest’s organisation apart along the five pillars of a functioning organisation – strategy, leadership, operations, culture, environment. At each point I ask the same question: keep, challenge, transform or kill? It is not a checklist but a thinking framework that carries the conversation.
Does the company have a strategy worthy of the name, or merely a collection of goals? I examine whether the direction holds and which few levers everything ultimately hinges on.
What does the guest stand for as a leader when things get uncomfortable? I ask where they truly lead and where they let the system lead them.
This is where it becomes clear whether the strategy stays connected to day-to-day operations. I look at the processes and routines that deliver, and at those that merely create busyness.
Culture is not in the mission statement. It shows in behaviour when nobody is watching. I ask about the gap between what hangs on the wall and what holds true in daily life
No organisation exists in isolation. I test whether the guest reads the market, customers and the major shifts, or is reacting to a world that no longer exists.
Keep, Challenge, Transform, Kill?
Against each of the five pillars, I assess what my guest does. Keep, because it holds. Challenge, because something does not fit. Transform, because the core is right but the form no longer is. Or kill, because time has overtaken the model. No consultant prose. A direct assessment
What interests me is what you cannot read about a person.«
Every episode a debugging
60 to 180 minutes. In German and unscripted.
Ninety-seven billion this year alone that the Big Techs are investing in AI.
On the other hand, MIT says we still have no measurable impact on the balance sheet for ninety-five per cent of AI projects.
Are you among the other five per cent?
Welcome to Debugged!
Our top management podcast.
A warm welcome to Julia Jarbitsch, and also many thanks for being here. As I've been reminded,
I should always remind you all to diligently like and subscribe!
So that we're not just number one in the Apple Business category with the Debugged podcast, but perhaps in other places too.
Many thanks for that.
But first of all, a warm hello to you!
Thank you so much for the invitation.
You've come straight from the Atruvia Solution Days that you're currently running in Hamburg. Before we get to that, I had to smile recently when we spoke.
I told you that after my twenty-five years of triathlon, I'd been in a training plateau and thought, what on earth is going on?
I felt wretched; apparently I'd drifted into a mild case of overtraining, but my cardiologist simply told me: Matthias, you're just getting old!
Ah, that's a bit mean,
isn't it?!
Well, it's also not... I actually found the message reassuring in that I didn't have anything serious.
Because when for the first time in your life over two or three months you get dizzy during a run -- I'd simply never experienced that.
But the message was fine in the end.
You said: feedback is a gift!
You don't have to accept it, though.
Exactly.
When was the last time you received feedback where you thought: I'll leave that one, thanks?
Can you remember anything?
Yes, there's an anecdote that comes to mind.
It was shortly after my appointment when I joined the executive board, about
now...
yes, roughly eighteen months ago. And of course you speak to many people, including various bank board members -- our customers. And I walk into a round, start chatting,
you greet each other nicely, and then a colleague comes up to me and says: Well, in terms of looks, the board has certainly improved.
I smiled politely too and had to wonder: what does she actually mean by that?
You went bright red -- it was quite funny!
It certainly wasn't meant maliciously.
We actually had a really good laugh about it afterwards.
But there are those moments where you think: okay, there are other ways to put that.
Which of course takes us straight into a topic that surely occupies you and probably hasn't made your life easier as a woman in top management.
My personal observation is that in banking and insurance I encounter more female board members than in the industrial environment.
But more doesn't mean exponentially more.
In industry it's usually zero, sometimes perhaps one woman out of four or five.
Does something like that still annoy you?
Or do you look past it by now, or... yes.
I take it very calmly and in good humour by now. I think over time you learn to handle it quite well.
There's certainly the odd comment here and there that might touch you a bit more emotionally.
But on balance, I simply fight for the message that there are genuinely many wonderful examples now.
Many brilliant women who have arrived in the sector, in industry, and we simply need far more of them.
And so that it serves as a role model, especially for younger women, to say: that's a cool path and I want to pursue it too. Not talking about quotas, but about this becoming the new normal.
That we have mixed teams, that we have different characters. The word 'diverse' is everywhere, but I genuinely believe in it.
When different backgrounds, different cultural backgrounds -- just as much as men and women and everything else that belongs to the topic of diversity -- come together, a completely different kind of energy and entirely different perspectives emerge.
And from that you can in turn create something truly brilliant and new. That's what I advocate for -- being an example myself, but also encouraging others to become one.
I'd love to explore that in our conversation too.
At Debugged we always look at strategy, how value creation actually works, culture, leadership, and also trends.
So what would interest me is if we could perhaps focus a bit more on culture and leadership today.
Not just whether you consider this diversity important -- and not just gender-specific. I'd be interested in your perspective later on what it actually delivers in practice.
I can only speak from the context of Debugged and my own experience: we've had Wiebke Meier and Amischa Weissenbacher, CEO of TUI Cruises and COO of Mann+Hummel, as guests -- two
outstanding female top managers, both of whom I've known for a long time.
And I believe it makes a real difference.
Perhaps on the topic of performance and pressure -- competition is anything but foreign to you.
You came to Germany from Moldova at the age of ten, I believe.
You did competitive sports?
Athletics, dancing -- you were even German champion in dancing, I believe.
Have you always had this... It pays to be a winner, or... Tell us a bit about -- is that
innate?
Absorbed with your mother's milk, so to speak.
Yes, lovely topic.
One aspect is the cultural influence of where you come from.
I always say I'm profoundly grateful to my parents for what they gave me, and especially my father -- someone who never saw me as a typical girl but said: here's a young individual with a lot of potential.
And how wonderful it would be if my child managed to get the absolute maximum out of that potential.
That's why I say in today's world... You really mustn't underestimate it --
what parental influence, what the family gives you.
It's truly a rucksack for life, and being aware of that responsibility is something that's very easily forgotten these days, which is why I keep coming back to it.
I think that's also a foundation and cornerstone.
One that you need to lay.
And yes, as you say... For me it was a very exciting time, coming from Moldova to Germany -- to be precise, to Dortmund.
I grew up in the Ruhr area, in Dortmund.
Then also... In the
Pott!
In the Ruhr area?
Exactly, I grew up there.
Picked up a great deal of wonderful values there, especially in the Ruhr area.
This sense of straightforwardness, clarity, and honesty in what you say.
May I ask a few questions in between?
Yes, of course!
A ten-year-old girl arrives in Dortmund -- are there still... My wife is a Russlanddeutsche, an ethnic German from the former Soviet Union; she was a bit older.
She was nearly twenty when she came to Germany.
She can still tell me exactly -- she first arrived at a refugee camp.
I don't know what the circumstances were for you, but she can still describe precisely what her first impressions were.
Are there still any first impressions that Julia as a ten-year-old has?
Do you have an image?
Absolutely.
Similar situations, actually.
We also first arrived at a refugee camp, in Unna, the neighbouring town.
Some of you will know it. And it was... well, in my very first hours in Germany I went shopping with my dad.
And it was at a Koop!
I don't think many people still remember that.
They were later bought out, but anyway -- into this Koop shop, and I walk in and see full shelves.
They are genuinely full.
And above all, one memory that always sticks with me.
Shelves full of bananas!
Bananas -- an absolute delicacy back in the former Soviet Union too.
You could probably only get them on the black market through some kind of barter. And my father looks at me, sees my jaw drop, sees me completely overwhelmed by this abundance of food, by this... this wealth, in inverted commas, and he looks at me and says: Julia, you've arrived in a country full of opportunities.
And it's up to you to decide what you make of these opportunities.
How wonderful!
Just like that.
And I have to say, every time I talk about it I get goosebumps, because it's truly a sentence that has stayed with me so deeply, and I keep bringing it back and making it present.
In those moments when you think -- don't give up. Perhaps losing a competition or not getting a promotion.
Always in those moments, remembering that point to stay grounded and to look at where your roots are.
Where did you start?
I think it's absolutely crucial in those very moments to be aware of that.
So it's very vivid in my mind.
Wonderful!
Do you have siblings?
How many siblings?
I have a brother.
My brother is ten years younger, so he essentially grew up in Germany. And yes, you know how it is when the age gap is that large -- he looks up to me and says, yes, that's of course my sister.
Sometimes slipping a bit into the motherly role too.
But especially the family influence and that solidarity, and certainly the language as well.
The languages too -- our parents always tried to preserve them for us.
I have Russian as my mother tongue, which was nurtured over many years to keep the language alive.
Well, that's already something.
But I think... The others
probably wouldn't understand that!
Very interesting.
And you got into competitive sport -- in Dortmund, through interest, school, or parental guidance?
How did that develop?
I first tried ballet as a child.
Also a classic --
we tried that with our daughter too!
Well, I have to say it wasn't for me.
It was so stiff, up on those toes and somehow too regimented -- it wasn't my thing!
But still, that love of music, dancing, and rhythm was something I carried within me.
And so I came to competitive ballroom dancing -- Latin American and standard dances. First in the ten-dance discipline, later as I got older with a focus on Latin American dances. And the topic of performance, as you mentioned --
I think people underestimate competitive dancing somewhat, but it really does require a great deal of discipline and endurance.
For me it was completely normal.
Five days a week there was training; at weekends there were either squad sessions or competitions.
When you made the elite squad... even more. Then I also did sprinting alongside.
That was the reason I did sprinting on the side --
to improve my endurance fitness.
And naturally, when you learn from an early age that discipline, that perseverance, setting very clear goals -- but also at a young age learning to deal not only with success but with failure.
When you don't achieve the goals you've set, and in that moment learning to get up, dust yourself off, and carry on -- over and over again... That's certainly something that sport shaped enormously.
That's why I can only encourage every young person -- and parents too -- to guide their children into sport, because sport gives you so much for life.
Things that school can only teach you to a limited extent.
Where you say to yourself: this is a foundation that will carry me for life.
Can you remember where you failed in sport?
Do you still have --
Lost!
I could probably spend several hours here... Something
that particularly shaped you.
It is very formative. I was very successful very early on.
That also always comes with certain downsides, because when you win a lot of titles early, the question is: the fall from height is of course brutal.
And that happened to me too -- regional titles, national titles... Then there were various changes.
In competitive dancing you also change your dance partner.
And then you start again from scratch and realise: you're just not managing to replicate those earlier successes.
What's different now? What do I need to change?
You can set yourself a goal, but that's no guarantee whatsoever that you'll reach it.
And then constantly reinventing yourself, finding new approaches, perhaps changing your training routines.
Perhaps working with different choreographers, perhaps bringing in other coaches and looking at: where are you already good?
Where do you genuinely still have potential to improve?
Do pick that up later, because I'd be very interested to know how you apply that
within the Atruvia organisation.
Let's make the bridge to Atruvia now, having got to know you a bit as a person.
After university you went to Commerzbank?
Yes, during
my studies already.
Straight
after my A-levels
I
studied and worked in parallel.
Was that a smart move in hindsight?
Best decision ever.
It's a personality thing; I'm a practitioner.
I think if I'd just sat on the university bench for five or six years it wouldn't have been my thing. This symbiosis of learning something and immediately having the opportunity to apply it, to see how it works --
for me it was absolutely perfect. That's why I say the dual study system that exists in Germany is a gift.
Great to hear!
Good. And you were there for seventeen years?
I was seventeen years in the Commerzbank group, correct.
And then you switched to Atruvia in twenty-two?
Yes. You took over the IT project portfolio management, right?
Exactly, the portfolio management,
I took over.
Would you mind briefly sketching out what you did at Commerzbank, and above all what drove you away from or towards Atruvia?
Or were you pulled by something?
Yes, seventeen years in the Commerzbank group -- quite a long time.
I was still a very young person when I switched, but it was certainly a formative time. And by background, as I said, I'm a banker.
I think that's also important to know for what follows, why I then made the move -- because understanding how banking works, being in daily interaction with the customer, understanding how a bank branch operates today,
also experiencing the first beginnings of the omnichannel world --
I still benefit from that today because I experienced it first-hand in practice.
The pain points, certainly, but also things that work and how to make a sales organisation successful. So by background I'm a banker, having had the privilege of serving various customer groups in banking.
I was also active in international business at Commerzbank -- in the context of servicing foreign banks. As a really young person, I had the opportunity to be involved in the material migration when Dresdner Bank and Commerzbank merged.
Those were my first points of contact at the time.
With IT -- migrating Dresdner Bank's international data into the Commerzbank world.
In that process I had my first encounters with IT systems, with mainframes, with various interfaces and technologies.
I have to admit, at the time I didn't find it especially exciting.
It was one of those moments where I thought: right, I need to learn this first.
Lots of data, lots of nodes, keeping them all apart. And then I had the opportunity to work on many strategic projects.
So out of sales and into strategic project management -- got to do some very exciting things.
Opening a representative office in Uzbekistan, for instance, or looking at how to increase the letter of credit business tenfold through new automated processes. And eventually the call came to become a board assistant -- I was assistant to
I think after so many years I can say it was Martin Zielke at the time.
Being a board assistant was a truly formative experience, because that was the first time I got a taste of what it's like at the top.
How does it work?
I also learnt that even a board member can't walk on water.
We're all just people.
And then the call came again --
back into sales. I had the privilege of leading a large sales unit there, before switching back into product management.
And at some point the opportunity came along: the digital campus of Commerzbank was being launched.
When was that, timeline-wise?
I really have to think about when that was.
Let me have a think.
Around sixteen, seventeen... So quite a while ago.
Digital
campus, Commerzbank.
The digital campus was one of the early initiatives. They were looking for someone who understood banking on the one hand
but also had the appetite and inclination to engage deeply with IT.
The first developments, doing things in an agile way, paying much closer attention to customer-centricity, thinking through an entire journey from the customer's perspective -- understanding what the customer's actual need is.
How do you bridge the translation into IT requirements?
I switched to the IT side and came back --
I'd say IT people are very honest, actually.
They tell you very precisely what works
and what doesn't!
And somehow I liked this very direct language, the hands-on mentality, but also the tremendous sense of change already then about what would be technologically possible.
And alongside my first degree I'd later added a Master's at Frankfurt School, and it was my
professor
who said to me at the time: Julia, I'm absolutely convinced that banks will be far more technology companies than they currently realise.
That was a sentence that really stayed with me, and I became convinced: right,
I think there's something to that.
But I asked myself, in a moment of self-reflection:
can I answer that for myself?
Do I also have the know-how, the competence,
the knowledge required to be a bridge-builder between banking expertise and IT?
And that's why the step into IT was so important.
I joined enterprise architecture, and then had the privilege of leading what was called the Customer Centricity Architecture at Commerzbank.
Through that I learnt a great deal about how that translation works, which is why the idea of being a bridge-builder between banking and IT took shape.
If someone asks me today: are you an IT person or a banker? I say: exactly that.
I think playing this bridge between the two worlds, harmonising them -- on one side, understanding very clearly what's actually moving and occupying the customer and the banks,
and translating that into requirements so it's clear on the IT side too.
But equally making the return journey, transporting the new solution back to the banks.
I think that's a capability that's more essential than ever today.
Because you think you're speaking the same language, but actually they're two different things.
That's true, and I think it applies not just to banks -- it's a general phenomenon.
Then in twenty-two to Atruvia -- why?
It's partly connected to those seventeen years at the Commerzbank group.
Still young!
But seventeen years at Commerzbank is a very long time. And I owe that company an enormous amount.
I met wonderful people there, including mentors, but I also saw things that could have gone differently.
I wanted to take what I knew into a different environment.
You also lived through some extremely difficult times at Commerzbank -- quasi-nationalised, to put it a bit dramatically.
But you know what I mean.
And how do you view it now?
One last point perhaps on that -- the HVB takeover. Does that leave you cold?
What's your view?
Well, there are certainly two hearts beating in my chest on that.
Of course, on one hand it's a shame if a company and a brand were to disappear in some form -- one that also shaped many years of my own career.
Above all -- and I keep saying this -- I think there's rarely been a company that gave such fantastic training to young people as this one.
You simply have to say that. On the other hand, it's a story that's been dragging on for some time.
And sometimes it's good to draw a line and bring clarity.
Bring clarity to the workforce too, have a clear course for where things are heading.
A new European champion may emerge from this, and that could be an opportunity.
So I don't see it only as: what a shame that a brand I knew is disappearing.
But on the other hand, it's also an opportunity to build a European entity that will be far more relevant going forward.
And if the best of these different worlds is merged successfully, I believe a strong new brand can emerge -- for Germany but above all for the European banking market.
Good perspective!
Explain to a twelve-year-old what Atruvia actually does.
The name hasn't been around very long.
I think 2020...
We've just celebrated our fifth anniversary.
Right, you emerged from the merger of Fiducia and GAD?
Explain it for simpletons like me, in inverted commas.
What do you actually do?
What do you earn your money with?
You're
not a simpleton! Not at all!
So firstly, we do cool things.
Of course!
How could it be
otherwise?!
No, but I think put quite simply: everyone knows a bank. And let's say, for example, a Volksbank.
The Volksbank customer has an app, probably also a card, and for that bank to function, it needs someone like us to make everything work technically.
We do our job best when you hear nothing about us.
Then we're really doing our job well.
So not
like on the seventh of July this year when... Apologies.
I'd
rather not talk about that right now, Matthias, please!
Let's
move on.
Let's just skip over that for now.
Right?
It happened,
it was resolved...
Moving on!
But do please carry on explaining.
Exactly,
but essentially, when I want to pay at the till -- especially if I want to pay with my smartwatch or phone somewhere -- but also if I want to finance a house or a flat, or if I want to buy securities...
So really everything you
do at the bank -- as I said, in the branch itself but also via the mobile channel --
we're there in the background making sure it all runs smoothly, technically, and that customers are hopefully as satisfied as possible.
And that's essentially what it does.
You'll correct me in a moment, but as I recall there are still roughly six hundred and forty Volksbanken
and Raiffeisenbanken.
And then there are eleven large Sparda banks?
Yes, so in total we have roughly six hundred and thirty institutions -- the statistics will
probably be updated at the end of the year because of course mergers also take place during the year.
But roughly six hundred and thirty Volksbanken and Raiffeisenbanken.
However, we have a total of roughly eight hundred and fifty customers in our portfolio.
Because there are also others from industry -- one I can mention publicly is for example the ADAC,
who are also with us, as well as some private banks in our portfolio.
And regarding the Sparda banks you just mentioned -- we're very grateful that since last year we have all eleven Sparda banks back at Atruvia.
The collaboration is going very, very well and we're delighted that the migrations have gone so fantastically.
I think everyone now has a clear sense of at least what you do.
Then there's this new operating model.
Oh look at you!
What you
know!
Yes, I looked it up beforehand. Let's see how my memory for numbers holds up -- by 2035 it's supposed to deliver two point six billion euros in savings.
And some check showed that if the banks actually used what's already there, nought point nine billion would come regardless.
In other words, there's an ambition.
These aren't exactly small change we're talking about.
Is that achievable from your perspective, and don't you essentially already have the solution?
Even in twenty-four it was said: of the two point six, nought point nine should be doable as things stand.
So what's the hold-up?
I think that's a really fair question, and the answer has several layers.
One thing is clear: the potential is there, the numbers aren't fiction.
But the challenge lies in translating that into practice.
Because what's true is that we have solutions, they're available.
The question is: how quickly are banks able and willing to adopt them?
Because it's not just about switching on a system.
Behind every change there are processes, there's training, there's cultural change within the bank itself.
Some banks are further along than others.
Some have already digitalised their processes very well, others are still on the journey.
And that's exactly the challenge -- it's not just a technology problem, it's an adoption problem.
And that's where our role as a technology partner becomes important.
We can't just deliver the solution and walk away.
We need to accompany the banks through this transformation.
And that's also one of the reasons why I say: the new operating model is so much more than just a technology story.
It's about changing how banks and their technology partner work together.
It's about shared accountability, it's about joint outcome orientation.
And that's a cultural shift for both sides.
Now you've also said, and I found this very interesting, that you believe in a future where the bank adviser will always be needed.
Not for a simple transfer, but precisely for the complex moments in life.
Tell me a bit more about that.
Yes, I genuinely believe that.
If I look at the customer journey today, the transactional side is increasingly automated -- and rightly so.
Nobody needs an adviser to make a transfer.
But when it comes to the big life decisions -- buying a house, retirement planning, structuring a business succession --
that's where the human element makes all the difference.
It's about trust. It's about having someone who understands not just the numbers but the person behind them.
And I think that's where the Volksbanken and Raiffeisenbanken have a genuine competitive advantage.
Because they know their customers. They know the region. They know the local economy.
That proximity, that local rootedness, is something no neo-bank can replicate.
But -- and this is the crucial 'but' -- this advice needs to be powered by the best possible data, by the best possible tools.
And that's where AI comes in.
Not to replace the adviser, but to make the adviser significantly better.
To give them a three-hundred-and-sixty-degree view of the customer that they could never achieve on their own.
To identify patterns, to predict needs before the customer even articulates them.
That's the future I see: technology and humanity working hand in hand.
Let's talk a bit about culture and leadership -- you touched on it already.
You joined Atruvia's board in what capacity?
I joined as Chief Market Officer, so responsible for the entire market side --
so customers, sales, marketing, product management, partnerships.
Tell me about the moment you walked in the door.
What did you find, and what did you think needed to change?
I found a company with enormously dedicated people.
People who are deeply committed to their mission.
But I also found structures and processes that had grown organically over many years and weren't always optimally aligned with the customer.
What do you mean by that?
Well, for example, our go-to-market approach.
We had account managers who'd been in their roles for twenty years, with wonderful relationships --
they knew their customers' families, right down to the grandchildren.
But the market is changing. The demands are changing. And the question is:
are we set up to serve the banks of tomorrow, or the banks of yesterday?
I believe with all my heart in the value of long-standing relationships.
But I also believe we need to combine that with modern tools, modern approaches, and a fresh perspective on what our customers actually need.
So that's the gap you identified?
Yes. And it's not about throwing out the old and replacing it with the new.
It's about intelligently combining the best of both worlds.
The relationship knowledge, the trust that's been built over decades --
that's incredibly valuable.
But complementing it with data-driven insights, with AI-powered recommendations, with a systematic CRM approach --
that's where the magic happens.
That sounds like it brings significant change management challenges.
Oh, absolutely.
And let me be very candid about that.
Not everyone was thrilled when I announced the new market strategy.
Change is uncomfortable. Humans are creatures of habit.
And when someone says: we're now introducing CRM systematically, we're using new AI tools,
we're trying to learn much more about the customer -- building a three-hundred-and-sixty-degree customer view and above all using AI tools to understand the customer better than perhaps any adviser ever could, and to issue very targeted recommendations.
Very clearly showing where a bank has already developed well,
and where it still has potential -- using these tools to serve customers in a much more targeted, personalised way.
With tools I first need to learn, first need to accept.
Tools that change my workflows.
Versus: I've always done it to the best of my knowledge and ability, and certainly done it well.
Why should I change my processes after so many years when they work?
And to go in there and say: you can't expect your customer to implement the biggest transformation --
not just 'do the new operating model'.
We have a transformation in the banks too; they're also changing
their entire processes, possibly even their business models and strategic direction.
Because implementing our solution is more than simply plugging in a new cable.
It's simply not credible, I think,
to demand that of your customer without practising it yourself.
That's exactly the point -- lead by example, believe in it too.
Something you're not convinced of yourself, you honestly can't convey to others.
And the truth is: not everyone will come along.
And I'm aware of that.
When I announced the new market strategy and spoke very openly about it, as I'm doing here --
I asked my colleagues a question.
It's your decision whether you're on board or not!
I think it's an individual decision, and everyone has to make it for themselves.
Do I want to go down this path?
Can I go down this
path?!
Or not.
And that's perfectly fine.
I'm not going to strap anyone to a chair and say: you have to do this. No!
I want everyone to make that decision for themselves, and I believe only once you've said in your own mind 'I want to' can you truly commit.
What do you do when someone says: Julia, I'm fully on board -- and you notice they're actually not?
Does that happen?
Or has it?
Well, we actually had a brilliant mentalist at the Solution Days yesterday --
Thorsten Havener, who explained wonderfully how different it is when someone nods but isn't actually engaged. You can sense it in someone's entire body language.
In their facial expressions, their gestures.
How well does it all hang together?
How does it resonate?
I think you notice it very quickly.
I'd describe myself as an empathic person.
And I believe I can read my counterpart to some extent in the moment, to recognise whether someone is truly present or... just saying
it. And when you notice that, how do you deal with it?
Are you more the proactively assertive type -- and I know 'assertive' can sound negative, but it doesn't have to be --
or are you more the observing, passive type who lets things run first? Or does it depend?
I think it depends on the person opposite me.
I wouldn't describe it as one blanket approach.
I first want to understand why.
Mm-hm.
So what triggers it?
Do you approach people about it?
Yes!
Definitely.
So actually -- I get the impression you nodded, but...
Exactly.
It's also that... especially in my direct reports, right?
That's also about my understanding of leadership.
Especially with my leadership team --
I often compare it to something like a family.
There'll always be the odd point of contention, but we always come back together and fight for the same cause.
And that's also very important to me -- that it works well in that way, and that I have the feeling we're all heading in the same direction.
And especially when I sense something doesn't quite fit --
I'll pick up the phone, or seek out another conversation. Listen in and ask the question: I'm just reflecting an impression back to you.
I somehow have the feeling we're not quite aligned here yet.
I sense something's holding you back.
Perhaps it's just my impression.
Perhaps I'm wrong.
But let's try to talk about it openly. And I try to make things discussable.
I think in many respects there shouldn't be any taboo subjects.
Especially in such large transformation processes, especially when you work so closely together.
A high-performing, capable team must be able to voice things that are going well, but much more importantly, things that aren't working.
Do your colleagues do that?
So -- how many direct reports do you have?
It's eight, did I remember that right?
Let me count myself.
One, two, three, four, five, six... seven!
Including you?
Then
eight.
Does it actually happen?
Let me think about that for a moment.
Can you share a sort of best practice -- if you want a high-performing team,
especially as a board member with your direct reports,
how should you organise yourself?
What does the governance look like? But also, what else do you do to ensure the team really is and remains a team?
Can you give us some insight?
Yes, so I've been with this team in its current constellation for about eighteen months now. And this is part of it too --
there have been some personnel changes, and I think it's important in a role like this to make sure you have the right companions by your side.
I believe that's essential, because it's also about mindset and, for me personally, about personal performance standards.
So the first piece of advice would already be: make sure you have a winning team that you're comfortable with?
Absolutely!
And especially when it comes to forming your team -- bring together like-minded people, and very importantly, distinguish that from people who are alike.
I don't want clones, for goodness' sake.
The more different perspectives, characters, capabilities and competences, the better -- that's what I think is crucial.
And especially on the topic of personnel decisions -- don't wait too long.
Right from the start, form a picture, understand what works and what doesn't.
Where do you need a change?
And I'd say: be tough on the issue, gentle with the person. That's very important to me -- always at eye level, where you can still look each other in the eye after the conversation, but have a shared understanding of the matter. I think that's crucial. So if there's one thing you should do at the very start of a leadership approach, that's definitely one of my absolute priorities.
If you think through your learnings and best practices -- what else would you say people should pay attention to if they want a high-performing team?
Well, I've just mentioned it -- the topic of diversity, different perspectives, capabilities, competences, people who've seen different things, who perhaps bring entirely different experiences.
A good mix of people who've been there longer and know the history, and those who bring a completely fresh perspective.
Getting that balance right... That's one thing. And another that I really want to underline:
people who give you their honest opinion.
People who deliberately say: that was all well and good, what you just said,
but I see it very differently.
I think it's important that we also look at this from a completely different angle.
I think there's nothing worse than losing yourself in your own self-satisfaction and saying: I know exactly how everything works.
And my perspective is always the best.
I think it's absolutely vital to hear other perspectives and to consciously avoid becoming resistant to advice.
Once you have the right people in place, and especially to bring those perspectives to life -- could you briefly outline how often you meet as a management team?
How much of that is operational?
What do you do that isn't operational but leads to exactly what you just described?
Can you share a few more insights?
Yes,
of course, happy to.
So we also have the classic routines -- our weeklies, essentially like a check-in.
How
long are those?
An hour, just under an hour.
So snappy, really
very brisk and brief.
What are the topics of the week?
Quick round-the-table: what's really current right now?
What's on your mind?
What do we need to know? Where do we perhaps
need to sync up?
Perhaps a look at the week ahead, what follow-up meetings are there, where do we need to align.
Those are the weeklies.
Then we have monthlies -- more time.
Always three to four hours where we go deeper on certain topics.
What you should know is that we do those digitally.
So weeklies and monthlies are digital.
And then there are the quarterlies, which are always in person over two days. We take time for strategic topics, for exchanging our thoughts and calibrating together.
I think it's also important to spend an evening together, getting to know each other as people outside the professional context.
I think that's very important.
I always say: one thing is knowing a person professionally; the other is what's currently going on in their private life.
And sometimes knowing that is almost more important in such close collaboration, because then you understand why a person is acting the way they are.
Because you should never forget: everyone carries a rucksack on their back.
Always.
And knowing that often makes it much easier to understand afterwards why someone reacted a bit more sharply, perhaps a bit more aggressively or dominantly, or is holding back.
There are different reaction and behavioural patterns.
That's why it's so crucial to try to understand the whole person.
Do you also allow them to see the whole of you?
Do you open up, or do you tend to close off? And have you ever had the experience that you opened up too much?
Or how do you handle it?
Yes... That's exactly, let's say, a fine line and a risk.
By nature, as I mentioned, coming from the Ruhr area, I'm quite direct.
I like to call things by their name.
I'm certainly someone who sometimes wears her heart on her sleeve.
And when something really preoccupies and moves me, I say so.
I also always start, when we have our sessions --
especially in the quarterlies, with a little check-in.
I say: on a scale of one to ten, where are you right now?
One is catastrophic, ten is brilliant -- and please explain why.
Perhaps privately and professionally -- what might be holding me back... Am I actually mentally present, or are my thoughts elsewhere and I don't want to engage?
Where are you right now?
Me, right now?
I'd say a solid nine.
This is fun right now!
The Solution Days are under way and I always draw enormous energy from them, so right now things are good.
And in those sessions, do you also share your own assessment?
I
do, I do.
And I'm happy to open up there too, and say what's really moving and occupying me.
Once more... If I don't
lead by example myself.
What was the lowest rating you've given yourself in the past eighteen months?
I've been down to about a two.
Oh!
What was going on at a two?
If you'd like to say -- you don't have to...
Oh, it can be various things.
It could be friction on the customer front.
But it can also be private things.
Or when something isn't right at home in the family,
I have to say...
That definitely affects me.
And do you share that with your colleagues?
So that -- leading by example, as you just showed -- it's important to open up.
Certainly!
Would you say it's simply important, in order to perform and deliver as a team, to have understanding for one another?
It's a question of trust.
Of course I also extend a great deal of trust.
I then naturally expect trust in return. Does it make you vulnerable and open to attack? Absolutely.
I've learnt over the years that it's worth doing it this way.
You gain a completely different closeness and a completely different sense of connection, a different fighting spirit -- everyone pulling together.
That's why I think it's crucial to decide for yourself: what kind of leader do I want to be?
And I decided at the time to act this way, and honestly I haven't regretted it so far.
Thank you!
Thank you!
Perhaps, if you'll allow, to close -- a bit on the market environment and competition.
One or two perspectives on developments.
You've already shared some thoughts on how productivity and so on will evolve.
Perhaps as a starting point: what can a Revolut do that an Atruvia never will?
Well, firstly, we're comparing a bank with a technology provider.
But they also do it somehow -- the technology, without me knowing what Revolut runs in the background.
I'd say what you have to address is: with us... speed.
I'm personally a huge fan of speed.
I remember when I came into the group, into the cooperative banking world.
Of course I had many introductory meetings, and one of the bank board members said something like: we're not exactly the fastest!
That can be an advantage, but it can also be a disadvantage.
One thing or another has also saved us from big mistakes. We just take a while to get going.
And I think that's something you do have to accept and understand.
We have our governance structures, the way we're organised.
And you first have to get over six hundred banks to agree on a common path, with the various regional structures, the associations and the various cooperative partners.
And getting to a sharp common denominator, so to speak --
it's certainly something that holds us back in today's world. Because while Revolut can scalably
just say: I'm doing this tomorrow and in a few weeks it's simply live --
we have mechanisms we need to go through, various committee processes, resolutions, before something even stands as a decision in the group, and only then can you move to implementation.
So
the reason I brought up that example was really more along the lines of... You said it's your conviction that the bank adviser will always be needed.
Not for making a transfer, but for the things you've described.
Now the question is: how rapidly do those things get automated, standardised, even anonymised with... I mean, there's no --
every day I walk through some airport corridor into some aircraft
and can barely escape the Revolut and Chase advertising billboards -- something neither Volksbank Raiffeisenbank nor any Sparkasse is doing.
So you notice a serious aggressiveness in clearing up that market. And with a technological speed that works against the structures which exist not just at your end --
it's the legacy systems at the big banks, and it's the financial IT in the Sparkasse construct.
Does that worry you?
And how do you try to counter it?
Or do you say no, it's actually a different battlefield...
No -- ultimately we're all competing for the same customer.
You have to say that.
And the question is: who succeeds in gaining access to the customer interface?
And crucially, not just gaining access but staying there.
And I think that's another difference you see with the players you mentioned.
Yes, the funds flow there.
The question is: do the funds stay there?
And of course it's cool as a gimmick to quickly execute a securities order or some sort of transaction, and that's one thing.
The other is what I'll actually need from my bank going forward.
And I believe customer behaviour is changing and customer segments are changing.
There are several factors I think are crucial.
For the standard business, for the purely transactional, the classic retail base -- that's not where we'll make the money.
What's interesting though is that everyone on the IT side is still investing heavily in this area.
An astonishing amount!
But at the end of the day it's pure hygiene -- it doesn't differentiate you going forward.
So to look again at where I can really make a difference -- perhaps in the wealth segment, at the corporate client interface,
but as I said, in those special life events where I can truly set myself apart.
Where I offer advisory services and, in inverted commas, offer them for free --
of course, it may result in cross-sell and upsell. Making a difference in a special moment in someone's life that perhaps stays with them.
So they say: it's worth it for me.
That's why staying there, not... You know, I don't have to look far --
I'm speaking about
myself.
Or I even come back?
Or
I even come back.
Because my
day-to-day banking I can do at Revolut, but they won't finance my house.
And
so, exactly -- I'll be quite honest, something like Trade Republic.
I try out all these accounts and apps myself to know what the market is actually doing,
how they do it.
The account opening?
Brilliant.
One, two, three clicks and you're in, can start straight away. You always have to ask yourself: how clean is it from a regulatory standpoint?
But that's a different discussion.
But what happens when something doesn't work, or when -- for example, can you currently set up a joint account with one of these neo-brokers or neo-banks? Something simple like that. These are niche things,
but you do make a difference in that moment.
And especially when I have my mortgage, when I perhaps need to make an unscheduled repayment or need a bespoke arrangement.
Or when something simply doesn't work.
I think there's nothing more annoying.
Something doesn't work.
You try to get someone on the line and then you're communicating with this chatbot.
This chatbot doesn't give you the answer you want.
You're sitting in front of this thing, wanting to hurl it at the wall, thinking: this cannot be happening!
That's not what I need.
And I think precisely in those moments you can make the difference.
Yes, true.
Even Trade Republic was forced by the market to... That's why
they introduced customer service!
That was exactly the point. And there are so many other examples.
Klarna too, as we know -- the whole AI-driven approach in the forms they'd imagined simply didn't work.
They're returning to human advisory.
So that's why I say: the deployment of AI -- you have to look very carefully at where you use it and for what purpose.
Where can I realise efficiency gains?
But to believe I can replace a human one-to-one with it --
replace a person one-to-one --
I think that would be jumping to conclusions.
But to believe that I can use it to improve quality and, as I said, create that combination --
that's much more like it!
Thank you so very much.
A wonderfully engaging ninety minutes.
To the listeners: I'm also supposed to say at this point, please like and subscribe -- it really helps us. And do write in the comments, as people have been doing recently, who else you'd like to see here in this lovely studio at OMR.
To you, a very warm thank you -- that was wonderfully engaging and... really excellent!
Thank you!
Lovely insights.
Thank you for being here.
Many thanks.
I'd describe myself as an empathic person.
And I believe I can read my counterpart to some extent in the moment, to recognise whether someone is truly present or... is just saying
it. And when you notice that, how do you deal with it?
Are you more the proactively assertive type -- and I know assertiveness can sound negative, but it doesn't have to be --
or are you more the observing, passive type who lets things run first? Or does it depend?
I think it depends on the person opposite me.
I wouldn't describe it as one blanket approach.
I first want to understand why.
Mm-hm.
So what triggers
it?
Do you approach people about it?
Yes!
Definitely.
So actually -- I get the impression you nodded, but...
Exactly.
It's also that... especially in my direct reports, right?
That's also about my understanding of leadership.
Especially with my leadership team --
I often compare it to something like a family.
There'll always be the odd point of contention, but we always come back together and fight for the same cause.
And that's also very important to me -- that it works well in that way, and that I have the feeling we're all heading in the same direction.
And especially when I sense something doesn't quite fit --
I'll pick up the phone, or seek out another conversation. Listen in and ask the question: I'm just reflecting an impression back to you.
I somehow have the feeling we're not quite aligned here yet.
I sense something's holding you back.
Perhaps it's just my impression.
Perhaps I'm wrong.
But let's try to talk about it openly. And I try to make things discussable.
I think in many respects there shouldn't be any taboo subjects.
Especially in such large transformation processes, especially when you work so closely together.
A high-performing, capable team must be able to voice things that are going well, but much more importantly, things that aren't working.
Do your colleagues do that?
So -- how many direct reports do you have?
It's eight, did I remember that correctly?
Let me count myself.
One, two, three, four, five, six... seven!
Including you?
Then
eight.
Does it actually happen?
Let me think about that.
Can you share a sort of best practice -- if you want a high-performing team,
especially as a board member with your direct reports,
how should you organise yourself?
What does the governance look like? But also, what else do you do to ensure the team really is and remains a team?
Can you give us some insight?
Yes, so I've been with this team in its current constellation for about eighteen months now. And this is part of it too --
there have been some personnel changes, and I think it's important in a role like this to make sure you have the right companions by your side.
I believe that's essential, because it's also about mindset and, for me personally, about personal performance standards.
So the first piece of advice would already be: make sure you have a winning team that you're comfortable with?
Absolutely!
And especially when it comes to forming your team -- bring together like-minded people, and very importantly, distinguish that from people who are alike.
I don't want clones, for goodness' sake.
The more different perspectives, characters, capabilities and competences, the better -- that's what I think is crucial.
And especially on the topic of personnel decisions -- don't wait too long.
Right from the start, form a picture, understand what works and what doesn't.
Where do you need a change?
And I'd say: be tough on the issue, gentle with the person. That's very important to me -- always at eye level, where you can still look each other in the eye after the conversation, but have a shared understanding of the matter. I think that's crucial. So if there's one thing you should do at the very start of a leadership approach, that's definitely one of my absolute priorities.
If you think through your learnings and best practices -- what else would you say people should pay attention to if they want a high-performing team?
Well, I've just mentioned it -- the topic of diversity, different perspectives, capabilities, competences, people who've seen different things, who perhaps bring entirely different experiences.
A good mix of people who've been there longer and know the history, and those who bring a completely fresh perspective.
Getting that balance right... That's one thing. And another that I really want to underline:
people who give you their honest opinion.
People who deliberately say: that was all well and good, what you just said,
but I see it very differently.
I think it's important that we also look at this from a completely different angle.
I think there's nothing worse than losing yourself in your own self-satisfaction and saying: I know exactly how everything works.
And my perspective is always the best.
I think it's absolutely vital to hear other perspectives and to consciously avoid becoming resistant to advice.
Once you have the right people in place, and especially to bring those perspectives to life -- could you briefly outline how often you meet as a management team?
How much of that is operational?
What do you do that isn't operational but leads to exactly what you just described?
Can you share a few more insights?
Yes,
of course, happy to.
So we also have the classic routines -- our weeklies, essentially like a check-in.
How
long are those?
An hour, just under an hour.
So snappy, really
very brisk and brief.
What are the topics of the week?
Quick round-the-table: what's really current right now?
What's on your mind?
What do we need to know? Where do we perhaps
need to sync up?
Perhaps a look at the week ahead, what follow-up meetings are there, where do we need to align.
Those are the weeklies.
Then we have monthlies -- more time.
Always three to four hours where we go deeper on certain topics.
What you should know is that we do those digitally.
So weeklies and monthlies are digital.
And then there are the quarterlies, which are always in person over two days. We take time for strategic topics, for exchanging our thoughts and calibrating together.
I think it's also important to spend an evening together, getting to know each other as people outside the professional context.
I think that's very important.
I always say: one thing is knowing a person professionally; the other is what's currently going on in their private life.
And sometimes knowing that is almost more important in such close collaboration, because then you understand why a person is acting the way they are.
Because you should never forget: everyone carries a rucksack on their back.
Always.
And knowing that often makes it much easier to understand afterwards why someone reacted a bit more sharply, perhaps a bit more aggressively or dominantly, or is holding back.
There are different reaction and behavioural patterns.
That's why it's so crucial to try to understand the whole person.
Do you also allow them to see the whole of you?
Do you open up, or do you tend to close off? And have you ever had the experience that you opened up too much?
Or how do you handle it?
Yes... That's exactly, let's say, a fine line and a risk.
By nature, as I mentioned, coming from the Ruhr area, I'm quite direct.
I like to call things by their name.
I'm certainly someone who sometimes wears her heart on her sleeve.
And when something really preoccupies and moves me, I say so.
I also always start, when we have our sessions --
especially in the quarterlies, with a little check-in.
I say: on a scale of one to ten, where are you right now?
One is catastrophic, ten is brilliant -- and please explain why.
Perhaps privately and professionally -- what might be holding me back... Am I actually mentally present, or are my thoughts elsewhere and I don't want to engage?
Where are you right now?
Me, right now?
I'd say a solid nine.
This is fun right now!
The Solution Days are under way and I always draw enormous energy from them, so right now things are good.
And in those sessions, do you also share your own assessment?
I
do, I do.
And I'm happy to open up there too, and say what's really moving and occupying me.
Once more... If I don't
lead by example myself.
What was the lowest rating you've given yourself in the past eighteen months?
I've been down to about a two.
Oh!
What was going on at a two?
If you'd like to say -- you don't have to...
Oh, it can be various things.
It could be friction on the customer front.
But it can also be private things.
Or when something isn't right at home in the family,
I have to say...
That definitely affects me.
And do you share that with your colleagues?
So that -- leading by example, as you just showed -- it's important to open up.
Certainly!
Would you say it's simply important, in order to perform and deliver as a team, to have understanding for one another?
It's a question of trust.
Of course I also extend a great deal of trust.
I then naturally expect trust in return. Does it make you vulnerable and open to attack? Absolutely.
I've learnt over the years that it's worth doing it this way.
You gain a completely different closeness and a completely different sense of connection, a different fighting spirit -- everyone pulling together.
That's why I think it's crucial to decide for yourself: what kind of leader do I want to be?
And I decided at the time to act this way, and honestly I haven't regretted it so far.
Mm-hm,
thank you!
Perhaps, if you'll allow, to close -- a bit on the market environment and competition.
One or two perspectives on developments.
You've already shared some thoughts on how productivity and so on will evolve.
Perhaps as a starting point: what can a Revolut do that an Atruvia never will?
Well, firstly, we're comparing a bank with a technology provider.
But they also do it somehow -- the technology, without me knowing what Revolut runs in the background.
I'd say what you have to address is: with us... speed.
I'm personally a huge fan of speed.
I remember when I came into the group, into the cooperative banking world.
Of course I had many introductory meetings, and one of the bank board members said something like: we're not exactly the fastest!
That can be an advantage, but it can also be a disadvantage.
One thing or another has also saved us from big mistakes. We just take a while to get going.
And I think that's something you do have to accept and understand.
We have our governance structures, the way we're organised.
And you first have to get over six hundred banks to agree on a common path, with the various regional structures, the associations and the various cooperative partners.
And getting to a sharp common denominator, so to speak --
it's certainly something that holds us back in today's world. Because while Revolut can scalably
just say: I'm doing this tomorrow and in a few weeks it's simply live --
we have mechanisms we need to go through, various committee processes, resolutions, before something even stands as a decision in the group, and only then can you move to implementation.
So
the reason I brought up that example was really more along the lines of... You said it's your conviction that the bank adviser will always be needed.
Not for making a transfer, but for the things you've described.
Now the question is: how rapidly do those things get automated, standardised, even anonymised with... I mean, there's no --
every day I walk through some airport corridor into some aircraft
and can barely escape the Revolut and Chase advertising billboards -- something neither Volksbank Raiffeisenbank nor any Sparkasse is doing.
So you notice a serious aggressiveness in clearing up that market. And with a technological speed that works against the structures which exist not just at your end --
it's the legacy systems at the big banks, and it's the financial IT in the Sparkasse construct.
Does that worry you?
And how do you try to counter it?
Or do you say no, it's actually a different battlefield...
No -- ultimately we're all competing for the same customer.
You have to say that.
And the question is: who succeeds in gaining access to the customer interface?
And crucially, not just gaining access but staying there.
And I think that's another difference you see with the players you mentioned.
Yes, the funds flow there.
The question is: do the funds stay there?
And of course it's cool as a gimmick to quickly execute a securities order or some sort of transaction, and that's one thing.
The other is what I'll actually need from my bank going forward.
And I believe customer behaviour is changing and customer segments are changing.
There are several factors I think are crucial.
For the standard business, for the purely transactional, the classic retail base -- that's not where we'll make the money.
What's interesting though is that everyone on the IT side is still investing heavily in this area.
An astonishing amount!
But at the end of the day it's pure hygiene -- it doesn't differentiate you going forward.
So to look again at where I can really make a difference -- perhaps in the wealth segment, at the corporate client interface,
but as I said, in those special life events where I can truly set myself apart.
Where I offer advisory services and, in inverted commas, offer them for free --
of course, it may result in cross-sell and upsell. Making a difference in a special moment in someone's life that perhaps stays with them.
So they say: it's worth it for me.
That's why staying there, not... You know, I don't have to look far --
I'm speaking about
myself.
Or I even come back?
Or
I even come back.
Because my
day-to-day banking I can do at Revolut, but they won't finance my house.
And
so, exactly -- I'll be quite honest, something like Trade Republic.
I try out all these accounts and apps myself to know what the market is actually doing,
how they do it.
The account opening?
Brilliant.
One, two, three clicks and you're in, can start straight away. You always have to ask yourself: how clean is it from a regulatory standpoint?
But that's a different discussion.
But what happens when something doesn't work, or when -- for example, can you currently set up a joint account with one of these neo-brokers or neo-banks? Something simple like that. These are niche things,
but you do make a difference in that moment.
And especially when I have my mortgage, when I perhaps need to make an unscheduled repayment or need a bespoke arrangement.
Or when something simply doesn't work.
I think there's nothing more annoying.
Something doesn't work.
You try to get someone on the line and then you're communicating with this chatbot.
This chatbot doesn't give you the answer you want.
You're sitting in front of this thing, wanting to hurl it at the wall, thinking: this cannot be happening!
That's not what I need.
And I think precisely in those moments you can make the difference.
Yes, true.
Even Trade Republic was forced by the market to... That's why
they introduced customer service!
That was exactly the point. And there are so many other examples.
Klarna too, as we know -- the whole AI-driven approach in the forms they'd imagined simply didn't work.
They're returning to human advisory.
So that's why I say: the deployment of AI -- you have to look very carefully at where you use it and for what purpose.
Where can I realise efficiency gains?
But to believe I can replace a human one-to-one with it --
replace a person one-to-one --
I think that would be jumping to conclusions.
But to believe that I can use it to improve quality and, as I said, create that combination --
that's much more like it!
Replace a person one-to-one with it.
I think that would be jumping to conclusions.
But to believe that through it you can perhaps improve quality and, as I said, create that combination --
that's much more like it!
Thank you so very much.
A wonderfully engaging ninety minutes.
To the listeners: I'm also supposed to say at this point, please like and subscribe -- it really helps us. And do write in the comments, as people have been doing recently, who else you'd like to see here in this lovely studio at OMR.
To you, a very warm thank you -- that was wonderfully engaging and... really excellent!
Thank you!
Lovely insights.
Thank you for being here.
Many thanks.
She came to Germany from Moldova at ten. Her first days were spent in a refugee reception centre in Unna. Today, Julia Japec sits on the board of Atruvia, the IT service provider for cooperative banks. A conversation about what it means to lead in a world where AI agents will fundamentally change every role – and why empathy is the last competitive advantage (in German).
There was a phase during the supply chain bottlenecks where our customers were essentially ordering from three manufacturers.
From us and two competitors.
That was wearing me down!
Once the supply chains settle and materials start flowing again, the one who can deliver first will keep the order.
Right, let's get started then.
Hi Heine.
Welcome to Debugged.
Yes.
Before we begin, I've been reminded once more by OMR to encourage you, dear listeners, to please subscribe to and like the Debugged podcast -- it really helps us, whether on Spotify or Apple or wherever you listen to the podcast.
And now straight into it with you, Rainer. I always like to start on a somewhat personal level, which isn't difficult with you.
We've known each other for a few years, have had the chance to work together, and I know you have a passion for cars, even if it's a slightly different flavour than mine.
We were just looking at the photos.
My off-road vehicle is finally being finished after two years.
You drive classic cars, or do you also collect them?
Well, collecting
is a bit of an overstatement.
But I believe you have more than just one.
Yes, that's right.
How did you get into that?
Have you always had a connection to cars and engines, or when did it happen?
Well, on the one hand, after school I did an apprenticeship as a car mechanic.
So you really know your stuff!
Well, I used to.
That's of course quite a while ago now given my advancing age -- it's been forty years -- and so I've pretty much stayed with the older technology, since I only look after vintage cars.
But it's really more about the joy that these were simply beautiful cars from that era.
The design was beautiful; not everything was cut from the same wind-tunnel mould.
I simply enjoy it, and it's also a great way to clear your head.
Sometimes you sit in the evening searching for parts somewhere in the world for cars where parts simply don't exist any more.
And that's a nice way to unwind.
Do you have a favourite car?
Yes,
do tell!
It's my Austin-Healey Mark Two with a three-litre engine -- it's just a gorgeous design.
Do you
prefer just looking at it?
Do you prefer tinkering with it or driving it?
Or everything?
It's
actually a healthy mix of both.
I don't have some sort of collector's garage where you stash them away -- it's in a perfectly normal garage, you can't walk around it, you can barely see anything.
And when you take it out and the weather is nice and it's running, it looks lovely just sitting there.
Right, thanks for that.
Other things you enjoy doing to unwind.
You've been at Draeger since 2015, haven't you?
Is that right?
Yes!
So over ten years on the executive board, also responsible for Safety.
We'll come to that shortly.
Other things you enjoy doing for balance, things you simply enjoy as a person, Rainer...
Well, I have this commuting situation.
I only live up here in the north during the week, usually Monday to Friday.
And we're fortunate enough to live near Munich on Lake Starnberg.
And of course I have those balancing moments -- typically on a Sunday morning cycling around the lake.
That's a good fifty-odd kilometres, and it's simply the joy of clearing your head on the bike in this beautiful landscape, enjoying it even though it's always the same route.
It looks different every day.
The light is always different, regardless of the season.
That, for example, really gives me a lot. And besides that, I'm fortunate to be able to maintain a circle of friends that has been there almost forever -- people who have accompanied me through my life, and we've accompanied each other.
They've also ended up there, either in Starnberg or Munich... It's simply wonderful quality time at the weekend.
And
one can tell you enjoy it.
How do you manage to maintain that despite the commuting situation?
Is it a high price to pay, or do you say no?
Fundamentally it wouldn't matter whether I work twelve hours or ten a day in Munich...
It makes no difference during the week.
The week is intense, and for our friends too, things shift to the weekend.
They've chosen similarly intense careers. Sometimes I'd wish...
Oh, there's a birthday on Wednesday evening and we're all meeting at the pub.
That's something that just doesn't work for me because of the distance.
I do miss that, I have to be honest.
That spontaneity simply isn't there.
You have to plan it.
But otherwise, I'd say it wouldn't make a difference.
No perceived high price that you're paying?
Through the commute?
No, you can't really say that.
When I think back to the time when I was working in Munich -- there's a reason we live there -- and at that time, things were even more intense.
Nothing was possible at all.
So from that perspective.
I simply believe that... And honestly, I don't really think about what it's like.
I'm fine with it.
Understood!
Tell us about Draegerwerk -- just give our listeners a brief overview.
What is Draegerwerk?
Up here in the north you're obviously a household name, and for anyone who's perhaps taken a breathalyser test or a
drug test.
That's perhaps already a little spoiler.
But tell us, what does Draegerwerk do and what are you responsible for there?
Well... Draegerwerk is, let's say, a fairly large mid-sized company.
It's a family-owned group that is now one hundred and thirty-seven years old.
And it consists of two parts.
One is the safety technology division and the other is the medical technology division.
If we start with medical technology... Anyone who goes into a German hospital will encounter a great many Draeger devices in the intensive care unit.
So in other words, we'd rather not
see these devices?
Exactly!
We essentially make devices that you don't want to need.
You want them when you're not doing well.
So we actually make products -- and this applies to both divisions --
that save lives, that support lives that are on the edge...
What does that mean in practice?
Are those ventilators?
Exactly!
Those are ventilators, intensive care ventilators.
Sometimes people know the kind where you snore and get a little tube -- it's not that.
We only make intensive care medical devices.
That includes anaesthesia, for example, a particularly emotional and important area -- as I see it, that's where life begins.
And when life doesn't begin so easily for premature babies, the whole area of neonatal care, intensive medical care for premature infants -- things like that.
And around that, there's naturally a certain ecosystem -- the whole topic of patient monitoring, increasingly stronger networking, digitalisation in hospitals.
That's the medical side -- which is actually the somewhat larger division.
What does larger mean?
We're at around two billion in revenue in medical technology, and then in addition there's
the safety technology division, which also deals with what happens to the human body when it needs to breathe, or when it enters difficult environments where breathing might no longer be possible.
So what does that mean concretely?
Self-contained breathing apparatus for fire services.
Everyone has seen a firefighter.
They carry two air cylinders or usually one air cylinder on their back.
The entire breathing air supply including masks and helmets as a system approach, increasingly digitalised and networked to ensure the safety of firefighters.
Then there are large areas where we're talking about protecting plants and people during work.
For example, you protect petrochemical plants through gas detection technology that alerts to toxic or explosive gases.
If there's a defect somewhere and something leaks, plants are shut down, people are evacuated to safety.
And every person moving around such a plant also has a personal body monitor.
There's a gas sensor in it too, typically worn on the lapel, and it also triggers an alarm.
And it warns the workers on the plants to leave the premises and get to safety.
And those are the kinds of things we make.
And traditionally, all of this actually originated from mining.
That's where it all started.
That's also where the first ventilator was created.
So it all began, as I said,
one hundred and thirty-seven years ago.
Yes, that was around nineteen hundred or so.
And then the area of alcohol and drug testing.
Yes exactly, that developed because an alcohol testing device naturally contains a gas sensor.
That's the connection?
The fascinating thing is when you think about it -- there's medical technology for intensive care, and then there's gas detection technology with completely different customers, but the technological core that's behind it all is the connecting element.
So on both sides we understand what gases mean and what gases mean -- in a positive or harmful sense -- for the human organism.
Because, for instance, premature babies in incubators are fundamentally dependent on oxygen measurement.
So what oxygen environment do I provide?
It's the same thing of course when I say I'm sending a utility worker into a sewage plant, into some shaft -- then you need to measure whether there's enough oxygen or whether there are other toxic or explosive gases present.
And this technically connecting core element is really what defines the company, and around this technology, applications and products have been created.
Wonderful -- even I've understood it.
Thank you!
And so in safety technology, you said it's a bit smaller than medical technology -- meaning?
We're
at one point six billion.
So in total, three point six to three point seven billion across the group.
And you're world market leaders in some areas of safety technology?
Yes.
In which ones?
We're for example the world's largest manufacturer of self-contained breathing apparatus.
So if we take the
fire service segment... Our markets are extremely fragmented; it's always a patchwork.
And that's how it all adds up.
And if we look at the alcohol testing segment, there are those classic screeners you can buy yourself in an online shop and put in your car's glove compartment -- we're probably not the market leader there.
But if we take the evidential segment, so in the evidential area.
What does that mean?
Those are devices that don't require a blood sample, where the measurement is so precise and technically sophisticated that the results are admissible in court without a blood test.
That's where we're the technology leader, and through technology leadership we've also achieved market leadership.
Yes, you could put it that way.
We're also the world's largest manufacturer of intensive care ventilators.
It's always quite difficult to establish, of course, because our competitors don't publish unit numbers showing how much they actually produce.
It really first came to light during the Covid pandemic, when intensive care ventilators were in extreme demand all over the world, and nobody on earth could meet the demand -- that's when the production numbers finally became visible.
You could clearly see that this company up here in the north, in Luebeck, is indeed the world market leader when it comes to manufacturing and bringing such products to market.
Tell me, competitors.
Which are the most relevant ones?
If you can even pin that down?
You can pin it down fairly well!
So if we take the example of ventilation or intensive care therapy devices, there's a Swedish group called Getinge, GE with its medical technology division, Hamilton -- an American parent company with its main production site also in Switzerland.
Those are the classic players of that scale.
The same for your safety technology division, or different ones?
Those are completely different ones in safety technology.
There we typically compete against large American companies like 3M, Honeywell, MSA -- very strong in the fire service segment -- and in gas detection technology.
Those are the typical players we come up against.
I mean, the companies you've just mentioned are simply huge corporations that you're competing with.
How does a large German Mittelstand company manage to actually outperform them and be the world market leader?
Is it quality?
Is it price?
Is it luck, or what?
Well, that's always the question.
How do you define world market leader?
If I throw everything into one pot, shake it up and measure how much there is, then perhaps so.
But that doesn't automatically mean you hold that leadership in the US as well.
Of course -- let's take the fire service. We're absolutely clearly the market leader here in Germany, in many other European countries as well.
And from that you can say -- you can calculate it -- we know that we hold market leadership in Europe.
But that doesn't necessarily apply to Asia-Pacific, and it doesn't necessarily apply to the US either.
In the US we're number three, and certainly still with a considerable gap to number two.
Who is that?
According to our assessment, that's the company MSA.
It's shifting a bit at the moment... Are they
actually the same ones as the camping gas stove people, or are they different?
MSA is an abbreviation for Mine Safety Appliances.
Right, so they're not the same.
It's actually quite a curiosity if you look at it from an industrial history perspective, how it all came about.
It arose after the First World War, when American mine operators depended on mine rescue teams.
Mines couldn't be operated without the safety infrastructure.
That was already the case around the turn of the century, and after the First World War -- or let's say slightly before -- Draeger was the market leader in mine rescue equipment.
That's why mine rescue workers in the US and also in Canada are known as Dragermen.
The term exists -- there's no translation for it!
It's an established term, Dragerman, and with the prohibition on trading technology and conducting sales
after the First World War in the US, the mines could no longer operate because there was no longer a secure safety infrastructure, and on that basis, people in the US set about manufacturing spare parts for these products.
These are what's called closed-circuit breathing apparatus, with which the mine rescuers, the Dragermen in this case, then make their way into the disaster mine -- a truly highly demanding job, even today.
And from that, a new company emerged, which eventually became MSA.
So quite a nice anecdote about how it all came about.
It has a very long history.
Amazing! And who is number one in the US?
Oh, sorry!
That's still Scott.
They were sold to 3M at some point.
Now I believe they've been sold on again to Bain Capital, or parts of Bain Capital, if I remember correctly.
And yes... that's how things move around.
In Asia there are of course many smaller Asian players; there isn't really a dominant one.
If you take the really large professional fire services like Singapore, for example -- yes, they use Draeger -- but then there's always an interesting battle with the multinationals I just mentioned, because of course with the really large and professional fire services, we all always want to be there.
Everyone's striving for that.
Yes, and it's commercially attractive too, of course.
We do have seventeen thousand employees after all, and we want to offer them and their families a secure economic future.
Speaking of economic future -- you still manufacture a large part in Luebeck.
A relocation to the Czech Republic -- could you perhaps describe briefly when that started and to what extent? The value creation -- does the bulk happen here, or is it globally distributed in the way you've described?
So could you just briefly explain how you've currently structured your value creation?
What happens where?
Well, that's of course always... It's a journey that's subject to certain changes -- if you look fifteen years back at how you could position yourself and how things are today and how they'll continue in the future.
Let's start with medical technology, for example.
We still have large manufacturing sites in Luebeck; medical technology produces the intensive care ventilators there.
The anaesthesia devices are manufactured there, and the entire
neonatal area is produced there, and then for adjacent areas such as monitoring, patient monitoring and corresponding customisation to deliver the final application.
In safety technology, we do all the gas detection technology there, and that's where the core know-how resides -- this very specialised gas detection technology has very exacting requirements.
You can't simply replicate it if you want to achieve certain parameters.
It's a protected technology core there.
Naturally we then have the corresponding development functions alongside it, because keeping development and manufacturing close together makes a great deal of sense in these sectors.
And we also have a plant in England.
That's where, for example, the self-contained breathing apparatus I just mentioned is manufactured.
Exactly, that's where the bulk of that segment sits.
For mine rescue equipment, we're back in Luebeck.
Components are manufactured there.
In a plant like England, the depth of value creation is again quite high because we go all the way to manufacturing the breathing air cylinders, so
how shall I put it,
the compressed air bottles that go on the back.
We largely manufacture those ourselves there as well.
Then there are of course other portfolio elements that we simply procure.
But it's a diverse mix.
And how is that changing?
It's changing in that we see commoditisation in certain areas -- where products simply follow standards.
Take an example like mobile gas detection technology.
Mobile gas detection, that body monitor I mentioned earlier... We sometimes call it a compliance product!
There are many countries in the world where longevity isn't so important; what matters to them might be cross-sensitivity, so you don't get false alarms, because if I get a false alarm in a mine, then people have to evacuate -- the same on a plant, people have to evacuate.
Those are all productivity losses, so you have to minimise that to some extent.
But the technology, even with simpler products, is increasingly moving towards dampening that so there appear to be fewer false alarms from competitors, which leads to cost pressure through this commoditisation.
Price pressure emerges first, and then we come under further cost pressure, and naturally manufacturing such products at high-wage locations -- they lose attractiveness, let me put it that way.
How much of your portfolio is that?
How much would you say are commodity or commodity-threatened products compared to those where that's not the case?
Well, firstly I don't have a clear analysis of that.
It's more prevalent in safety technology than in medical technology, I'd say.
And when I look at safety technology, it's the classic elements that you'd commonly consider as occupational safety.
So PPE -- Personal Protective Equipment.
That often already moves into mass production at competitors, but we always try to differentiate on a different level.
We place value on higher protection.
It's how we design our filters, how we develop them -- the ability to absorb very specific substances.
And we still try to differentiate ourselves there, but with these complex products in the Asian market, they say: as long as it ticks the box!
How much do you produce today?
In safety technology, in the Czech Republic?
And how much in Luebeck?
Honestly, I don't know the revenue split because the plants aren't measured by revenue.
It's unit numbers.
And when I talk about masks, for example -- those full-face masks that firefighters use with the breathing apparatus --
we only make those there, but I don't have the ratios.
How
many employees do you have in the Czech Republic?
In the Czech plant there are around four hundred, but it will increasingly grow. And it would also grow in the sense that we're no longer just talking about
having a production facility there.
We also need to think much more about -- and this is driven more by demographics --
how do I find certain qualifications where I'm increasingly struggling to fill positions here?
Certain areas in engineering -- the whole topic of lifecycle management in engineering for a product range.
We're now setting that up so that we transfer those functions along with the production lines.
Not transfer as in people from Luebeck going to the Czech Republic -- rather, we need to build up afresh there, and here we reduce headcount
by not backfilling positions. We've built a system where we use natural attrition, don't backfill here, and fill those positions at those production lines.
And in that way, we're gradually building up engineering capacity there as well.
Such locations are actually predestined for this, because since the early nineties -- whether it's Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia -- there have been strong automotive supplier ecosystems with production systems, and the associated engineering activities are widespread and feature in the education system.
So we can find the right people there.
You can see it quite impressively in practice.
The engineering know-how that now exists there is, I think, pretty much on a par with Germany.
And honestly, I come from a generation that studied after the transition, after the opening of borders.
A Czech mechanical engineer has always had an outstanding reputation, even before reunification, and it's the same in Poland.
They've always had excellent universities.
I do feel qualified to judge this, because I actually wrote my diploma thesis in Krakow.
I'm fully convinced by these universities, and I continue to follow how these places develop.
It's remarkable, and I mean, there's no debating what growth rates Poland is achieving and with what level of structure the country is managed.
I have the greatest respect for that.
Can
we learn anything from them when you look at it like that?
The question is always: does one actually want to learn?
I think that's always the question of willingness.
Of course you can learn something.
But what do I actually observe... what do I personally note in a broad observation of the whole model?
They have a high degree of systematism in their approach.
They connect elements, and there's also a certain drive.
Young people who all want many things.
A good education system, culturally always at the forefront.
But there you go, those are things.
I'm not even sure if you'd call it learning -- perhaps some of it is simply... Perhaps there's also a recovery.
You have to consider that this kind of pioneering spirit and building up hasn't existed in Germany in that form.
And I'm not just talking about the post-war period, but the generation, the golden generation that we live in, fortunately still, even if things have become a bit more arduous.
But the last thirty years -- I mean,
how could it have been any better?
True!
Good point. You --
I
started on the executive board for supply chain.
For the entire group, it was called Chief Supply Chain.
And then you took on safety technology as well?
Exactly, we restructured and have just changed the model.
Did
it... So if I see it correctly, you then had
for the first time a full market responsibility as someone who probably had strong competences in production, lean, logistics, supply chain -- was there a learning curve in marketing and sales for you?
Or was it straightforward?
Or where did you have to make a leap, where you also thought... Damn, it might have been good to have known that before.
Do you know what I mean?
Yes...
So let's start with the first part of the question.
This learning never stops, even today.
Because we're so incredibly diverse in our customer groups, technologies, and applications, we also face the challenge that when you look at go-to-market models, there's no one size fits all.
So we need to be very diversified with different sales approaches to match how our customers want to procure, or find
it valuable to have a Draeger product.
Could
you pick out two or three extremes?
How does, say, the fire service procure?
How does perhaps the gas sensor industry procure?
Just to make it tangible, what the differences are.
With fire services, it's very typically a tendering process -- in Europe, European procurement law.
That naturally requires being very close to the customer early on.
Very close to the customer is the whole topic of driving technological progress with fire services ahead of such tenders, because it's also important -- how do I create value from technology?
So it's not always just the customer's requirement.
I have this, I want to check the following -- when I buy a car.
It has a certain number of cylinders or a certain battery.
With us, that's a baseline topic.
You need that too.
But the really crucial thing is: how do I convey to a fire service today the advancement towards better protection of firefighters in action?
And that means we partly set up quite an expensive sales operation for this.
Because it works with indirect partners -- so-called fire protection specialist dealers.
Because a fire service doesn't just buy breathing apparatus in its procurement -- they buy hydraulic rescue cutters, hoses, axes, chainsaws, entire fire engines in all sorts of configurations.
And that means there's a dealer model.
It's also a very well-established dealer model that extends across the entire world.
And then there's the direct sales component.
We have that too, of course.
Where we operate a kind of key account management but together with the dealers, approaching fire services for example. You have that in hospitals too, but less so.
So those are different models.
In gas detection technology in industry, you naturally have large key accounts -- whether it's BASF, Bayer, or ExxonMobil.
Or whoever.
We approach them with a direct sales key account model, and then there are parts where the key account says yes, I'd specify Draeger.
Or whoever.
But I'll purchase through an indirect partner.
I hope that's not through you, because we buy everything -- gloves, eye protection, hearing protection -- we always buy everything from these distributors.
And so it's a relatively, let's say, varied model -- it's a mix rather than purely direct or purely indirect.
And that varies.
And
all of this globally?
All of it globally!
And you came into this responsibility in 2020.
You hadn't previously had active marketing and sales responsibility?
Did it come relatively quickly to you, or were there a few learnings where you said, I actually got a bit of a black eye there?
I thought that's how marketing and sales work.
Care to share?
Let me start briefly with the phase before my time at Draeger.
When I was working in Switzerland with a sensor manufacturer, I naturally had a classic COO role.
But the COO is always at the interface with sales -- the whole topic of order processing systems, production scheduling systems.
Always these interfaces.
That gives you quite a good view outward -- what are the customer's actual requirements?
What's happening at the customer's end, and what effect does it ultimately have on the supply chain?
I believe that most COOs who take on this kind of overall responsibility can build up a good perspective, looking out through that window, so to speak.
Do you always need to change things at the customer?
Tends not to be!
During my time at Baumer, we then acquired a large manufacturer for mechanical measuring instruments -- pressure, temperature, those kinds of topics -- the local market leader in India.
I led that acquisition process at the time.
And as it always goes, when you do that, you also have to integrate it.
So naturally I handled the entire post-merger integration.
And the crucial thing there was to immediately bring calm to the sales organisations.
And sales organisation in a subcontinent like India means bringing calm through a distribution structure -- because of course immediately it's: oh God, someone's bought this company.
What about us?
Us as dealers, who are also dependent on this manufacturer's lifeline... How do we get it back? And so I was very early into this sales integration.
How do we integrate this?
What forms of sales
are there?
Direct, or engineering sales in the IPC area?
I had no other choice!
Did I get everything right? Probably not. The advantage you have in a COO world --
you work a great deal with structured number-based analysis, and that actually helps in sales too -- the underlying analytics.
Simple things like ABC analyses, basic ABC structuring of dealers, how do I get orders flowing in?
And what makes us attractive to a dealer?
Being fast, having the right products, generating inventory turnover -- they don't want endless stock sitting around either, things like that.
So those were the beginnings.
Now I've gone on a bit of a tangent, but it all belongs to the story.
Later at Giesecke+Devrient, working with the large telecom providers -- I was CEO for the smart card division.
There I was of course already, as CEO, heavily and very early involved in the sales structures, because a Vodafone or a Deutsche Telekom -- those are such large volumes, or with credit cards, a Commerzbank or JP Morgan or whoever -- I need to get that into production.
So again there was this close link to the sales teams.
So that's where it started. And at Draeger, we then built the structure -- well, as a classic supply chain person.
But we'd already changed the structures so that we'd created a sales allocation on the board.
Every functional board member -- whether it was the R&D function, at the time we still had HR --
and in my case supply chain -- we each received and were responsible for a region of the world in the sales model.
That meant I was responsible for all sales and service companies for medical and safety technology in the Americas -- literally from Alaska to Patagonia.
And then you dive into the analysis, think things through, and above all you listen a lot.
First and foremost, you need to do a lot of listening -- what's actually happening in all this diversity?
How do customers behave, how necessary is it to make certain changes?
And to add to the question -- did we get everything right?
No, certainly not.
And there are points --
when I think back to the US today.
We then developed a go-to-market strategy for safety technology as well.
We wanted to move away from the really large distributors because we felt their business model was very opportunistic.
And does such a distributor actively sell for a smaller company -- if I compare us to 3M?
Not really.
There's more of a catalogue, and you're on page sixty-seven with your products, and there are products they absolutely want to have, which they then put in the catalogue.
And we didn't value that active sales approach because we didn't feel we were being treated well enough -- and I in particular.
We committed more strongly to mid-sized distribution partners and moved away from the large ones.
Well, that didn't really work, did it?
You just have to acknowledge that.
Those are typical learning phases where the market power of these large ones... You can't escape it!
And then you changed the model in 2020.
So you reversed that dual responsibility you described.
Would you generally say there are phases where dual responsibility on the board -- for a function and a sales region -- is a smart thing, or is a learning from that
that it was a good idea but perhaps shouldn't be done as a general rule?
Can you share anything with the listeners there?
What are the structural advantages and disadvantages?
It's naturally an individual question for each company, and I always hold back a bit from making sweeping statements... How
was it at Draegerwerk?
What would you say was the reason you changed it again?
Well, let's say it was essentially that we made the assumption, through our growth ambitions,
that a different model would achieve the goal.
Behind that is... behind that is the fact that we have divisional responsibility.
The group's governance today is based on a relatively simple principle.
That means there's a Medical Technology division and a Safety Technology division, both have a P&L, and the sum of those respective P&Ls equals the group P&L.
Anyone can look that up in our annual report.
It's clearly described there, and it's relatively simple.
I found the organisational form as it existed, with this separation --
now I was of course also the CSO.
It had the advantage that in the region I was responsible for, I had very good control over managing the entire logistics chain, order processing and production scheduling, right through to the sales territories.
That naturally has a certain appeal.
I saw advantages in it.
But does it always apply to all other areas or regions? In Europe, for instance, where we're simply stronger and larger, the need to do that might not be so great.
So it had good justification during a certain phase of the company's development on this long journey, and also achieved good results for that period.
The switch to the divisional structure also has advantages, but sometimes also a few disadvantages.
There are never advantages without disadvantages, I believe.
We're of course very clear in what we do.
Especially when you think about the capital markets.
I believe this kind of organisation is also more intuitive on the capital markets side, for analysts, because in many facets there's a
business unit
and it has clear P&L responsibility.
There are two people who have this P&L responsibility.
That's my colleague in medical technology.
And I'm in safety technology, and there are two faces you can talk to and place your feedback with.
So you took over in this function in 2020.
Bang -- three months later, Covid.
Revenue inevitably exploded.
Partly.
That would interest me shortly.
Let me frame this in the bigger picture -- at least when you look at your P&L over time.
It looks quite interesting, doesn't it?
Because then after Covid there's this sudden upward pull, and then there's 2022 -- such an odd year.
Honestly, let me elaborate in a moment!
And although you pursued -- or still pursue -- a growth strategy, we might come back to that, the growth was, I believe, a CAGR of three per cent over that period.
But perhaps I'm remembering wrong.
But the EBIT has risen dramatically from around four per cent to now nearly twelve per cent.
Yes, let's just look at safety technology.
So if you trace the safety technology story through these numbers -- or what happened during Covid, what then suddenly happened in twenty-two?
No growth, EBIT drops back, and then twenty-three, twenty-four, twenty-five -- you don't grow massively, a bit, but the EBIT shoots up.
Was that strategy, was it luck?
What's behind it?
Yes,
what's behind it.
Let's start with the Covid period and what actually happened.
If you look at the group level, it's naturally fascinating and was also under public scrutiny -- everyone was watching, then there are these profiteers and it's all terrible.
Profiting from something -- I don't find that so terrible honestly, because there was a very particular necessity.
People were dying; everyone can remember the images from Bergamo.
We know, for example, that in Italian hospitals
they connected three or four people to one ventilator, one infecting the other.
I
think we all found that horrific.
It's dramatic, and anyone who managed to get hold of a ventilator during that time, wherever it came from, could count themselves fortunate. A great many people survived thanks to Draeger ventilation technology.
And the ability to triple production within the shortest time, so...
What does that actually mean in unit numbers?
Triple -- what was before, and what was three times that?
We don't disclose the unit numbers.
Shame!
And this situation naturally also led to higher revenue.
But what was ultimately finite were ventilators.
What was definitely not finite were financial resources.
Financial resources, specifically those of the buyers -- hospitals.
These financial resources were reallocated.
So whoever put their entire budget into ventilators simply didn't buy anaesthesia equipment any more, and they didn't invest in neonatology either.
And when you look at the individual financial years you mentioned, that's exactly what showed up in a single period.
Revenue up, results up... The delayed effect being that when Covid fortunately ended, there was complete oversaturation in the market for intensive care ventilators.
So in the following years, you don't buy as many ventilators -- the shelves are still full.
Anaesthesia then had a catch-up demand for the first time.
So this dip actually came later.
And that's the thing -- when you put it in perspective and just look at a single financial year,
then in a long-term model like how hospitals operate or how the overall market functions, you can't really capture the perspective properly.
Right, now let's switch to safety technology.
Oh yes, safety technology.
I already said at the beginning: we work in occupational safety. People stayed at home.
Many production operations scaled down.
So occupational safety went down too, with one exception -- that was respiratory protection with FFP masks, because they became necessary in the private sector and in all other areas.
That's not quite right -- it wasn't just the private sector, but also much more than previously in occupational safety. At an assembly line of a car manufacturer, for instance, you had to wear masks because of distancing.
So demand naturally went up significantly -- we all know what happened.
So the question I asked myself was: how do we compensate for this?
Yes, we have FFP masks, but those are small production lines -- one in South Africa, one in Sweden.
They were designed to protect mine workers -- gold mines in South Africa.
In South Africa they use Draeger FFP masks, and that's where it comes from. Not scalable to any volume that would have been useful.
Given that size constraint, what do I do now?
On one hand, revenue is dropping, and then I remembered... In terms of timing,
so we're talking about 2020?
That was relatively early, 2020 -- must have been around March, April, right?
Then I remembered my time at Giesecke+Devrient.
Everything in a working life always has connections.
Back then as CEO for the smart card division, I'd always thought -- even from my student days -- this semiconductor industry, when you're in production or similar, it's really demanding.
I always had great respect for that.
These short cycles, these high investments -- if utilisation isn't right, I always had enormous respect for that.
Then I started at Giesecke+Devrient.
For the smart card division -- SIM cards, credit cards, essentially also identity documents and so on.
But where volume matters were concerned, that was a different area.
At our peak, that was about nineteen factories in roughly fourteen countries that I was responsible for, if I'm remembering correctly.
They had similarities in their equipment, but they were never exactly the same.
And when we had large orders, large tenders with short delivery times to fulfil that suddenly came flooding in -- and that does happen -- then a local factory was sometimes simply unable to ramp up that quickly.
That meant we dismantled machines at other sites and had them flown by aircraft.
Whether it was a chip implanter or whatever -- multiple machines, I always say -- and sometimes we flew them around the world to address bottlenecks in other factories.
So that reminded me of the speed with which we'd reacted through unconventional measures.
Dismantling here, building up there for a single order.
You do that when relocating a factory, but for individual orders it's rather unusual in industry.
And I simply recalled this flexibility model.
I said, shall we do this differently?
We'll try to place large tenders in the regions with the commitment of local manufacturing in-country.
And then I wrote a concept paper.
And at Draeger, as in many other companies of course,
we sell what we've developed -- that's a fixed system!
We're confident we can do it, we have enough engineers.
We'll manage it, and we're now going to sell something we don't
even have yet.
And then we first approached the US government with this concept for local production of a certain volume of FFP masks, with a corresponding ramp-up curve showing when this factory would start operating... and we did that and won the contract.
Yes, and then things got a bit hectic, naturally.
I had no machines, I didn't even have access to the material yet.
But the US government was able to help us there, because through a law... we obtained national industrial priority for material procurement.
That still existed from the Korean War -- laws still valid in the US today -- and so we were able to secure the material.
We found production halls near Pennsylvania, converted them, and then had complete production lines built in Schwaebisch Hall for a lot of money, shipped them over, and then started manufacturing on schedule.
We did that three times.
I'd set myself the goal of perhaps managing five countries.
Well, let's just say I was pretty spent by the end -- it was intense.
Deep down, I was actually quite relieved it stayed at three countries, because it was quite a push.
Equipment we didn't have, materials we didn't have,
employees we didn't have -- ramping all of that up.
Walk us through the timeline once more, Rainer -- from the decision or your initial thoughts,
March/April 2020 to masks being produced in Pennsylvania?
I'd say I was always in the thick of it, still pulling the strings.
If I remember correctly, the production lines must have started in early 2021.
So that was about nine months.
Six months was the plan.
Yes, I think they must have been...
Perhaps it was already around September, but I can't remember exactly off the top of my head.
But the scale -- a complete factory, and these aren't small factories.
They're not small.
Yes, not small. We had
about a hundred and twenty employees working in one of those -- all highly automated. And yes,
looking at safety technology then, the consequence was that in twenty-one
the bet, in inverted commas, paid off. It was very successful, both in terms of growth and EBIT.
In England and in France.
We replicated it in exactly the same way there.
Germany showed less interest, for the reasons now well-known in hindsight -- why they didn't want to invest in domestic production. Yes.
So what happened in twenty-two?
You -- and forgive me if I'm putting it a bit bluntly -- but you essentially delivered a zero-EBIT result with one point four billion in revenue.
So what happened?
Blimey!
It was all hands on deck, so to speak.
Self-inflicted, market-driven, or where did it come from?
What happened?
No, it wasn't directly market-driven.
The market was actually alright -- we had full order books.
It wasn't as if we didn't have orders.
It wasn't golden, but it was perfectly fine.
Then the supply chain crisis hit.
That really, really hurt us.
Not just us, but our competitors equally.
They weren't much better off.
If we take certain product areas, like stationary gas detection technology.
Just as an example.
A high-margin area for Draeger where we have an outstanding reputation, where you're always invited to the table.
Where Draeger is always part of the enquiries, whether we keep all the orders or not -- and there, we were simply unable to deliver.
We were unable to fulfil orders.
And
could that have been avoided?
Do you say to yourself today: I could have done this or that to prevent it?
I believe with long-term preparation and the learning curve from that period, one is better positioned today. Could it have been avoided given the same level of knowledge?
But I
don't believe so, because everything is always based on a certain level of knowledge, and on that basis --
we used those lessons to do things differently, so that something of this scale wouldn't happen again today.
What did you change?
What specifically is
different today?
Let me go back briefly and explain why things would be different today.
The products we produce in safety technology are in the market for a very long time.
That means such systems are installed and in place, and the consequence is that the innovation cycle is longer than, say, with a car where you get a new model every five years.
That's not the case with us.
The consequence is that the design principles that were originally developed are certification-relevant.
Such products must comply with
certification criteria.
This certification process takes a very long time.
Twelve months can easily pass, and an electronic component that's in short supply --
just changing it on the circuit board because I say I have a substitute and can use the other component --
that largely requires a new certification.
And this re-certification during such a supply shortage makes no sense.
You can't manage it.
So what insight did that lead to?
Development principles -- how we change the certification criteria to allow more degrees of freedom in the substitution model.
We did that, which means the new generations of products or redesigns follow a different set of criteria.
We're more flexible in substituting components... It's not unlimited or one hundred per cent, I should say, but it makes things easier.
Then there are the classic themes -- different inventory situations.
We have much better transparency on bottleneck components, and also on second and third source options.
That's been handled structurally so that we're certainly in a much better position if something like that happens again.
After that flatline experience in twenty-two,
you managed to dramatically increase the EBIT in safety technology.
Looking at it from the outside?
What would you say were the key levers?
How was that achieved?
Previously always around four or five, then twenty-two was dreadful, and now nearly twelve.
That's naturally a whole bouquet of measures.
I believe the first and most important thing is always: do I acknowledge this problem?
In that context, we could have said: well, that was just a bad year, and after that it'll be fine again.
No.
We committed to many... May I
follow up on that, Rainer?
Is that an attitude thing where you say: listen, if you want to be successful, the most important thing is truly having total accountability -- do you see it that way?
I would clearly say yes. That's how I see it, though not everyone has to see it that way.
Because if I don't acknowledge things as problems, they simply fall off the radar completely.
Yes, because we all have a somewhat human tendency towards idealisation, looking for blame elsewhere, and so on.
Is that something you... Have you trained yourself to do that?
Were you raised that way, or have you always had it?
Have you said: no, it's on me?
No, I haven't trained myself in it.
If anything, unconsciously.
It's perhaps just how I'm wired, I don't know.
It's like driving a car -- when we're racing and I can't get through on the right, I have to go left; the main thing is I get past.
I have to do something.
Maintaining the status quo just isn't really my...
So that means acknowledging the problem without excuses?
Exactly!
And that's the very first thing.
At that point we had revenue of around nine hundred and fifty million, and have since grown organically to one point six billion.
That's correctly analysed.
Four and a half per cent EBIT!
We spend money on development, and not a small amount.
We're based at a high-wage location with large parts of our organisation.
That cannot be sufficient in the long run, and this company is of course fundamentally designed for the long term -- to create a stable foundation. Getting by in this industrial segment with four and a half per cent EBIT just doesn't work.
That's always been the fundamental problem for me.
Then came the blow in twenty-two. And these blows are so brutal when you don't already have a robust system in place.
I always talk internally about robustness.
With four and a half per cent EBIT, any crosswind from something going wrong
and I'm at zero -- and that's not a world I'm comfortable in.
So we started to change things in a structured way.
That was the first thought.
And look --
today I look back on it with a bit of a grin -- that was my first record.
Yes, the worst result ever!
An absolute record for the worst result ever.
Great start.
Ugh!
So that was twenty-two, right?
And from that worst-ever result, there are typically two options.
Now I also came from a world where you restructure McKinsey-style, where you say right, we need to take a hundred million out of costs, and somehow it works, and you squeeze here and bend something there, and yes, you're in the newspaper, but unfortunately you also have to let a whole lot of people go.
We made a very deliberate decision against that, because we believed -- and I know this well.
And I must say, here Stefan Draeger comes in, with the knowledge of this company's inner strength and the resilience that comes from the employees' conviction of creating high value through technology for life.
We used that and built on it.
We motivated the people.
It started with us first raising the topic of pricing during the allocation phase of twenty-three.
That means we achieved a significant portion through better prices in this shortage environment.
They still need to be competitive, because ultimately it's the market price that decides.
That gave us some breathing room.
We used that breathing room to change and improve internal structures.
These supply chain --
Were you
also worried that this pricing strategy would lead to
losing customers, that it would backfire completely?
No, I wasn't worried about that!
Fear wasn't a factor there.
Quite the opposite -- it was a deliberate and desired calculation.
Because who gets dropped first? The ones with consistently poor prices.
And let's call it -- it sounds a bit harsh --
but it's also a clean-up in sales. If the market price is the market price,
then why do we actually have poor prices in certain parts of this market?
Perhaps I also have a problem with certain sales individuals who have perhaps got a bit too comfortable.
So it shook things up a bit, and today we're in a sustainably much better position.
We have structured processes for how we manage price increases, and that continues to be successful.
Of course it then tapers off asymptotically -- at some point you're back at the market price.
Those were such things, and quite the opposite --
I thought it was good. The customers also want to make money.
Then we naturally built up internal structures, and from that point the collaboration came together.
Together we then positioned our model in a strategic approach, because the team, all the employees, saw the success.
It works -- and if I remember correctly, we turned the result from zero to roughly one hundred million EBIT.
So that was a genuine turnaround.
We went from zero per cent EBIT to, I believe, nine, nine and a half, something like that.
With previously only four and a half over many years, you can certainly call that a turnaround.
And what I'm especially pleased about is that we did it in a socially responsible way.
We didn't have to let hundreds of people go.
So
one lever was pricing, among others -- structures, cost structures,
speed, delivery capability.
Now I need to briefly explain something else. There was a phase during the supply chain bottlenecks
where our customers were essentially ordering from three manufacturers.
From us and two competitors -- that was wearing me down during that phase.
My hypothesis was -- I didn't know for certain, but it was my firm conviction that this would happen:
once the supply chains settle and materials start flowing again, the one who can deliver first will keep the order.
So it's opportunistic behaviour.
We had to be first; we had to cross the finish line first. And so we set up the entire allocation principle together with the whole supply chain.
In full task force mode -- and initially not everyone accepted that.
That was quite interesting at the start.
Starting in task force mode...
Yes, we come together, and then we'd need to visit the circuit board manufacturer or the assemblers.
Then we'll do it in four weeks -- and we're absolutely not doing it in four weeks.
We're calling them now, and we're heading there tomorrow.
That's how I know you!
Yes!
And that's exactly what we did, and the wonderful thing was... at some point it was no longer driven by me.
I'm always a bit of an outsider in a way, though I'm there every week -- but because of that it's always somewhat externally triggered.
And after two or three months, this behaviour changed among our employees and managers.
They developed this kind of can-do approach themselves... and it was actually fun for everyone -- not always, but quite often.
And with that, we crossed the finish line first; we kept our orders.
Very cool!
Well, the answers are sometimes a bit lengthy, but the subject matter is just so diverse.
How do you deal with behavioural patterns?
The technology is often already there.
Yes, alright, I don't have a certain component right now -- but how do I deal with that?
Can I get a new component in?
How do I need to test it?
How quickly can I test it?
Is a regulation, the way I've always interpreted it without pressure because I never thought further about whether it could be interpreted differently -- is it actually open to different interpretation?
We went incredibly deep and changed things at a fundamental level; we do it differently today.
And that emerged from this?
I hear two key success factors there, or rather let me put it this way:
two things stand out -- that you're essentially saying: speed is simply a competitive advantage in itself.
Absolutely!
And I always like to say: work takes as long as you give it time for.
Secondly, you questioned everything -- there are always shorter or simpler paths, and if you don't make the effort, it won't happen.
At the same time, looking at this phase from 2020 to twenty-five, your revenue hasn't grown as much as you might have planned.
EBIT yes, revenue
no -- why not?
I wouldn't entirely confirm that.
What is our fundamental principle in safety technology?
We say we want to grow at twice the market rate.
Our market generally grows at around four per cent.
That was roughly valid until -- what are we at now, twenty-six -- until the end of twenty-four.
If I may challenge that -- you're running at about three per cent; double the market would mean more.
Exactly, now let me get to that.
That's our strategic ambition level that we've set for ourselves.
Now in twenty-four we had to recognise that the market isn't growing that much any more.
Unfortunately.
I believe we grew four per cent, and we're seeing this through the decline in markets where we're particularly strong -- Germany or some other European countries, for example the chemicals industry or petrochemicals, taking a brutal hit.
Everyone reads the papers -- how many people is Bosch cutting?
Or VW?
What's happening in the decline of the German chemicals industry -- quietly, at a site in Ludwigshafen a workshop gets shut down, no one talks about it any more. Boehlen closes -- that was still visible. The plants go down and they won't be restarted. And that's one of our main customer groups.
We see that in occupational safety -- we've landed at a growth level of roughly two per cent, and the ratio still roughly works, as long as we don't also grow above that in costs.
We always make sure we stay significantly below cost growth.
That's also where the EBIT strength comes from.
It seems to be recovering a bit at the moment, because we've opened up new areas.
For example?
Take the maritime sector.
I can elaborate on that in a moment, but let me just finish this point first.
And this model still seems to work -- this growing at twice the market rate.
So we're actually quite happy with that.
And when I compare directly to our competitors, whether it's 3M --
they've also had a long period, I think they had internal restructurings too, they haven't grown much.
Honeywell hasn't grown much, MSA -- not much organically.
Look at organic growth, not through acquisitions.
Currently, taking the first half of this year -- and it hasn't slowed down in the third quarter either -- I believe we're growing at roughly twice the rate of our competitors.
Together, we in that group account for a significant share of the market.
So you can use that correlation to some extent.
And as with other things -- if one path is blocked, what's the next one?
Where are there opportunities, where is our market share lower, or where do we
believe there's potential? We identified thematic areas and positioned them strategically.
So we briefly touched on this -- is there, from all this learning curve, a build-up plan?
Of course we've built ourselves a strategy internally.
We're now roughly at the halfway point.
In twenty-three we said: by twenty-eight we want to have achieved the following. We have an internal medium-term plan, and we absolutely want to hit it.
And we've set certain targets that sit a bit above that, to provide a buffer when you cascade downwards.
But you need building blocks for that.
These building blocks don't come by themselves.
You have to define them, evaluate them, assess them commercially, and create the organisational preconditions.
What building blocks do we currently have?
Take growth in the US -- we talked about fire services at the outset.
We've developed a product, a breathing apparatus specifically designed for the American fire service market.
Positioning it, working differently through sales --
we're seeing good progress there.
There's a dedicated, targeted model behind it for the American market.
That contributes to the German side but is also embedded in a larger US division, partly because they're different teams.
Then there's the topic of defence.
We wanted to triple that -- from one hundred
to three hundred?
Exactly!
This tripling is another pillar in the growth.
Defence specifically -- what does that mean?
Customer products from a Draeger perspective?
Well, it follows exactly the principles Draeger has always had.
We protect life, and we also protect those who defend our freedom.
So anyone who's perhaps done military service will have seen a gas mask like this -- it's from Draeger.
For example, the entire filter technology. The crew compartment of a Puma armoured vehicle --
it's NBC-protected -- meaning protection against chemical, biological or radiological attacks.
The entire ventilation technology that goes into it -- that also comes from Draeger.
The whole filter system and filter technology.
Those are typical products we make, and in the strategy... Or to take another example -- the whole topic of combat divers.
Combat divers use closed-circuit breathing apparatus from Draeger. Not just our German combat divers -- the American Navy SEALs
use them as well, and those are typical defence products that we make.
And then it goes further.
Right at the beginning we talked about core technologies.
What core technology do we actually master?
And from that, certain problems arise -- I can't go into all of them here -- that are currently landing with us.
From that we develop solutions in future models or procedures that will find their way into the respective defence forces, and that's strategically positioned within the NATO environment.
So that's a sector that continues to grow.
Is that a bet you're essentially making?
Or are you at the table with NATO or NATO member states, products are discussed, there's an order, and then you develop and build? Or do you have to develop, build, and hope someone takes it?
It can be both.
The second part -- I make that dependent on whether someone pays for the development.
So if the development is funded, then of course we develop down that
path.
But we don't develop bespoke solutions and say, right, we've developed that now,
let's put it on the shelf and maybe someone comes along.
You're at the table together.
Exactly, it's a very close collaboration because... We need to integrate ourselves into the programmes of the major primes, whether it's Kongsberg, Rheinmetall, or KNDS -- we need to integrate as
component and sub-system suppliers.
It's a very close engineering exchange; it can't work any other way.
Of course, once a gas mask has been developed or the corresponding NBC filter for it, that's managed through call-offs.
That's naturally a bit like a commodity.
Then.
Tell me, is there actually a tension there? Because you're listed on the TecDAX, but nearly three-quarters is still family-owned.
Is that right?
Yes, it depends on which class of shares you look at.
From what I've seen, a large part -- whether it's seventy-five per cent or so -- of the shares and ownership still belongs to the family. And watching Stefan Draeger over the years, I believe profitability and stability matter more to him than growth.
Is that the case, or is there a contradiction when you say growth is also important to you?
I don't think he draws such a hard line.
Because he knows very well that growth is a condition for us to also look forward to profitability.
And honestly, with the setback we had in twenty-two -- having delivered the worst company result ever -- we've of course repositioned things, clearly steered by him personally, towards certain corporate objectives that focus on profitability or prioritise it to a healthy degree.
That really moves to centre stage, and growth is necessary for that.
So the strategy going forward is essentially profitable growth in the existing fields,
continuing to drive efficiency, including relocating commodities to sites that can handle them, keeping core competences in Luebeck and Germany, and then looking for fields like the defence sector to participate through close partnerships with the platform providers and suppliers.
Now we looked at the cultural factors.
Why do people enjoy working at Draeger?
Because they apparently do -- I believe your average tenure is twenty-plus years. Is that more of an asset or a burden?
Two questions at once, but you know how to handle them.
That question does come from someone who's moved here.
Yes, so why do people enjoy working with us?
The company has a... We have a tagline.
Draeger -- Technology for Life!
We turn technology into technology for life, and that gives our employees a truly deep sense of purpose. All our products that we make --
I can't think of a single one that doesn't.
A deep sense of purpose.
Going back to the breathalyser test -- no road fatalities or serious injuries through safer roads.
That has a profoundly meaningful purpose; the same goes for drugs. In an intensive care unit --
when you see a premature baby today that can survive at as little as two hundred and thirty grams -- it used to be two hundred and fifty. That's engineering excellence with a truly deep sense of purpose.
Once someone is at Draeger, that apparently fascinates them.
We run a global employee survey every two years, and that always ranks very highly.
We know what motivates people because we do this continuously every two years across the entire workforce in every country. And those are typical themes.
And then one mustn't forget -- why do people also stay for a long time?
We're a very good employer in every respect you can imagine.
Sports groups... We genuinely have on-site childcare.
We have special units for when there are family difficulties, particularly with ageing parents.
We have programmes for that.
So there's everything around it that also makes life worthwhile in an intensive professional context.
That's genuinely outstanding at Draeger, in my view.
So that's one part, and then there's another.
We're of course an industrial company -- we're the largest industrial employer in Schleswig-Holstein.
That naturally follows certain structures -- in this case, we're clearly a company with trade union organisation, with the corresponding salary structures and all the social benefits that come with it.
In a region that's beautiful, with the Baltic Sea, high recreational value, perhaps also offers housing that isn't dirt cheap but is affordable -- perhaps a bit different from Hamburg
or Munich.
And all these elements come together, which is why, in our assessment, we remain a popular employer.
And as I said, no advantages without disadvantages.
I'd sometimes wish for a bit more external mixing and a slightly higher turnover in some areas, because it's not always productive -- you can see that in yourself.
You don't even need to look at others.
If you work on the same thing for too long, it's not always creative.
Do you recognise that in yourself?
Because you just said so.
Can you remember a specific instance?
Yes, you do have those moments.
Nothing specific springs to mind immediately, but I do notice it occasionally -- where I shake myself and think: why am I being like this again?
That does happen, of course.
Have people ever left because of you?
You can't remember anything?
They don't
exactly tell you that.
Can you imagine... What I'd like to get at, in the Draeger context overall, Rainer, is: why do I enjoy working for and with Rainer?
And what might also annoy me about him.
Yes!
Oh yes, that's where an employee survey actually helps, because my direct team -- that's about eight people -- they also rate me directly.
And from those questions you can derive quite a lot. I believe what they really value is, let me say... I won't say this about myself; I'll say what came out in the employee survey -- that I have a very entrepreneurial way of acting.
And I naturally demand a certain standard, and by doing so I also advocate for my team. Now, my team is also set up to be an ambitious team, fortunately. And what they particularly appreciate is that I ensure the right conditions are in place for them.
Because really, my job is to create the conditions for the people around me to flourish, because they have the ideas, they can multiply the entrepreneurship. It's always about multiplication. And that's what they feed back to me as something they greatly value, along with the associated freedom.
So rather than being some sort of control freak.
I'm pleased when... No, it's more than pleasure.
Yes, I do want the feedback when things aren't working, because then we can look more closely and say: what's actually the problem?
Where has the thing got stuck?
So those are things that come up first.
And what probably isn't liked so much -- that's not in there at that level of detail.
I'm sometimes a bit absolute.
It can happen with me -- a mental drawer opens, someone goes in, and the drawer shuts again.
That's a certain absoluteness.
My wife likes to reflect that back to me, and I think that's
another example --
that side of things.
Yes, you can be a bit like Rumpelstiltskin sometimes -- very absolute when I want something.
Then I simply don't want it.
It's a matter of principle -- which is of course total nonsense.
Do you see it in the moment, or do you only realise it after the fact?
With sufficient feedback from those around me, I'm recognising it increasingly early.
I do know that!
That's an area where I'd say: yes, he could do with a bit of a softer touch.
Give me the last few minutes then, with a look forward.
We've talked a bit about strategy.
Of course, where you're setting priorities... What developments do you see over the coming years?
You can choose whether you're looking five or ten years ahead, but tell us: what developments do you believe are truly relevant for a company like Draegerwerk in the years to come, and where are you pursuing them? And what might that also mean for Germany as a business location overall?
Share your perspective.
Let me think for a moment, because it's... You can phrase the question briefly, but it has a certain weight to it.
I believe the crucial thing is to recognise within your own company where you have the opportunity to play at the front.
And playing at the front means somewhere in positions one, two -- and we might still accept three.
But after that it gets harder, I believe.
I think it already gets harder at three.
Because there are simply too many where I'm fighting too many defensive battles.
Where I can't just push forward as stringently.
Themes that will play a role from the market side include how connectivity develops.
What's happening in traditional markets, as they relate to us?
In hospitals, that's naturally a topic.
When it comes to connectivity and digitalisation in hospitals --
in the intensive care area, let's call it, there's still some catching up to do, but the industry standards are oriented towards it.
Industry standards are shifting.
I believe the added value that we can create there --
do we always need to invent the digital system ourselves, or can we build on something else?
I believe German companies are better served if they understand this system and can assemble it from certain elements that already exist in more digitally advanced areas.
And present that as market-ready.
I believe that can carry us forward well and with growth.
It's exactly the same in safety technology -- the whole connectivity theme.
There are very specific unresolved issues.
Nowhere in the world has any competitor solved them.
For instance, how do I make heat stress in firefighters measurable?
Body overheating that can lead to death after deployment -- making that measurable and reflecting it in digital models so these people are protected.
For us, those are typical themes -- connectivity
in combination with further technologies that create greater value going forward. I firmly believe in that.
Individually, one needs to look at whether there are transaction-based business models.
In this case, changing business models.
Do industrial companies always want to invest in a CapEx sense, or would they rather move towards OpEx?
What managed services can we provide?
That's something that's on our minds, and we already have good solutions -- we do that too.
Revenue contributions in safety technology that deliver that.
That's a classic managed service.
And then there are, let me simply say, bread-and-butter opportunities -- things where we say: we've left opportunities on the table, and there's still plenty there, and we need to react aggressively enough in the competitive landscape.
So those are -- I think that was four -- four models that I believe can deliver high value.
I haven't placed the employees front and centre in that just now.
But I'd very clearly position them too, because they're the ones who -- if we're able to give that direction, what do we actually want to achieve and why --
with a certain sporting ambition, they all get on board.
Nobody does the bare minimum, and this activation -- I always call it the power of the swarm.
Getting that aligned with the objectives -- I'm not worried about that.
Now of course I can talk cleverly -- we're not an energy-intensive company.
If I were running a glass smelter, I'd probably argue differently.
If you put this in context -- your contract runs until the end of twenty-eight.
No idea -- you don't have to answer whether you'd like to extend it or not.
Is there anything particularly important to you in this period, in this context?
At some point, whether twenty-eight or later, Rainer won't be here any more. What's still important to you to achieve or carry forward by then?
By then... That can't be pinned down so concretely.
Or what's important to you -- say, once you're no longer there?
That a Draegerwerk says:
Rainer left this or that behind, perhaps also culturally and structurally. Where you perhaps now -- I don't know if you do this -- when you can at least see the end, whether you look at things differently than perhaps ten years ago.
Well, how do I see it... How Draeger is built --
it's my fourth family-owned company that I've worked for.
First it was KSB in Frankenthal, then Baumer in Switzerland, then Giesecke+Devrient, and now I've been here for over eleven years.
And why?
That's my personal brand, so to speak!
I enjoy this form of larger family enterprise.
For me, it's a German -- it might sound a bit odd, but a German cultural asset.
It's the backbone of the German economy.
And what I do should contribute to ensuring it stays that way tomorrow too.
We provide work for many people.
There's an enormous amount of technological knowledge in there.
I'm an engineer at heart.
Yes, that's what matters to me, and when I eventually leave this company, whether in two years or five or whenever --
I want what I've done over this period -- I already mentioned robustness -- to stand robust, so that it doesn't collapse simply because a person suddenly leaves. And I don't believe in that anyway.
That somehow the whole thing tips over.
We have the advantage of operating in good, healthy markets.
Other companies unfortunately don't have that to the same extent.
And if we continue our model as we've now built it, with the ambition that's embedded in it,
then I'm not worried about Draeger's future, even many years after I'm potentially no longer there.
Because the thing is tidy and stands stable.
There are no brutal risks lurking somewhere in a balance sheet or similar.
For safety technology, it then stands stable.
That's the wish I have -- to eventually leave that behind.
It already sounds a bit like my own grandfather, but... Those are the things that drive me.
It's a family enterprise -- the value of families in German industry -- cherishing that, and after one hundred and thirty-seven years of Draeger, building it so that it prospers well for many more years.
That's a lovely perspective to close on!
That's a lovely perspective to close on!
Superb.
Thank you so much for being here.
Great conversation.
I knew it would be, even though you're not a podcast listener yourself.
Then I thank you for recording this one with me!
To the listeners of Debugged -- as always, feel free to comment on who else you'd like to see here.
There have already been some great suggestions that we've picked up.
Otherwise, do please like and subscribe.
I'm supposed to say that line at the end every time.
Thank you all, and Rainer, a very warm thank you for being here.
Great conversation. See you next time.
This podcast is produced by Podstars.
After school he trained as a car mechanic, and to this day he tinkers with his Austin-Healey after work. In his professional life, Rainer Klug is responsible for one of Dräger's most critical business divisions. He speaks about the year everything went wrong, how to rebuild trust after a crisis, and why hands-on leadership beats management theories (in German).
We assessed the risk regularly, and I believe nobody truly anticipated the scale of it.
Two days before the attack took place, a large delegation from the German government was also in Abu Dhabi, and even then the feedback was -- nothing's going to happen right now. At that point, there were twenty thousand German holidaymakers in the region, five thousand of them on our ships.
A warm welcome to Debugged!
Our management podcast covering strategy, execution, culture, leadership -- and I'm absolutely delighted to have you here today, Wiebke.
Thank you very much for the invitation, Matthias!
You've had a peek -- we already know each other.
Ten years, it must be.
Two thousand and sixteen, a digitalisation project at TUI Cruises -- a digital strategy.
A few days have passed since then.
Indeed.
Perhaps we'll also look at what role digitalisation plays these days.
Otherwise, I had to smile.
I looked into what drew you into the tourism industry in the first place.
You'll tell us a bit about that yourself in a moment, and what I found particularly fascinating --
you grew up on Helgoland, and as a child, you regularly got seasick on the Helgoland ferry.
But I got just as sick in cars and on buses.
So until I was about fourteen, I was regularly motion sick.
That's also
the reason I've never been on a cruise ship.
It might tempt me at some point, but my wonderful wife Bella has already flagged it. And my two children as well --
they get terribly sick.
The worst anecdote I can offer is that we once went whale watching in Monterey, California.
And when you look out at the Pacific... it always looks
so smooth, doesn't it?
Exactly!
Perfectly harmless.
And then there were options for two hours, four hours, or eight hours.
I thought, go for the middle.
I've never seen so many people being sick as on that whale-watching trip.
They were retching the whole time, and my family -- all just green and pale.
I don't know what it's like on big cruise ships.
Can you tell the difference, or do you still feel it?
That's a question everyone responds to differently.
There are certainly people who are very sensitive to any form of movement.
You'd still notice it even on a large ship.
But interestingly, for me, at around fourteen or fifteen, it stopped overnight -- the seasickness just went away. And today, on these large ships, even with quite a lot of wind, you barely notice anything.
They're built that way and have stabilisers to compensate very effectively.
So the wind plays a role?
The
wind plays a role!
And the swell plays a role.
So it varies considerably.
But the seasickness issue -- and setting aside my experience or yours -- we can see exactly how our guests react, and by now there have been quite a few of them, and seasickness is one of the very, very minor issues. It comes up very rarely.
If a ship does an Atlantic crossing or similar, things can get a bit rougher, and the Canary Islands... But those are always isolated voyages or perhaps a single day!
And then you're very quickly back in calm waters, so I'd say seasickness is genuinely no longer a limiting factor.
Right, so it didn't put you off going into this industry...
Not at all.
...or growing within it?
You come from tourism, and now you're obviously still in tourism, but a shipping line -- which is essentially what you are --
was it coincidence that you ended up here?
I believe you also enjoyed working as a tour guide.
So you really know this business from the ground up.
How did it come about that you're now -- I mean, you've been CEO for twelve years?
Yes.
Since October twenty-twelve.
Was that something where you thought, I'd really love to do that -- or did you stumble into it?
No, it genuinely just happened.
I've never had anything like a career plan in my life. Probably because of growing up on an island -- Helgoland -- where there were lots of day trippers back then.
In the seventies and eighties, I was always somehow in touch with tourism.
I was also always connected to the sea, because Helgoland is Germany's only island on the open sea, and it was a wonderful place to grow up.
But of course, the size -- or rather the smallness -- of the island also meant certain limitations, and so I had the urge to discover the world.
When did that come about?
It was there early on, but I think many Helgolanders feel that way, and it's perhaps also because, as in Schleswig-Holstein and other federal states where tourism plays a big role,
the summer holidays are only five weeks long and the autumn half-term is three weeks.
My parents ran the island bakery, so they were extremely busy during the summer months.
So we took our family holiday in the autumn, and by October we were allowed to have a say in where we went.
My brother and I -- where do we want to go?
Then we went on trips, and I think one thing led to another. But certainly, being on a small patch of island,
seeing ships come and go every day, and also having to travel ourselves for specialist medical appointments and the like --
travelling was just part of life from childhood. As was contact with the many people who visited the island as a holiday destination.
I'd already made friendships as a child with the spa guests, as they were called back then, and so I think it was just always there from the start.
And then I went to Hamburg, and after school I asked myself: what can I do to work abroad?
I went to a foreign languages school and actually wanted to consolidate my Spanish, and that's how I ended up in tourism through the profession of tour guide.
Fascinating, lovely!
There are quite a few exciting topics we can touch on today.
I always like to look at how the business actually works.
Perhaps we can explain that a bit.
Then a bit of strategy, and how the execution of these things has gone -- or hasn't.
And then it's certainly super interesting in your case, especially after the Hapag-Lloyd Cruises merger, from a cultural perspective.
I mean, you have two brands across three segments, all very different.
You've been through crises and enormous growth phases.
Most recently, both growth and crisis again.
I think there's a lot others can learn from that.
Try to explain, in inverted commas, for the uninitiated: how does the business model work?
Obviously everyone knows the TUI Cruises posters.
I think anyone who uses public transport to some extent can't avoid seeing your adverts.
Bring it down to basics!
Yes, I think one first needs to put this into context in terms of how the cruise market is generally positioned.
First of all, cruising is a global business. And the big volumes historically came from the USA.
I don't know -- anyone who remembers the nineties will probably think of Das Traumschiff -- Sascha Hehn and
co. --
but also of luxury offerings, of course.
In the nineties, very few people in Germany had actually been on a cruise.
There were already expedition cruises.
But Hapag-Lloyd Cruises already existed, for example!
Ticket prices were very, very high, and so when the market was opened up
by saying, let's simply build ships for specific customer groups -- and that already had scalability built in --
that began in the late nineties, actually, with our market companion AIDA, who really brought cruising into the mainstream here in Germany and said, we're essentially adapting the club concept for ocean-going ships. And then TUI Cruises waited a bit longer and came with a concept that positioned itself between the very traditional, more luxurious cruise -- meaning higher ticket prices --
and AIDA with the club cruise
at the other end. TUI Cruises positioned itself in the middle and said, we're doing a premium concept.
One that offers a great deal of comfort, drawing heavily on the experience of a very good four-star hotel holiday.
But we're not coming with a dominant theme or anything restrictive -- we want to create a platform that's open to many.
And what cruising has always offered -- even back in the nineties, if you look at the old BAT studies.
By Professor Opaschowski at the time,
who's still around.
BAT?
BAT -- the leisure researchers.
They used to present their research at all the travel fairs in Hamburg -- they still exist.
The Travel Analysis is also still around.
And these days it's Professor Reinhardt.
So you can still read up on how Germany travels.
And even back in the nineties, cruising was essentially the dream holiday.
A bit of the unattainable.
I check in once, unpack my suitcase, and wake up in a different port every day. I can wonderfully experience lands and people, see something new, and yet have the comfort that my home base is travelling with me.
And I think that sense of the sea -- provided you don't get seasick -- setting off and discovering something new every day.
But also the calm of being at sea, gazing at the horizon -- it's a very special atmosphere.
I believe it was always this aspirational form of travel, and with more supply
being created, demand naturally rose, and that was true globally,
but of course in Europe and here in Germany as well. Perhaps for some context:
some years ago, there were seven point six million cruise passengers worldwide.
Last year, it was thirty-seven point two million.
So you can see how it's developed.
In Germany, it's around three million
cruise passengers, roughly.
But in proportion to the question, it first needed genuinely new ships.
New platforms, the actual capacity
that also made cruising accessible and affordable for a broader customer base.
And then everything I've already listed -- what a ship can offer -- becomes scalable.
And the ships have become somewhat larger.
And as I said, Mein Schiff TUI Cruises started when Royal Caribbean contributed two ships that were renovated for the German market. And that's a very important aspect.
You need to know who you're doing this for.
Am I a US-American shipping line
with predominantly American guests? Then the programme and overall offering on board will look different from what you'd find in Europe or Germany.
Where would the core difference lie?
Well, I obviously have my own...
Everyone probably has a few images in their head, but it starts with the fact that Americans have significantly less paid holiday than we Europeans,
and in particular, we Germans.
That means holiday time is more compact -- three, four, five-day short breaks are very popular there.
But they also pack in a lot of experience density. And compared to a land-based holiday, that's still very good value.
I don't know who's recently holidayed in the US and seen how prices for land-based accommodation, hotels, or incidental costs have developed.
Cruising has an enormous advantage there, through the economies of scale. And then you'll easily notice that the ships in the US are larger.
The ports are generally larger too, and built to handle such large ships comfortably.
You get a variety of everything!
You have casinos, naturally.
On our ships, you'll find a few machines and a table where you can play blackjack, but we don't have a casino spanning an entire deck.
You find many American brands, but also wow factors like a FlowRider.
For example, Royal Caribbean has a mini surfing installation on a pool deck, or there's the North Star --
a platform, a kind of gondola that rises up for panoramic views.
They also have an ice rink where shows are performed in the evening, and those are the sort of differences.
So everything we associate with the USA as a travel destination, you'll find represented somewhere on these ships, and the communities interact differently too.
And ultimately, when I compare how important it is for Germans, for instance, to be outdoors,
to have fresh air --
a US passenger, beyond certain temperatures, prefers everything air-conditioned, and those are the kinds of differences.
But what you can leverage is:
you can design a platform, build spacious cabins, style them according to the target groups, and build a ship that covers as many holiday interests as possible.
Both opportunities for socialising, shared experiences,
and equally, spaces for retreat.
So
could you just take those two former Royal Caribbean ships and use them as they were?
Or did you have to extensively refit...
They were...
I wasn't there at that point, I should say.
My predecessor Richard Vogel positioned that brilliantly and chose this positioning together with TUI.
Perhaps a word on the joint venture.
How did it come about?
Royal Caribbean is today the most successful cruise operator worldwide -- not just by volume, but if you look at their overall success record. Driven by the fact that
how many ships do they operate?
In total, it's around sixty or even more.
I'd need to check the exact number -- it's more than sixty.
Ours are included in that count.
So... that's part of the joint venture. But back then, it was about thirty.
Of course, Royal Caribbean had, one could say, thirty ships, and even in two thousand and eight
we were already far enough along with digitalisation that anyone worldwide could have booked any ship.
Every guest.
But in the end, it's not always just about the hardware -- it's also about what surrounds it.
And Royal Caribbean always had, and still has, guests from Germany, but to really crack the number-one travel market -- which Germany was in two thousand and eight by global comparison. When you look at travel frequency and travel intensity, Germany still ranks in the top three.
Were you aware of that?
Absolutely. We Germans spend a great deal of money on experiences -- on entertainment, concerts -- but especially on holidays!
And the travel frequency in Germany is also higher than elsewhere.
So naturally, Royal Caribbean said: we've never found the right market access to understand what the German customer wants.
With an average ship size back then of around two thousand five hundred to two thousand six hundred passengers -- if you asked how many German guests you could find and how tailored the product, the on-board experience, actually was for this guest --
there were probably natural limits, and demand in the US was high anyway.
So Royal Caribbean provided two ships, and the first team around Richard Vogel and Frank Kuhlmann -- the CFO who's still with us today --
he was there from day one.
They then designed a product that was very specifically tailored to the German market.
Back then, the language barrier was also a big issue, because for German guests, being able to communicate in German on board was always a very important factor -- and it still is, though it's declining.
Where are we now?
In about fourteen years, that's changed.
We all know that from our everyday lives.
TUI, for its part, recognised that cruises are indeed a travel form that fits perfectly with the world's largest travel company.
But in that year, there was also the limiting factor of shipyards capable of building cruise ships, and that's how the joint venture came about.
And then the colleagues from the founding team converted those first two ships for the German market.
A bit as a test, because they said: the market research was always very clear.
The market can easily support it, but ultimately you have to experience it yourself -- in every sense of the word.
And that's what happened with two ships converted for German concepts.
An important factor was already having as many balcony cabins as possible, but also designing the outdoor decks so that you'd want to spend time there.
A large sports and spa area was installed at that point.
So many things are used differently here in Europe, and particularly in Germany, compared to the US.
And then came the first newbuild order -- the ship that was truly planned on a blank sheet of paper and built at the Meyer Werft in Finland.
That was then delivered.
That was Mein Schiff 3, and that's when I joined.
Tell me, a ship like that isn't exactly cheap.
If I've looked it up correctly, you can spend somewhere between half a billion and a billion euros.
When and how?
And I also found it fascinating because, from the outside, you're incredibly lean.
You have, I believe, around seven hundred people permanently at headquarters.
And then you have on-board staff -- I think about a hundred and fifty or...
The on-board numbers are a few more?
Yes, that order of magnitude.
You've thought about it.
And the newer ships --
you say it used to be two and a half thousand, now it's up to four thousand berths.
How should the strategically and commercially minded listeners picture this?
You've got a ship.
It sails for about thirty years. You spend a billion euros on it, and the whole thing needs to eventually pay for itself.
Can you walk us through the key parameters that go through your mind as CEO?
Well,
what's really important -- we've just talked about the beginnings -- on the one hand, it was clear there's demand in the market for this form of travel.
Then comes the question of what size.
Then: how much do I spend on a newbuild?
But what's really important is: is the market potential actually there, and can I achieve the occupancy? Unlike hotels, which are sometimes only open for a hundred and eighty days due to seasonal conditions --
a ship operates three hundred and sixty-five days a year, and occupancy is the big driver of profitability.
And then of course, with ship size -- whether that's five hundred passengers, two thousand, three thousand, or four thousand -- that scalability is the real driver.
And if you then manage to achieve the occupancy, you get to a point fairly quickly where you not only have a payback, but also very satisfied customers.
The occupancy rate is...
It's above one hundred per cent.
Happily, we've achieved that... That means --
above one hundred per cent -- do some guests have to go in the lifeboats?
Exactly!
It's fairly easy to explain.
The one hundred per cent occupancy is based on double cabins and also some single cabins.
But one hundred per cent means every permanently installed bed -- let me put it that way -- is occupied. If you then add a third bed in a cabin, which some customers do, or even two,
or if children are travelling, you go above one hundred per cent.
And that gives you a sense of just how strong the demand is -- and that it's an incredibly popular form of travel.
It always has been, but new ships have increasingly incorporated what customers expect, wherever they come from.
What do customers expect from a holiday?
What are the main motivations?
What do I need to offer?
And on a ship, particularly a somewhat larger one, we have the ability to offer a huge range of areas, keep them well utilised thanks to the number of people on board, and simply create a diverse holiday experience.
The mix -- the cost structure, let's say -- is one thing.
Then the ship needs to be operated, it needs looking after.
And then you have various offerings that happen ashore.
How does that break down from a business perspective?
How significant is the investment in the ship itself, or its depreciation? How much is operating costs?
Can you give us a rough feel for it?
Yes, I can give a sense of it.
Well, it starts with the ship itself, and the more modern a ship, the more energy-efficient.
A ship sitting in port isn't much fun.
So ship operations are obviously essential, and every energy efficiency measure we take helps.
So operating costs -- ship operations -- that accounts for a large share.
How do you measure that?
Is it per ship per day, per passenger, per year? Do you have metrics?
We work with what are called APCDs.
Those are Available Passenger Cruise Days.
That's
our occupancy calculation, and that's essentially our baseline, against which we set our KPIs.
This is what we want to achieve, and we evaluate against it.
Where are the ships sailing?
What prices do we want to achieve?
There are already differences within our fleet: on the one hand, the Mein Schiff fleet with medium-sized ships -- averaging around three thousand passengers -- and then Hapag-Lloyd Cruises, where in the luxury segment it's four to five hundred passengers on Europa and Europa 2.
Or on the Hanseatic ships, just two hundred and thirty.
And with a luxury ship or an expedition ship sailing to Antarctica, it first has to get to Antarctica.
That naturally involves far more sea days but fewer APCDs,
because the ships are smaller. So operations costs vary by sailing area and deployment.
And then there's the food and beverage offering.
In the Mein Schiff world, we have the premium all-inclusive concept, where all drinks and meals are included in the fare.
Of course you can spend extra, but you don't have to.
With Hapag-Lloyd Cruises, for example, the share is higher because it's a luxury product and smaller. The extras are more pronounced there, the wishes more varied when it comes to truly premium offerings.
That varies again. And then we have what, for Mein Schiff, is the main driver of additional spending.
It's actually the shore excursions. Our guests go ashore disproportionately often and really explore each region, usually on organised excursions, which also helps to manage guest flows.
That's a significant share.
But then there are other extras too -- massages, beauty treatments, and so on.
If
you were to roughly break it down: how much does operating the ship itself account for?
How much is the guest care side?
Can you give a sense -- ten per cent, twenty per cent, the rest?
Can you give us a feel for it?
I can, but it gets quite detailed, and each cruise line steers it differently.
Let me ask something else. You just mentioned your staffing structure -- the headquarters setup. And then you have relatively few of your own people on board.
That means
the people who work on board -- where do they come from?
How do you orchestrate and organise that?
Because I imagine there are quite a few more working there than
the... Yes, well, as you mentioned, we have just over seven hundred and fifty employees here on land in Hamburg.
Then we have a site in Berlin, where the entertainment programmes that are shown on the ships are created.
And on board, we have something over twenty thousand --
it's a bit more by now, must be around twenty thousand crew members.
Twenty-two
thousand.
Who are on duty every day. And then, broken down to a specific ship size -- let's take Mein Schiff 7:
we have around eleven hundred crew members, of whom roughly three hundred and seventy-five are in the nautical and technical area.
And the rest are in the hotel operations.
So
that's a ratio of roughly four thousand passengers?
Well, for that ship, which has a capacity of just under four thousand passengers,
we have thirteen hundred crew on board.
We have a very, very good crew-to-guest ratio, which in turn relates to our overall offering, because we work with a great deal of table service rather than self-service.
That's what makes it work commercially.
Do I need more waiters, or more... whatever it may be.
Those thirteen hundred on a Mein Schiff 7 -- can you roughly break down where they're deployed?
Well, as I said, the three hundred
and seventy-five are nautical and technical. That starts with what's obviously absolutely vital:
the engine room, but of course also the bridge, navigation, the colleagues who actually move the ship. That's a large share.
Then, within that nautical-technical area, the ship has air conditioning.
The ship has its own water treatment system. From waste separation to everything else --
these are all systems that need to be operated, and that's done by this group of colleagues.
That makes
sense now, hearing you say it, because I was just thinking -- those huge container ships are sometimes run across the Atlantic by twenty-five people, but they don't have
... they don't have cargo that's alive, like our guests, thankfully.
And so everything is included, from switching on the lights to playing music, running entertainment stages -- lights have to come on everywhere.
That's the nautical-technical side.
There's really a great deal involved, but also very importantly, air conditioning.
How is the air supply managed?
What temperatures can I regulate?
What do I do with excess heat?
How can I use it elsewhere?
These are highly fascinating systems we have in operation.
Waste heat can be used, for example, to heat the pool. And it's not just seawater we're dealing with -- we also have various water features on board.
And what distinguishes Mein Schiff is a twenty-five-metre pool, so you can actually swim lengths.
And then we have several smaller ones, and all of these areas need to be operated, with technical staff ensuring everything runs smoothly.
That's all very well monitored nowadays, so we can achieve real savings. And something I think is still particularly worth mentioning, because many people don't know:
there's perhaps this image of a ship arriving in port and bunkering not just fuel but also fresh water for a certain number of days.
We produce ninety-six per cent of our water ourselves through reverse osmosis systems.
They're essentially miniature desalination plants on board, which give us our fresh water.
On board we're also self-sufficient --
which means we can operate in regions where we're not taking water from countries that may already be suffering from drought.
That's very important -- not just because we're on the ocean and need that independence in case of weather events, but also because it's vital that we can do it ourselves.
And here and there, we also donate water... So cruising can also give something back to the destinations we visit.
You were just saying -- the thirteen hundred minus the three hundred and seventy-five -- how are the remaining colleagues distributed?
Then we have housekeeping, and of course a great deal in the kitchen area, because on-board dining is naturally important.
A medium-sized ship, as we operate --
by today's standards, we're talking about medium-sized ships --
there's a huge amount in the galley. And then of course the tour guide department --
tour leaders who go ashore with guests, but also personal training.
We have an entertainment cast of around forty people per ship.
So it's well distributed.
Now, you said that from TUI Cruises directly, there are twenty to twenty-five colleagues on board.
Where do all the others come from?
What does the business model look like in that regard?
It's less a business model and more a legacy of the early days.
When TUI Cruises was founded,
we started working with a service provider called Sea Chefs -- they're also based here in Hamburg -- who specialise in training and providing maritime hospitality staff, founded by two entrepreneurs who'd been to sea themselves and know exactly what matters.
Both, if I'm not mistaken, with hotel backgrounds -- and they've built a very good company.
For us, it was simply this:
because we were expanding and still are,
it makes sense to have specialists handle it.
They're steered by us from headquarters, but we have an independent service provider running the hotel operations.
It happens in coordination -- we set the concept, the standards.
How should it be implemented?
But the execution is done by Sea Chefs. And so... that's our central provider for everything hotel-crew related.
Then, for deck and engine crew, we also work with Royal Caribbean -- our parent company, or one part of the parent company -- and it's a very good collaboration.
Does something like a shared company culture emerge from that?
We
manage that well!
The question that usually follows is --
so I'll answer it straight away. Was the decision to outsource this driven by cost savings?
That's not the reason.
All salaries are negotiated with the trade unions, including through the service provider and the ITF.
It's all transparent and known.
So there's no --
it makes no difference.
But
does someone like that actually feel they belong to TUI Cruises?
If I look at how well that works... I think we manage it very well.
It works because we have a fantastic team, like our Vice President Dennis Wiechert, who oversees the entire Mein Schiff product, and everyone who brings it to life on board.
We have a General Manager on board -- that's a TUI Cruises position. We have captains -- those are TUI Cruises positions. Chief Engineers.
In the engine room, we have an Environmental Officer -- just to name a few.
They all have TUI Cruises contracts, and the others work through the service provider.
But it works very well in this combination -- and there is a sense of community!
In the truest sense of the word, everyone's not just sitting in the same boat but working on the same ship.
And the goals are clear!
We're very transparent in saying: this is what we want to achieve together.
And we also develop jointly with the service providers what we want to offer the crew.
For example, we're one of the few shipping lines that allows crew members to use guest areas
in their free time -- they just need to wear name badges. And anyone who's been on board will confirm:
there's no two-tier society there -- it's a real togetherness.
And when I look at how many repeat crew members we have who keep coming back to Mein Schiff from countries all over the world, I'd say it works very well.
Fascinating!
Tell me, from a business model perspective, I believe you have about fifty per cent repeat guests, in inverted commas.
That's really quite remarkable.
I think many a hotel would love those numbers.
And you say there are around three million cruise passengers in Germany.
I believe your estimate is that it could grow to about four and a half million.
Roughly.
So still plenty of potential. And you have over one hundred per cent occupancy.
Is there anything left for you to do, or do you just need to wait for the ships to come in?
So where does the challenge actually lie?
The
challenge is there every single day.
It stands or falls with achieving guest satisfaction, with guests coming back -- regardless of the frequency.
That's the absolute priority.
You have
a high score there -- I believe it's generally very high.
It
is generally very high,
but
at Hapag-Lloyd Cruises it's a bit higher.
In the luxury segment. For Mein Schiff, we're also at around ninety this year.
So truly outstanding figures.
But ultimately, we're creating holidays for our guests, and everything has to be right. And you can't just keep doing more of the same.
It's always good to maintain certain things, but you also constantly need to reinvent yourself and question what you're doing.
What do we have to do?
In twenty twenty-five, we had around nine hundred thousand guests across the ships over the full year, and you can imagine that there's always something to work on -- training the crew, developing the ideas we have.
But also translating that for the guest and continuously maintaining the product at a high level in every part of the world.
And of course, you're dealing with guest expectations -- perfectly legitimate ones -- to have a certain product at the other end of the world.
So there's quite a lot to manage in daily operations to ensure that carefree time at sea.
And the fact that the ships move is a great advantage.
It gives us an independence that a fixed location doesn't have.
But it naturally brings other challenges too -- constant adaptation due to weather, or most recently, geopolitics.
You have to deal with that too, and that's what keeps us busy.
There's also the fact that...
Let me jump in here, if I may. I always find it appealing when companies have, perhaps not forever but for a certain period, a real focus metric.
That focus metric, if I'm reading it correctly, is customer satisfaction, customer-centricity.
In industry, insurance, and other service sectors, there's frequently the strategic aspiration to become more customer-centric, more customer-oriented.
In practice, they're often very far from that aspiration.
What can people perhaps learn from TUI Cruises
about genuinely lived customer-centricity? Do you have particular habits,
rituals, mindsets in meetings -- how do you do it?
Beyond just saying, there's a symbolic chair with the customer sitting on it and we ask them from time to time. What's the trick?
Or simply, OK, right.
Is there anything you can share?
Well, I think it starts with listening to our customers -- and not treating them as one uniform guest.
Not someone you survey once a year asking: what would you like?
What would you like?
How
do you do it
in practice?
We ask straight away on board, through a questionnaire -- digital or on paper -- after every voyage.
That generates substantial feedback.
But we also do sentiment measurement in real time while the guests are on board, and for that we have our crew members on the ships who have a very good feel for things.
Where is the mood good?
Where is it perhaps a bit dampened?
And so on.
Many things can be resolved on the spot, when you notice -- where we actually get the most criticism is when we can't fulfil wishes, like when we can't call at a port.
Is weather typically the reason?
Or when the weather is bad, does the mood dip a bit?
The colleagues on board already have tools for that... The key point is that it's no longer a means of transport but essentially an entire holiday destination that travels with you, docking here and there to visit other regions and cities. That's the thing.
You have
a customer journey.
And are there critical touchpoints where you say, we pay particularly close attention?
Yes, there are always neuralgic points.
Where you can always improve, and of course with increasing digitalisation -- which has worked better at some times than others, I have to say -- that was an intensive journey.
When we worked together, those were the early days. And today it's simply a must, because we all want to travel seamlessly.
We all still want to speak to actual people and not just communicate with hotlines or bots. But the moment it's just about getting from A to B or onto a ship, it should be as frictionless as possible.
And whenever that hasn't worked -- at various stages, there were different projects.
You spread the check-in across time slots to avoid large crowds arriving at once, and so on.
But it also depends on how the customer travels to us.
Are they embarking in Germany, or was there a flight beforehand?
So the customer journey varies.
And crucially, there's that first moment of coming aboard. It simply has to be a welcoming atmosphere, and everyone's still excited.
You don't know who's had a stressful journey.
Who arrived perfectly relaxed?
Those are the first moments. And the ship's leadership handles that very much in the moment.
What can we do here?
Because we have different customer journeys defined. And once the customer is on board -- and perhaps coming back to how we measure things, beyond the sentiment shared by the ship's leadership
and the customer feedback, we're constantly reviewing and developing our offerings by identifying what's missing.
Where do we need to improve?
You never finish with that.
Are
there things where you sometimes think, surely not, are we dealing with that again?
Of course, that happens from time to time.
It tends to be something that's really...
What was the last time?
Flights being cancelled, for instance -- nobody's fault.
And then you've got guests who are on their way and arrive too late for the ship's departure, in correspondingly good or bad moods, and so forth.
That sort of thing happens.
But there are also issues like
a check-in system in a port going down -- we had that recently, in a German port. The check-in system failed.
Because the internet connection wasn't sufficient!
And then two thousand guests had to wait a bit longer and queue.
So there's always something. What has changed over the past ten years is that we can communicate faster and more directly.
Digitalisation really helps there!
We were actually among the first, back in two thousand and...
At the time, we invested quite a lot of money by the standards of the day, with limited customer benefit. That's changed now.
Today we can quickly reach customers in any form of crisis and say: attention, there's a flight delay, or the port is cancelled due to weather, and here are the alternatives.
We've learnt a lot there.
But those are the kind of things --
you're never finished. It's a permanent pursuit of improvement.
But what I think is important -- perhaps coming back to your question about how we do it:
we measure it. That's absolutely vital. And not by saying, there's just the one guest -- but really looking at the guest mix. Who has which expectations?
During school holidays, we naturally run a different programme from a period in late November or early December when it's mainly couples travelling without children.
And you simply have to say: today, we can target the offering far more precisely. And what also works for us -- it was possible before, but thinking back ten or twenty years, it was much harder to make niche offerings accessible to specific customer groups.
What do you mean by that?
I
mean that a great deal of effort used to go into reaching perhaps a very small customer group.
And now, through the personalisation that marketing enables,
we can target much more precisely.
And I don't have to say, it's just one ship offering a holiday for three thousand guests. Within those three thousand guests, there are often
thirty or forty completely different customer groups on the same ship, and everyone finds something for them.
So you also have
quite a few personas, to use the marketing
jargon?
Well, we do fewer.
We've actually moved away from personas.
We did that too, once upon a time.
We went through that phase.
In twenty-sixteen and twenty-seventeen, we still worked a lot with personas.
Today, we simply say: we want to make what we offer accessible to as many people as possible.
We're still in the phase of working out the best approach.
Whom do I target with what?
We're not there yet.
So there's still plenty of room for improvement.
We all talk about it... What's
currently the best approach, even if you're still learning?
What are your learnings?
Well,
our learnings vary!
One customer is someone who works closely with their travel agent beforehand.
The travel trade still has great significance.
Absolutely --
it's not all digital. A cruise is, for many, still a very special form of travel.
It's not just the weekend city trip you book with three clicks. Do you
have a sense of what percentage goes through that channel?
Yes,
I can tell you. Through third-party distribution channels, we have around seventy per cent.
And of that seventy, approximately sixty per cent are still traditional travel agents, though many now also have their own online portals and hybrid models.
And about twelve per cent come through online portals.
Most of those specialise in cruises.
So if I'm doing the maths correctly in my head, about a third still comes through travel agents and tour operators.
Well, thirty per cent we do directly.
Perhaps that's clearer: seventy per cent is third-party, so to speak.
And of the total revenue,
about twelve per cent comes from online providers.
The rest is travel agencies and tour operators, though not necessarily the traditional travel agency -- many now
operate their own travel portals or have hybrid presences.
One guest prefers to walk into a travel agency that perhaps specialises in cruises.
There are quite a few of those -- they know every ship and can advise precisely.
Where are you more likely to get seasick, or where perhaps not?
Where is there a strong focus on dining, or where is it more international?
Or where is the entertainment better?
They're true experts.
A lot happens at that stage.
They can then also say which cabin is best suited for which type of guest.
One person wants to be close to the lift because they're not so mobile.
The next one would rather be further away. One wants to look out the back, another out the front, and so on.
So there are a multitude of factors at play.
But then there are also offerings like our fitness programme -- which is always the thing people least expect.
If you survey people about what actually happens on a cruise ship,
the response is still: I'm worried about gaining weight because the culinary variety tempts you to eat constantly.
It can -- but it doesn't have to, because we operate the largest fitness facilities at sea, all with ocean views.
You can train whilst looking out at the sea, use personal trainers at considerably lower cost than on land, get nutrition advice on board.
Or we have coaches on board who are experts in all sorts of sports, and a holiday is a perfect time to pursue that.
But that's not something you'd run a campaign for.
Because perhaps only two hundred out of three thousand are interested.
But those two hundred come on board and say, oh, that's wonderful -- I can combine that with my holiday. In a family holiday, I can still pursue my special interest. And we communicate that mainly through the app, customer communications, social media feeds -- all very different channels.
So that means personas would essentially be too coarse a grid, to put it simply. And you then presumably also use social media --
which
platforms play a substantial role for you?
Facebook still plays a big role. Instagram. TikTok is coming --
TikTok
relatively late, but that's naturally linked to the age profile. It's gained quite significant importance.
But the big communities -- the Mein Schiff communities -- are on the customer side, and our product colleagues read a great deal from what's being discussed there. Those are mainly repeat guests who communicate, who know exactly what's changed and who don't necessarily welcome every change or celebrate it, but say the old one was better. You can also read a sentiment from that.
And so the product team is really focused on saying: we have various KPIs that we review daily, weekly -- daily on the ships.
What are
the most important KPIs you look at?
Is it utilisation of the different areas?
How high is the participation rate in the on-board offerings? If we provide a lot and nobody turns up,
that's a pretty big indicator that something's wrong.
Those are obvious ones.
Also revenue KPIs -- we invest in areas on the ships as well. For example, with the new Intuition class of ships,
we've built two restaurants that offer a digitally immersive dining experience.
That's more than just a superb five-course menu by Tim Raue, the Michelin-starred chef from Berlin -- there's also a story being told.
It's a combination of entertainment and significant investment in technology. And that's not part of the all-inclusive package -- it's an extra.
If you invest in something like that and nobody goes --
we watch all these things constantly and adjust where we can.
But it's also about how we reach the customer.
And when you have many repeat customers or interested prospects who come to us and share their preferences,
you can of course engage in a very different kind of dialogue.
Has customer behaviour actually changed in the past ten years, in your view?
In your industry -- has it remained fairly constant?
Well, I think it starts with the fact that the main motivation for coming on board is genuinely to relax.
It's about holidays -- I want to hand over everything and have a completely carefree package.
And if you look at the leisure research analyses over the past thirty years, that's never been different.
Of course, there's always the theme of exploration, of doing your own touring --
but the overarching motive has always been relaxation.
And with cruising, we have the opportunity to combine both -- a truly relaxed atmosphere on board, and discovery ashore.
What has changed, I'd say, are the customer groups.
Twenty years ago --
I don't remember the exact figures now --
in Germany, the average age was, I believe, around sixty, and it's now around fifty. So it's getting younger, because the range of offerings has broadened, with different ships, different concepts, more affordable for everyone -- and therefore genuinely younger. It's no longer the Traumschiff image where you have to sit in a dinner jacket or evening gown at night -- or get to, depending on your perspective.
Instead, everyone can enjoy their holiday, and that's leading to a rejuvenation of the customer base.
And what we're seeing is more families coming on board, and the family offerings are being expanded accordingly.
We've just introduced a new icon for our ships and created a character called Fini, to keep things fresh.
Thank you so much.
You can now get a good picture of how the business is organised and operates.
Is it actually worth us talking about strategy?
Strategy always implies placing some kind of bet. And if I think of my last Debugged episode with Weissenbacher, CEO of Mann+Hummel -- they make filters for automotive and said, our bet is that we can also do life science and environment, filtering not just oil and water in vehicles but also air and water in entirely different areas. A genuine strategic bet.
You don't really have one of those, because essentially -- I think you've ordered ships through to thirty, thirty-one, two more coming -- and you'll fill them, and until then you've got one hundred per cent occupancy, so you focus on operational excellence, customer-centricity... Tell me I'm wrong.
We're convinced the market is there -- otherwise we wouldn't be building the ships.
That's crucial. And that we have to do a great deal to keep filling the ships well goes without saying.
We could talk at length about marketing and distribution strategies, but that's just one part.
Otherwise, I'll grant you that the overarching goal or strategy is: we operate cruises and we operate ships. We're a shipping line running vessels across different segments.
That's set and won't change.
Where we do invest, and where we do place the occasional bet, is when we -- as you say, it's thirty or thirty-one when the next newbuilds come.
We ordered those ships last year, in twenty twenty-five, for a vessel that arrives six years later. Some who aren't familiar with this market might say that's perhaps a bet.
We don't think so, because we believe the market will support it and the potential is there, and ultimately, the ships are mobile.
Even if something happens in one source market, that's already baked in.
But it was an important strategic anchor for us that we set last year, and we intend to continue.
Perhaps one more small point.
Why is that?
Why does it matter that we secure another ship?
And the ship we're receiving this year -- Mein Schiff Flow --
that was ordered years ago.
So correspondingly long lead times. Not because it takes that long to build such a ship, but quite simply because the shipyards' order books are full. And something very few people know:
ninety-seven per cent of cruise ship construction takes place in Europe. It's a genuinely important industry here in Europe.
There's Fincantieri in Italy, the Meyer Werft here in Germany and in Finland,
and there's Chantiers de l'Atlantique in Saint-Nazaire, France -- and that's it!
They build ninety-seven per cent of all ships.
Very little has been built in China so far, and to my knowledge, exclusively for the Chinese domestic market.
And all the innovation in these ships is truly a European achievement -- a hugely important one. And cruising is the innovation driver for the shipping industry in many areas.
The cruise industry started installing so-called scrubbers -- exhaust gas cleaning systems -- even earlier, to keep sulphur oxide and nitrogen oxide emissions low in cities and ensure clean air.
The cruise industry installed those, operated them.
Invested in catalytic converters, water treatment systems -- all things that the commercial shipping industry, which is volumetrically much larger -- there are just over four hundred cruise ships worldwide but roughly sixty to eighty thousand commercial vessels -- and shore power: fitting ships so they can use shore power.
We've done that too -- all our ships, for example, are pre-equipped. But it took a while before we could actually use it, because the shore power installations simply didn't exist in the ports yet, which is meant to reduce emissions in harbours.
That's gradually improving, but there's still a long way to go.
So on the topic of sustainability -- which we've had anchored in our strategy since twenty fourteen or even earlier, when we placed the newbuild orders -- we said:
We create holidays for people.
We sail to regions that are holiday destinations, and wherever we operate,
we want to preserve those places.
We can't simply add to the problem -- we want to minimise our impact as much as possible.
That means we invest in environmental technology.
And we started doing that very early on.
And you do place the odd bet there, committing to a propulsion type with long lead times,
in the hope that it works out.
But I can offer a positive example: for the Mein Schiff Relax and Mein Schiff Flow, which we have this year, we opted for a so-called dual-fuel propulsion system,
so we can use different fuels.
It's a bridging technology,
but this summer, we're running entirely on bio-LNG, which reduces our carbon footprint by around eighty per cent.
That's still not enough -- you're never finished. But that's the overarching goal, and we'll keep at it.
Millions go into ship equipment that you can't always use from day one.
We also have another example.
We were very proud that a ship we built at the Meyer Werft in Turku during the pandemic
is now being pre-equipped for methanol operation.
Green methanol has even better values in the long run than bio-LNG.
But for that, it also needs to be available in as many ports as possible, and at a price that makes economic sense.
We've made the investment, and then you go through various bureaucratic rounds, but last week we successfully completed the first methanol bunkering in Kiel, so that at least for part of the ship's operations, green methanol can be used.
Once availability improves, we can retrofit further. So those are the kind of bets we do place.
That's one aspect.
And what's naturally also a theme: the ships love being at sea, and there's nothing lovelier or more famous than gazing at the horizon from your balcony.
But we also depend on -- and our guests want to -- discovering regions. That means we sail into ports!
And there, we naturally also need to work with ports and destinations to think through the customer journey in the destination, so it's a good experience for everyone.
That
would have been one of my follow-up questions.
So I see... Two things that could potentially dent the business model.
One is probably what you're just touching on... Amsterdam, Venice.
There are a few cities -- I'm not
the first to say --
that are now saying, overtourism, we want to regulate this.
Which cities are actually doing it?
I honestly can't tell you exactly right now, because some of them are initiatives from port cities.
Sometimes it's genuinely regulated.
Palma, for example, has a fixed plan specifying how many cruise ships can call.
But that was developed jointly with the companies.
We welcome that.
It's very sensible. Dubrovnik also... So
when Palma does something like that,
it doesn't actually affect your business model?
No, in the end it's a planning question. The key issue is: can cruise ships actually come here, do we want that?
Do we have the port infrastructure to berth ships, and can we then offer a decent experience ashore?
That's where it starts. And then of course there are different interests in port cities and regions. What we see much more is not exclusively an anti-cruise sentiment but rather a European-wide issue.
At certain times -- typically the summer season, when travel intensity across Europe and indeed globally is at its peak, during school holidays, when the whole world is travelling and it gets concentrated -- it's about managing those guest flows better.
And something we mustn't forget: everything we do is one thing.
But there are also locals living there who may not be thrilled, because it affects their daily lives.
And it's less about whether it's guests from a ship or day trippers walking through -- it's more the broader effects of us all having become global citizens, wealthier people renting flats in southern Europe and coming three times a year.
It's a hugely multifaceted issue.
But regardless -- and I don't want to deflect from cruising -- the point is that we need to engage with ports early enough.
What do we do? Our sailing schedules are planned three to four years out.
We broadly already know where we want to deploy our ships, by size, right through to the value creation that then happens in ports with local providers -- all planned.
It's not a surprise that next Thursday, two thousand guests want to explore Mallorca -- and we can steer: who goes to Palma?
Who goes to the museum? And so on.
What we actually hear from destinations is mostly positive feedback, because cruise guests spend disproportionately on experiences.
Probably because time in port is somewhat more limited than when you've a week to explore a city.
Then you spread it out. Otherwise, it's more compressed.
Far more cultural institutions are visited, and those are all things we can measure and use to shape our offerings.
But of course, travellers today travel differently from ten years ago, when a large majority said
I want the first impression, perhaps with a panoramic bus tour.
Today, there's much more individual initiative.
One person wants to do it by bike, the next with a guided walking tour, another just with their device.
The next wants to look behind the scenes of a restaurant, or go shopping -- and offering all these excursions
-- those are the great advantages we have today.
And that ties into the multiple interests.
It naturally creates opportunities in destinations even for small providers who would never have had the chance before -- to say, every Tuesday I open my kitchen for twenty people and cook with them, just as an example, or visit a workshop where a bag is hand-stitched.
That would have been very much left to chance before.
And today, with social media and targeting specific customer groups, it works quite well.
Do you see, overall, a threat -- not just for the cruise industry but for tourism as a whole -- from this overtourism, especially as cities increasingly get involved?
Or do you say, well, I understand...?
You have to take it seriously.
I can't say it's complete nonsense when the perception... Do you
think it'll intensify?
I think we're seeing this not just in tourism but extreme perceptions where few facts -- whether they're not being provided or not being consumed, I can't say --
you have to engage with that.
That's why it's always hard to say: where is there genuinely an anti-cruise or anti-tourism initiative?
Or where is it perhaps a relatively small group gaining public attention, which then lands as a headline around the world, while the actual perception locally isn't that strong?
That's becoming increasingly difficult to distinguish.
But what we can do as operators is genuinely engage with all local authorities and also with residents, and ask: what do you want?
And I believe there'll never be one single solution that satisfies everyone.
But what we can do -- through long-term planning and by managing the guest numbers we bring -- is, in coordination with the destinations, make it work for everyone.
And the economic value creation -- I must stress this again.
Because there are old perceptions and narratives that cruise guests don't spend anything in destinations, which is complete nonsense.
Even just the docking -- the berth fee for a Mein Schiff-sized vessel averages around one hundred thousand euros for a single day. And then everything that's generated on top of that is substantial.
And with Mein Schiff -- I checked the figures just yesterday -- on a seven-day voyage, it's around two hundred and eighty euros per person spent on shore experiences.
That goes directly into the communities in the ports we visit.
Now, that won't necessarily interest the resident living three rows back, who says: what's in it for me?
And that's precisely where the destinations are called upon to say: how do we communicate this?
And how do we really orchestrate it?
We're only just at the beginning there.
It can only get better, but it's a genuine volume tourism issue.
On the other hand, if travel were only possible for a privileged few, what would the world look like?
I'd rather not speculate on that.
Let's perhaps spend the last twenty minutes or so looking at leadership and culture.
You've been through extraordinarily intense phases in a very short time.
You've been at the helm since... twenty-twelve, then twenty-twenty brought Covid, which presumably -- you can perhaps put this into context -- led to a business collapse.
How did you deal with it?
You went into the valley, and then in twenty-four, twenty-five, twenty-six, I believe, you've delivered forty to fifty per cent growth.
So tell us: how does one manage crises of this kind?
Economic crises, specifically.
How do you manage growth, and what matters most?
And then perhaps acute crises too -- the Iran crisis.
Two of your ships were stuck. Some passengers for three to four weeks, and the entire crew for about a month longer. But perhaps one thing at a time.
How does crisis management like that work?
What actually happens at your end?
How did you deal with it?
From about January onwards -- I believe it was early January -- the first reports appeared in Germany
about a virus in China.
At that point, we had a ship in Asian waters, and we were already in contact, saying: how do we need to prepare?
We do that together with Royal Caribbean, who also had more ships in the region, and we said: what does this mean?
I should preface this by saying that cruise ships, as holiday venues, naturally have preparations in place for virus outbreaks on board and similar.
Everything that can happen on land can also happen on a ship.
And so there are far more prevention plans than in other forms of travel where you might just be in a hotel.
So based on those, we assessed: what does this mean?
For the crew, for everything else -- can we still allow shore excursions?
What do we need to watch out for?
At that stage, relatively little was required. What we did in January was distribute significantly more masks on the ship. At that point, we still hoped it was simply a matter of getting that one ship from Asia into safer waters, back to Europe.
And then the whole thing would be over.
So we stepped up the health and hygiene measures on board, shifted to a higher level.
We managed that well.
But then, essentially,
week by week, the crisis crept closer -- just as it did for everyone here in Germany.
How many
ships did you have in service at the time?
At that time, we had seven ships in operation. And so it was then that we... We also regularly practise for this.
We have an Emergency Response Team, and we regularly train for all manner of scenarios -- major incidents, minor incidents -- with a crisis team that's activated.
We do that thankfully.
It was actually one of the first exercises I went through in twenty-fifteen.
What does a crisis actually look like?
Including for me as CEO.
This is my role, and so on.
And the first thing I had to learn -- the thing I was fortunate enough to learn --
is that it's important to have a good process.
And that as CEO, you step back and let the experts do their work first -- you really hold back, so as not to exert undue influence.
In the sense that someone who perhaps only has the commercial interest in mind might tend towards a different decision than what an expert-based decision-making process would produce.
Were there situations in the Covid crisis where that was hard for you?
Not at all!
In the Covid crisis, not at all.
No, because it was simply clear that we... As a team, we worked together brilliantly.
Looking back, it feels like it was much longer ago, and yet many moments are still very present.
And where you can see that when an established process exists, it gets rolled out across everything.
Almost on autopilot.
There was nothing but the crisis, and you were incredibly focused on what needed to be done.
And for us, what always counts is: we carry the most precious cargo, so to speak.
We work with people -- whether passengers or the many crew on the ships.
Following that principle, everything was cascaded down.
And then we said: first priority -- we need to get everyone back as quickly as possible.
Where were the seven
ships? In the Caribbean?
One was in the Emirates.
Ships in the Mediterranean, the Canary Islands, and so on.
And in Asia -- so they were well spread out.
Right, so what happened then?
Can you do a time-lapse of twenty-twenty? The crisis started and lasted at least until twenty-two.
Yes,
though for us there were intermediate steps.
The first six weeks were really intense -- we had to get all the ships... And then we moved into a phase where we sent the majority of the crew home.
At the beginning, we still thought: perhaps -- how long will the crisis last?
Two weeks?
Three weeks?
There were different forecasts.
At some point in March, it was clear: this is going to drag on.
So we said: we're winding everything down to a skeleton crew, and we laid up almost all the ships in the German Bight with a crew on board who looked after themselves and kept the ships in good condition.
So you had seven TUI Cruises ghost ships out there?
Yes, though there were still around eighty crew members on board, and all that had to be worked through. There were real hurdles, because there was a worldwide travel ban.
Where do you get the permissions from?
Our incredible flight department organised charter capacity very quickly, and we got the guests back -- all of them, really very quickly. And then the crew as well, though some we simply couldn't get home.
I believe it was Mauritius and Honduras.
They wouldn't even take their own nationals back. So we looked after them here in Germany.
There were all sorts of extraordinary situations. We practically ran a consular operation.
We designated an officer whose sole job was to have all these conversations with different countries.
How do you get people back to their home countries despite closed borders, and so on?
And obtaining the corresponding permits.
Every country also had different hygiene requirements.
We all became experts fairly quickly in the sense of: how do we test, what do the results mean?
How do we break chains of infection, and so on?
And when a certain calm eventually settled -- the ships were safely in the German Bight, or the Hapag-Lloyd ships were in Bremerhaven or here in Hamburg at the quay -- and we said, right, let's see what happens next.
I'd say that was around mid to late April.
So it took months?
It was about six weeks.
In early March, it was clear the world was grinding to a halt, and then it was four to six weeks until we'd reached that status.
In parallel, of course, here in Hamburg we had four hundred and fifty employees who were all worrying about their jobs. And naturally, instead of commissioning one ship after another,
instead of booking customers in, we were booking them out -- a huge burden on customer service and accounting, who had to reverse all sorts of forward bookings, including customer refunds.
The finance department -- Frank Kuhlmann, whom I already mentioned -- was focused on maintaining liquidity.
We moved very quickly and introduced short-time working immediately, and somehow managed to...
For the entire Hamburg headquarters?
For everyone who wasn't strictly needed... There were some areas -- like the ship entertainers or the team in Berlin -- for whom it was particularly painful, because we told them it's best to go on full short-time working. No stages to perform on.
And of course, there was a question of how to evaluate all this.
But we communicated very openly about it. And what I remember is that while we were implementing emergency measures, we always communicated very intensively.
Once a week, we did a briefing call for everyone, saying: here's where we stand. These are the next steps.
From repatriating guests and crew,
to how we're managing infection incidents.
How we're preparing the offices.
We also switched to mobile working overnight, equipping all employees.
But for those who said they'd rather come to the office, we set up the offices for social distancing so that operations could continue.
But unlike many others, we were anything but bored. I still remember a good friend calling me and saying:
why aren't you at home? No ships are sailing!
Nobody can travel.
Exactly -- so we were anything but idle.
But it was also clear that this was, for us, truly the hardest part -- getting guests and crew back. And also here in Hamburg, trying to keep morale as high as possible, saying: we're keeping you informed transparently. Everyone who goes on short-time working is helping the company.
Some carry a heavier load, others less.
Those in the crisis team obviously had disproportionately many working hours.
We also redeployed teams -- people from product, for example, who would normally work on product development, helped out in accounting and similar.
We distributed the load fairly well to get through it.
And then it was about -- and here I remembered a call from the beginning of the year, when the first information about this virus came through, and a virologist from the US said that the cruise industry is actually quite well equipped,
because of the prevention plans on board, outbreaks can be managed.
That of course helped us. What was already in place for ship operations with guests on board provided the template
for how to move forward.
And then --
was it always clear to you that the business would continue?
Or were there moments where you thought, this business is...
No, I didn't. Whether it was naivety or purposeful optimism --
no, I genuinely never thought that.
And it
never got to the point where the financial damage -- which must have been enormous -- threatened the substance? Where you'd say: I'm having existential concerns?
The existential concerns were there, yes. But through quick action and a very good track
record up to that point, a fundamentally sound business model, and assets in the form of modern ships -- I didn't doubt it.
Of course there were various critics and analysts who said the cruise industry is dead.
It won't come back.
I told myself: I don't believe that.
In my previous career, I'd experienced crises where people said nobody will ever travel to that destination again.
This, that, and the other.
Customers generally have very short memories, and when opportunities return, they take them up again.
The important thing is simply: how can you operate safely?
And there, the mantras of seafaring -- safety first -- were naturally paramount. How can it work?
Without taking disproportionately large risks.
How can you make it possible?
So.
We consulted scientists, virologists here in Germany, and after a few weeks began reaching out. I noticed during those calls that not everyone thought it was time yet.
Everyone was very much in stay-at-home mode, doing as little as possible. That probably raised a few eyebrows.
Including with the port authorities, whom we also needed.
And then -- I don't know if you remember -- in the summer of twenty-one, every German holiday destination was booked out.
We still had a worldwide travel ban.
The Baltic coast was full, the North Sea coast was full, the Bavarian Forest was full -- and everywhere you needed tests just to be able to travel.
So we said -- and I think this is part of the cruise industry's DNA -- let's do a so-called blue voyage: we won't be able to dock, but we have a ship that we'll only half-fill, so it makes commercial sense,
and we offer a holiday experience -- a holiday destination that happens to be at sea.
And you can do plenty on a ship like that.
There was enormous demand.
Customers came straight back, even if it meant wearing masks on board, maintaining distance, and testing regularly.
I can't even begin to say how many tests we actually conducted on board our ships.
And then we were on this trajectory.
That was actually already a vindication and a success story.
Then the first countries opened up, then some closed again, regulations tightened once more -- and every last infection on board a ship
generated major headlines. But all in all -- and there was of course a reason for it, because at the beginning of the crisis that cruise ship in Japan was so badly affected.
I don't want to trivialise any of it.
But we'd developed a certain routine by then and kept saying: the risk is no greater than elsewhere, and we're doing everything we can to offer holidays in a safe manner.
That was a good starting point, and we came through it very quickly.
And beyond the commercial side, it was also important to provide proof of trust -- that this is a form of travel that wasn't finished because of Covid. Not just for our guests but crucially for our crew.
Who said: how wonderful that we can carry on.
These are people from many countries serving on board, for whom this has an even greater significance.
What were your one or two -- perhaps three -- key learnings from this crisis management?
Did you personally take something away from it?
The learnings -- yes. It's always the case, however difficult things get:
there's always a way out.
You have to take a moment, gather yourself, sit down.
And again -- these aren't decisions one person makes alone. You really have to come together with all the experts, the entire leadership team, and say: what can work?
Everyone works in their discipline, you bring it together, and then you decide.
That applies to all situations, in my view, but becomes particularly important in a crisis.
But also, giving the crisis team the space and staying in the background -- not being neutral, but acting when asked to make the decision -- and not sitting there with a raised finger or an air of judgement. Otherwise, they can't do their work.
But even more important for me was: things will go on somehow, and we have to find the way.
And another learning, which came a bit later: because we restarted quite quickly -- I believe it was the first of July we set sail again --
naturally under intense public scrutiny.
Does it really work?
It did work!
But I think it's also important -- something I took away -- that you harness the energy a crisis generates. Because I believe we're all quite performance-driven people, and when you have the success of saying, we've brought everyone back safely,
we've sorted this out, we've made it again --
that gives you a lot of energy. But it also masks the fact that being in a crisis is draining.
And what we've learnt from that -- and have now applied -- is that we're more sensitive in the aftermath for everyone who was involved in the crisis. Because some colleagues experienced that flashback --
what was all that, actually? --
in some cases much later.
When day-to-day business had already returned, when you'd think everything was fine again --
that's when they collapsed.
So we're more attentive now, and also willing to say -- just as with any good sporting event --
you can only perform at your best if you look after yourself. And sometimes that means creating a second or third position to cover, so people can genuinely deliver that level of performance.
Did you lose people during that time -- people who simply lost faith in the business model?
Of course. During that period, we lost quite a few in IT, because there were crisis winners -- the entire digital commerce sector boomed.
Some colleagues here in Hamburg approached employers who had enormous demand.
We lost people there.
We also lost some who said it was too intense.
This constant feeling that anything could happen any day --
they wanted a calmer professional life. Some in between, and probably the odd person who left for genuinely emotional reasons or due to the strain, without us necessarily knowing.
So yes, that happens.
And that's why --
in hindsight, I'd say that was a learning.
To look more closely. If you ask me in my role, to reach out to certain people sooner.
That applies to the leadership team -- saying, take a step back, take a few days off, however long.
We need to approach things differently.
That was the learning.
But fundamentally, I had -- and if not for one exception --
I've also been in a professional situation before where it was clear: this isn't going any further.
And you have to communicate that clearly and transparently too.
Which I did.
In that case, I genuinely didn't believe. That was much earlier.
But it was a start-up that wasn't going to last, and...
So you're saying: transparency, clarity?
Not pretending everything's fine is
absolutely crucial.
We didn't tell all our colleagues everything will be fine.
We said: you need to contribute, and that means short-time working. And of course, that brought change.
In the first week, when we thought -- I still remember the early calls and the projection:
perhaps six weeks.
We could have easily absorbed that ourselves.
But it ended up being months, with that impact. So the messaging evolved too.
But we always communicated based on what we knew at that point, and tried to be genuinely transparent -- not sugar-coating anything, not painting a doom-and-gloom picture either, but speaking
clearly, whilst also conveying the genuine optimism and confidence
that I had, that almost everyone on our leadership team had.
How long did it take to recover the financial damage?
About two and a half years.
Yes, I can imagine.
Was everyone happy and relieved when that was done?
What about your shareholders -- you're a joint venture between the two companies we mentioned.
Were they aligned?
Were they confident it would work, or was there...
They were affected very differently.
Royal Caribbean, as a cruise company, equally so.
But they chose a completely different path.
We also received a government-backed loan very quickly.
That helped too, as TUI Cruises GmbH.
Royal Caribbean, by contrast, didn't pursue that for themselves -- they took on more debt and said: liquidity is what counts.
And then we'll rebuild ourselves, to remain independent.
TUI, as a Germany-based company, was just as affected as we were and had its own challenges.
But they were aligned insofar as we coordinated the measures, said we're winding down, here are the initial stop-the-bleeding steps, and then at some point you rebuild.
That all happens in coordination -- it's not a solo decision but a joint one.
And they also supported us when we said we'd like to try setting sail again. It took a bit --
the perceptions differed. TUI, being here in Germany, saw no major infection wave at that point.
And from the US came the note: well, you're not exactly spending money wisely.
But if this doesn't work, the impact on the entire cruise industry would be even greater.
But in the end, they backed it. And each party digested the crisis in their own way.
For the cruise industry, it helped that demand genuinely recovered -- and after what is one of the most organised forms of travel, that actually provided a further boost and, in my view, is still a growth driver today.
Because you can truly sit back and relax.
And in the first two years after Covid, travel was genuinely more cumbersome, because nothing was really working properly again. So I think many customers said: I want to put everything in one pair of hands -- the good old package holiday benefited from that.
You're seeing that too now -- a kind of return to that, where people say: I'll book it once and I'm not interested in organising it all myself.
And then the exact opposite happens --
meaning
the massive growth after Covid?
Well, we knew that would come!
You
knew. Well, in part that was obviously a question of what to do next.
And you always act according to what the situation demands.
Of course -- we'd ordered those ships. During the pandemic, we'd ordered a ship in Finland at the Meyer Werft, and we had two ships on order in Italy, with an entire team involved in designing and planning them.
And of course we also reviewed things, saying: perhaps we need to rethink this or that. For example, during that phase, we redesigned the hospitals on board and paid much more attention to infection management.
But we also said: what's a Plan B if we have less capital to spend on construction?
Where would we compromise?
In the end, we didn't have to!
But we went through that exercise. And during that phase, we decided not to exercise two further options we'd had for Italy.
Because by twenty-one, we would have had to decide -- sorry, twenty-one -- and we were still in the middle of the crisis.
So to then say, let's order more, while the balance sheet was still burdened by the standstill --
that simply wasn't possible at the time.
Had we ordered at the price available then, it would have been nice, but... it just wasn't feasible. Full stop.
And so it's partly reactive to the situation, but the planning we have and our strategy --
we want to operate modern cruises with a European DNA, as sustainably as possible --
that stands. And everything we do across the many individual areas that make up the whole picture,
that's what we need to keep working on.
Now, the Iran crisis.
Two of your ships got stuck there.
What did that do to you personally?
I think at some point, a rocket struck near one of your ships, the Mein Schiff 4, or...
No, that didn't happen!
But so much for that.
Thankfully, that didn't happen.
But those are the kind of stories that get out into the world. Not always accurately.
But yes, what did it do to me?
We dealt with it very intensively.
We had two ships there because we'd been using a shipyard in Dubai, and so it was all planned for January.
Dubai, the Emirates, Qatar -- hugely popular winter destinations.
Great weather, easy to reach, safe -- and the booking numbers spoke for themselves.
Everything was looking very good.
But from August twenty-five onwards, we regularly conducted assessments with Royal Caribbean's departments and also with TUI.
Can we sail there?
Is it safe?
Are there any signs -- were there other operators who'd decided against it?
There was certainly criticism along the lines of: you should have known.
Yes,
in hindsight, it's always easy.
It's not as though we hadn't considered it.
As I said, we monitored it.
We assessed the risk regularly. And in January, we came close to pulling out, saying: do we leave now?
Is that the right call? Every source available to us, including the German Foreign Office, essentially said: it's not going to happen now.
An attack couldn't be ruled out, but nobody expected it
before late March or early April -- by which time our ships would have already left. And the scale of it, I believe, nobody truly anticipated.
Had we foreseen it, we'd have sailed out immediately. And there was no travel warning -- we're in constant contact with all authorities. And I believe two days before the attack, a large German government delegation was
still in Abu
Dhabi.
And even then, the feedback was: nothing's going to happen. And at that point, there were twenty thousand German holidaymakers in the region.
Twenty thousand, and five thousand of those on our ships.
Yes, it was a Saturday morning when I woke up and got the news.
It's happened after all. And even then, it wasn't yet clear what the scale would be.
Is this a few hours?
A few days?
This is also a crisis that develops gradually.
I wish I could have spared everyone -- our guests, our crew, and also the team here in Hamburg.
But again, we handled it well, and the very intensive training from the pandemic certainly helped. We said: first and foremost, fly the guests home if possible -- but then the airspace was closed.
So we flew passengers out via Oman and other routes.
We were very quick again.
It worked.
But it was a different kind of threat, because you're suddenly in a region where drones are flying over ports and attacks are happening.
We were in intensive contact with the local authorities, who said: one ship stays in Abu Dhabi.
One in Doha. We stay at the quay.
Several other cruise lines were alongside us -- the same applied to them. And the message was: these sensitive areas are well protected.
What was a strain for everyone, I think, was the constant sound of drones. And naturally, everyone dealt with that differently.
And then, once most or all the passengers were gone and a large part of the crew as well,
we said: what options do we have to get out?
We kept exploring every available route, including an attempt we made via the IMO.
Because for passenger ships, the Strait of Hormuz wasn't formally closed.
But we didn't want to simply try our luck and see if we could get through.
We didn't pay anyone for safe passage. Instead, with all the relevant departments -- security teams from Royal Caribbean, from TUI, the authorities,
and also the German armed forces and the US Navy -- we kept seeking dialogue, and then said: we're going out together. All the cruise lines, during this ceasefire window, we're leaving.
That was clear by mid-April?
Yes, that
was late April.
And we sailed out in convoy, reported it, and left. But there were no drones or anything.
We weren't fired upon -- none of that happened.
But those were nerve-wracking times.
To close out -- a final question for you, Wiebke. You've been doing this for quite some time now, compared to the CEOs I know from other companies and from previous Debugged episodes.
Are you still enjoying it?
What do you still connect with the role, or would you say -- especially after these crises and the growth management --
I've set all the levers, everything's sorted.
So.
Where do you stand personally?
I still love it. It's completely changed, no question.
When I joined --
as I said, we had three ships and the fourth came soon after. And then there were different phases, with very different
workflows and areas of focus.
So there are always new challenges.
But ultimately, there are two big motivating themes for me. One is seeing delighted holidaymakers -- genuinely this theme of holidays, everything it encompasses, from cultural exchange to simply giving people a wonderful time.
That still drives me enormously.
And the world is still big. There's still a lot to discover and develop.
And the second is that it's naturally wonderful when a company or a form of travel can grow, with all the pros and cons.
Where there's light, there's also shadow.
You have to deal with that too.
But I still find it hugely exciting, even though it's a completely different kind of work now compared to twenty-fourteen.
A heartfelt thank you for being here.
Wonderful insights. To the listeners: feedback, suggestions, and ideas for who else we should welcome on Debugged are always appreciated.
Thank you so much!
My pleasure!
This podcast is produced by Podstars by OMR.
As a child, she regularly got seasick on the Helgoland ferry. Today, Wybcke Meier runs one of Europe's most successful cruise lines. Since 2014 at the helm of TUI Cruises, she has steered the company through the pandemic, the energy crisis and into a phase of ambitious expansion – always with a distinctive European identity (in German).
In Wildeshausen, I carried out my first real restructuring, where we had to let go of a third of the workforce.
Afterwards, I continued living in the town.
I was there as a restructuring manager.
And Wildeshausen is quite
a small place?
We were the largest or second-largest employer there, and I simply ran into one of them.
I don't hide behind these things.
Right!
A very warm welcome to Debugged, the manager deep talk where, together with fascinating guests -- today with you, Christian --
we take a look behind the scenes at the person, the top manager I have as my guest, and their company, to understand a few things.
How did these people get to where they are?
What sets the company apart?
The strategy... the execution of strategy, the culture, the competitive landscape.
I'm delighted to have you here for this Debugged episode today, Christian.
What will we be talking about today?
It's about how you essentially led the company from restructuring into a profitable business.
Now on a growth trajectory to also achieve a substantial return on equity and a healthy equity ratio.
We met two or three years ago at one of my board dialogues, didn't we?
Yes.
Two
years ago -- a format I run from time to time in various cities.
Can you remember our first meeting? Why did you come along back then?
Well, there's a backstory, and it's your book Konsequenz.
Konsequenz is certainly one of the key themes for me.
I had an interim marketing director who had done something with you at some point, and she recommended it to me when I was looking for Christmas gifts for my leadership team.
And then I gave it as a Christmas present.
Konsequenz?
Konsequenz, exactly!
That's precisely what we need, and here's someone who's written something interesting about it.
And that's how the contact came about.
Before we get into the story of Saacke and yourself -- restructuring manager doesn't exactly sound sympathetic.
What is a restructuring manager?
Can you try to explain that?
I can explain the role -- the person I can't explain!
The role involves a company being in a difficult financial situation.
Typically, the term is properly used when you're in the context of a bank-driven restructuring with a so-called S6 expert opinion, and you have to achieve certain financial targets within a relatively short timeframe.
These targets are first of all about restoring liquidity, but then also demonstrating a certain level of earnings power, and this is set out in a so-called restructuring report.
And the person who then implements this package of measures is the restructuring manager.
Those are the Christian Ausfalls of this world.
Now, about four weeks ago, I had the privilege of attending your international management conference and giving a short talk.
I can hardly put into words the warmth and genuine care that was palpable there. And those are two qualities you wouldn't necessarily associate with a restructuring manager.
Yet you've done this job, and not for the first time?
How does that fit together?
On your LinkedIn profile, the first thing you see is essentially 'restructuring or transformation and growth CEO'.
So you put it front and centre.
Does it fit together? Can you reconcile the two?
Apparently so.
I chose the theme 'turnaround and growth' because those are the two aspects that interest me most.
I believe you can't do a restructuring without having a goal, and that goal can only be a growth objective -- so for me, the two fit together very well.
And the good atmosphere you perhaps sensed there comes from the fact that treating people respectfully, even in difficult situations, is important to me.
Perhaps that radiates outward.
If I may jump in briefly, Christian -- it also requires, and we'll talk about Saacke in detail shortly, since you joined in twenty-one I believe -- it does require a good measure of, well, at least consistency.
Perhaps even a degree of toughness in certain areas, to actually do what needs doing. And dialogue alone will only get you so far in that regard -- or am I misreading things?
No, I think once the goals are set and the personnel measures --
that's really what it's essentially about.
Cutting non-staff costs is something everyone manages without real difficulty -- that doesn't truly hurt.
But with personnel measures, it's about implementing them consistently. And that actually has little to do with toughness.
I remember -- these are personal experiences. In Wildeshausen, when I carried out my first real restructuring, where we let go of a third of the workforce.
When
was that?
That
was in two thousand and two.
I continued living in the town afterwards.
I'd come in as a restructuring manager
and it's
a small place.
We were the largest or second-largest employer there, and I ran into one of them while we were both pushing our prams.
And he said -- the person who'd been let go -- he said he'd moved on, but he felt we'd handled it very well and humanely.
And a path forward had been shown to him through that.
For me, that was an incredibly enriching experience in such a situation.
Because I told every single person personally -- not one-on-one, but in groups of five or six.
I simply don't hide behind these things, and that's a different standard to hold oneself to.
Where did you develop this composure?
Or was it something you were born with?
Because I know many top managers who, in such phases, sometimes even hide behind restructuring consultants and essentially let them have the uncomfortable conversations -- who don't face these issues as directly and honestly. Did you have it from the start, or did you develop it?
I think it simply came naturally.
I could never imagine doing it any other way.
I had to conduct the first personnel conversations at the beginning of my career, and I'm always amazed when I hear about situations like the ones you just described, where the HR department has to handle such things.
That simply doesn't work for me.
It's incompatible with my understanding of what it means to be a manager -- whether that's a restructuring manager, an interim manager, or a managing director.
That's very admirable.
Let's have a look at Saacke.
What I can share about Saacke -- I mentioned it briefly in the introduction already.
You're a hidden champion with around twelve hundred employees.
Over the past four years, you've been doing roughly one hundred and ninety million euros in turnover, fully family-owned. It's a family business that you run.
I know, of course, what your core business is -- whether it's boilers or combustion systems for industry, be it in marine or offshore.
But would you like to explain in two or three sentences, for those who don't yet know Saacke --
What do you actually do?
Who uses your products?
Saacke makes industrial combustion technology.
The simplest example anyone can relate to: if you still have a gas boiler in your basement, there's a burner inside it.
We produce that kind of burner technology for industrial applications, in a larger performance range.
We start at around five megawatts and go up to about thirty megawatts, fifty megawatts per burner -- and we can handle even larger systems.
Our customers are industrial companies or infrastructure providers in the onshore sector.
Breweries, for example, are a large customer group of ours. The German Bundestag is heated by our burners.
But we're also active in marine applications -- many container ships and bulk carriers, these large merchant vessels, are equipped with our burners.
In the marine sector, we also manufacture the boilers ourselves, so we actually provide hot water or steam on
ships.
Could you explain for listeners who have no idea about this --
What is a burner and what is a boiler?
Where would I find one on a cruise ship like the AIDA?
What does it do?
Well, primarily it produces hot water on board a ship.
That's essentially the main purpose, because AIDA passengers want to have showers.
At least
warm ones.
It's located in the engine room, in the machinery space.
Fire is generated using various fuels to create combustion in a burner.
In a burner, you don't simply produce a flame like a gas lighter -- instead, through a specific velocity and fuel-air ratio, the fuel is optimally utilised.
That's what we call the productivity aspect at Saacke.
So I create a fuel-air mixture that achieves a high utilisation of the calorific value contained in whatever fuel is being used.
Then this flame, which can be up to seven, eight, ten, twelve metres long, sits inside a boiler -- essentially a metal vessel, if you'll forgive the simplification -- with various fire chambers, hollow spaces in which the flame develops, and through heat transfer via the material or steel,
you ultimately get hot water or steam.
Thank you!
And in the marine sector, these are so-called steam boilers that produce hot steam.
It's a different technology.
Some use high-pressure systems, and in other applications lower pressures are used.
Understood?
You once said that you burn things no one else dares to burn.
What should we picture when we hear that?
What can we think of?
Well, first of all, one classic example that's been very much in demand over the past two years is hydrogen.
I believe we first burned hydrogen back in nineteen eighty-six.
That gives you a sense of why we're known for being the people you turn to when no one else can industrially combust something -- in a laboratory, you can burn just about anything.
Then you come to Saacke.
Christian, where do you burn hydrogen?
In which applications?
You mentioned a few just now -- can you say where it happens?
Well, at the moment there's really only one industrial application.
That's the BMW plant in Leipzig, where we've equipped the paint-drying facility with these burners.
The thing is, one hundred per cent hydrogen isn't yet available there, and that's really the core problem.
We're currently delivering a steady, if not huge, number of burners that are H2-ready.
So they're capable of hydrogen combustion.
But the customers simply don't yet have hydrogen available in their pipelines.
And what else gets burned?
The simplest thing is gas.
Then of course there's heating oil.
Saacke grew big through the combustion of heavy fuel oil.
Heavy fuel oil isn't a single substance -- it comes in vastly different qualities.
You can imagine that when it comes straight from the borehole, it's very mixed and contains a lot of sand.
It needs a certain viscosity; it's sometimes tar-like and has to be heated.
And then burned.
Creating the fuel-air mixture is a mechanical process.
And that's technology that was originally developed back in the
nineteen thirties, and from which the company has evolved.
Let's move on to Saacke then -- first of all, many thanks.
I think the picture is quite clear now of what exactly you do.
Fascinating business.
The global market, I've read, is around three and a half billion euros and is growing at a compound rate, supposedly through to twenty-thirty-five.
So annually, on average, around six to six and a half per cent -- we'll certainly come back to that.
In Debugged, I always like to look a little more closely.
So when we talk about the organisation -- what's the strategy?
What about executing the strategy?
What matters most? What does your daily business look like?
How is it structured?
What can we learn from it?
And then culture, leadership -- there's still that to look at.
Afterwards, we'll gladly have a look at the competitive landscape.
But try to summarise the strategy in a nutshell for a friend --
as you know, give it a go for the listeners.
So what's the 2030 strategy?
Well, first of all, the strategic objective -- I'd put that front and centre -- is that we need to achieve an equity ratio of thirty per cent.
That's what the financial community reflects back to us as the strategic target at group level.
We have various opportunities in our environment that we can exploit better.
In the marine market, there's still very strong demand for our products.
Our strategy here is to expand the customer footprint -- to deliver more adjacent products that we can manufacture.
We have a highly capable plant in China and want to perform better there -- moving somewhat away from standard products towards more customer-specific solutions that build on our technological expertise.
We may come back to why that's an attractive positioning when we discuss the competitive landscape -- one that's probably more sustainable going forward.
Our major focus is the service excellence theme.
Serving our customers even better across the lifecycle of their products -- or rather our products -- selling them more and binding them more closely to us.
Is that... You sent me the strategy document, and I had another look at it yesterday.
You have seven strategic levers.
One of them, I believe, is 'expand the base', and what you've just described, this service excellence --
Where does that sit within those seven levers?
There's a lever called 'defend installed base' -- defending our installed base so that essentially anyone who has a Saacke burner never buys another brand again.
That's the strategic objective behind it.
Can you bring that out of the abstract and anchor it in a concrete example, perhaps from the past year or twelve months?
Something you could point to when explaining it to someone in the organisation -- saying, this is what we mean by that?
Defend the installed base.
Well, firstly, we've mapped out a classic lifecycle model showing how the systems operate, and that's been communicated.
I think the first steps, once a burner is installed, involve the first major scheduled maintenance -- there's regular servicing that obviously needs doing.
That goes without saying.
But then, to increase customer loyalty, the first things that come up after five to ten years, depending on the application --
that's when you'd modernise the control system.
We have our own control system that we supply. Electronic components are what fail or become obsolete first.
And offering a modernisation to the latest control system from our house, with a new control cabinet, is the first step towards binding the customer closely to us.
Can you give a concrete example -- without naming names, of course -- of customers where this 'defend installed base' strategic direction is already taking effect?
Well, firstly, it's working with all our marine customers. That's going very well.
And with...
What's the difference?
So I'm a marine customer of yours, and you've nicely described what the technology does -- how do I now experience Saacke differently in relation to this strategic lever? What's happening for me now that wasn't happening before?
I think we're very close to the operators there.
We talk to them, know precisely which systems they have installed.
What condition the systems are in.
This isn't yet digital,
but we track when the last service was done and when the last overhaul took place.
In the marine sector -- and I should clarify, by marine we don't mean the navy but rather commercial shipping.
There's been an enormous consolidation over the past fifteen to twenty years, and we work very closely with a handful of major customers.
And we try to stay very close to the operators -- the people who actually run the ships.
What else could you have done?
Where you deliberately said, no strategic focus on that?
We've had a lot of internal discussion about simple maintenance and repair work.
Where you're essentially just competing on hourly rates with competitors.
And for me, it's difficult to put it simply.
It's more important that we work on delivering genuine added value for the customer.
The goal is -- a burner is typically said to have a twenty-year lifecycle, and a boiler, the large metal casing around it, about forty years.
Our goal is, and we're achieving this step by step, to extend the burner's lifespan to forty years as well.
Meaning no more downtime.
That works quite well on ships.
It also works well onshore. And once you've understood that and the analysis supports it, you can develop products accordingly.
The next products we develop will also be able to do this -- so I don't have to touch the boiler itself; I can replace the internals and try to manage things via the control system.
That's
where your technological expertise comes into play.
We'll perhaps come back to the competitive differentiators later that play a role here.
So, regarding the 2030 strategy -- you say the equity ratio of thirty per cent is the target, that's the financial goal.
You want to achieve that organically -- or rather, you have to achieve it organically?
We just briefly touched on the 'defend installed base' strategic direction, the service excellence theme.
You also have 'expand installed base', and then there's operational excellence, digitalisation.
I can't remember all seven off the top of my head.
Is it worth picking out another one because you'd say it's a core focus of the strategy?
I think this operational excellence theme must always go hand in hand with every growth initiative.
For me, it's important that we keep doing the fundamentals.
Especially when you're coming out of a restructuring, all sorts of wishes suddenly resurface.
It's simply about maintaining the focus -- that we still have the mindset of getting a little bit better every single day.
And that's why operational excellence, alongside 'defend installed base', is hugely important to me, because it's all delivered by our people.
Service happens on-site first and foremost, and then it's about making sure all the processes are organised so efficiently and leanly that the service technician on-site feels fully supported by the organisation back at base -- the parts are there.
They've had the training and the tools so they can really focus on the work at hand, and that's an equally important part of this service excellence theme.
So that means the growth can essentially only come from the 'expand installed base' direction?
Both, actually --
because if we can extend our product portfolio further, we can deliver more to customers in that area.
There are also customers we simply haven't visited in ages.
Those are also strategic directions.
None of this is rocket science, but you have to focus on it, do the work, and steer it properly.
And my hope, through this clear approach and the focus on these seven priority themes across the entire company, is that we can ensure we're doing the right things in the right order.
What worries you?
What are you afraid of if things go wrong?
Or do you even know that feeling?
I know it from my day-to-day business -- the worry about what happens if a project doesn't materialise.
If the revenue doesn't come through, or a newly developed product doesn't land well.
Admittedly, I'm often also driven by anxiety.
How is it for you?
Are you immune to that, or are there things that keep you up at night?
Well,
what actually keeps me up at night... We're still very dependent on the EU and Europe, plus the UK. And all the uncertainty we have around the design of our energy policy.
That simply worries and concerns me.
A company today doesn't know which technology, which fuel, or which form of heat generation it should or must back.
On the one hand, we see that electric solutions are reaching higher temperature ranges.
Previously, people would say, well, or higher capacity ranges.
On the other hand, there's no clarity on whether natural gas is really the answer.
A great deal of refitting happened after the Ukraine crisis.
So companies would need to diversify to have an optimal energy mix.
But there's simply no regulatory framework for that, and companies -- especially those that aren't doing well economically -- would rather not invest at all, because infrastructure, including heat generation, for many of them
can hold out another year, particularly if it's well maintained.
And that removes the pressure to invest.
And that's what really concerns me.
That we're heading towards deindustrialisation, and as a result, less and less is being invested.
Then I can devise lovely strategies all I want.
Things simply get run into the ground.
Nobody cares any more whether the system will still be running in twenty years.
That's what really weighs on me.
In the competitive landscape section of Debugged, we'll also talk about competitors making strong inroads with electrification technology.
But you're essentially saying you don't quite know, one hundred per cent, given these broader conditions, which horse to back.
Would that be fair to say?
Yes, I think we have ruled out making electrification a core competence of our own.
We already offer a hybrid boiler in the marine sector -- one that runs on fuel combustion but is also at least prepared for electric operation.
But we won't be able to build that as a core competence of our own -- simply nobody would believe us!
We stand for combustion technology.
So we'll continue to develop where our core competencies lie. And I believe there are many opportunities in the combustion of residual and waste materials.
In disposal-related areas that simply open up new avenues for us.
Understood.
Let's move from strategy towards execution and transformation.
Looking back over the years since you joined Saacke -- that'll be nearly five now.
What have you really followed through on consistently?
On the one hand, things you're proud of -- and what has failed?
Can you think of things in both categories?
Do you see anything?
Well, one thing that worked really well was the entire relocation of our marine business to China.
And that at a point in time after which we ran straight into an absolutely booming market.
So,
that was previously in Bremen?
Exactly.
We'd already had a plant in China for over twenty years for boiler manufacturing.
But in Bremen, the burners were still being manufactured and then shipped to China for assembly.
We started relocating the burner production a bit earlier.
But the entire project execution -- that was really the key: Chinese project engineers and Chinese project managers working with Chinese shipyards.
The complete
value chain is in China.
How much revenue do you generate in China, roughly?
About forty million.
So quite substantial.
So that was a smart decision, consistently executed.
Exactly.
Worked brilliantly!
What went wrong?
What had you planned, and where would you say in hindsight --
that really went pear-shaped?
What really went wrong was this high-performance assembly concept in Bremen. We'd tried, in the first phase of the restructuring, not to close the entire plant but instead to set up a flow assembly line. That completely fell flat.
What
does high-performance assembly mean? What should I picture?
We tried to move from what had been a very pronounced island manufacturing setup, very much a traditional workshop approach. And I really wanted to introduce a takt-based production system -- and that was the problem.
Had you seen it work elsewhere?
I'd introduced it elsewhere -- I did it in Wildeshausen with... That's a formative experience for my entire career, because we implemented it there with Japanese courses.
You can see the grin on your face -- clearly a successful project.
Yes, it was above all an incredible cultural experience, because a former manager from a major lorry manufacturer came in and ran workshops with the entire team every six weeks, through an interpreter.
And that's how we drove it forward.
Why didn't it work at Saacke?
At Saacke, it didn't work because I believe we didn't engage deeply enough with the product configurations. And that's why it simply didn't function.
We had far too many errors; we couldn't manage the parts supply to the workstations and so on.
So we didn't achieve the competitive advantage we were after.
If
you look at that really critically, Christian -- I don't know what psychologists would call this bias; perhaps some can help us in the notes --
but this phenomenon comes up quite often: as a top manager, you have positive experiences with a certain approach in one company.
And you then carry that as an experience bias, thinking along the lines of 'every nail just needs this particular hammer, and it'll work'.
How do you view that self-critically?
Could it be that you fell in love with the approach and therefore applied it?
Or would you say, no, we genuinely thought it through, but it still didn't work for the reasons you've outlined?
Or would you say in hindsight -- is that normal?
My experience bias.
How did it catch me?
I don't look at it that way. I look at it differently.
The analysis wasn't thorough enough.
You have to analyse certain things before making a decision, and the analysis -- not just mine, because I wasn't deep enough in the data --
but from the entire team, it simply wasn't deep enough to properly assess the risk or identify the gaps. And then perhaps a different decision could have been made.
When
did you say, stop?
This isn't going to work?
Well, ultimately the market showed us. Twenty-three was still reasonably good, but in twenty-four I could see it wasn't working.
Understood. Well, thank you very much for sharing.
You've given us two great examples of what worked and what didn't in the past.
Looking ahead now, what would you say are the two truly critical success factors for executing the strategy?
Well, one is that we need to return to growth in the onshore segment, and globally at that.
That's not just about Bremen, which is still the largest division.
But getting back into growth there and really securing the projects that suit us -- it's important that we don't shoot in the dark!
And on the other hand, winning back customer trust. With any relocation, you inevitably shake confidence in your delivery reliability.
It's really critical that we regain trust, including within our own sales team.
Because if your own salespeople no longer believe that you can deliver on what they're promising to customers, they won't go out there with their heads held high either.
Let's
have a look at this sales topic.
There's that old saying: what got you here won't get you there.
If you now need to -- and you do, to hit your financial targets -- move into real, significant profitable growth.
That means you'll have to do sales differently from before.
So what does it look like?
It's 2030 now.
You've stepped into the time machine -- you know my strategy target-picture game -- you step out, you look at the sales team.
What do we see?
2030 at Saacke?
What's different compared to 2026?
I believe we'll have two types of sales.
One is very transactional, which we already largely have with our shipyard customers in China, and we'll have pushed that further.
We'll also have that in the onshore segment, because we'll have better developed key accounts and will work more closely with them, essentially as a system supplier for larger systems.
That's mode one. Mode two will be a much more advisory-driven sales team, where we help customers reduce their CO2 footprint, deliver bespoke systems where combustion technology is the key.
We're obviously not going to become general contractors building houses
and so on,
but this technology will once again be a very strong focus for us.
And we'll be in a position to deliver that globally -- not just around our own parish, but with a global team that actually implements this advisory sales approach.
Do you have that team today?
Who'll still be there for this kind of sales?
Or will it require new people, new skills?
And if so, which ones?
I think I do have some of the right people.
But I don't have all of them. What
sort of people are you looking for to make this happen?
Well, on the one hand, for the system sales to OEMs, I need people who are commercially minded -- with less of a technical orientation, who better understand the customer's commercial requirements and can translate that within the organisation.
I think what we also need is a support team behind them.
Perhaps we have the individual competencies, but we don't yet have the team in place.
We'll perhaps come to that in the culture and leadership section -- the fourth dimension we want to explore.
And the other thing is that we really need to strengthen our engineering capability.
That's a classic issue, I think, that I've seen in many companies -- that at some point, they tried to employ fewer and fewer engineers, the very thing that made the company great in the first place.
Somewhere in the twenty-tens, or a bit earlier, only commercial training programmes were offered, with no engineering apprenticeships in the company any more.
And I believe that's what we need to push forward again -- that we are an engineering company and that we offer attractive workplaces for engineers, whether they're process engineers or otherwise.
But I think that's the other crucial thing: that we succeed in exciting these people again about what we do.
Let's briefly look at your operating model, operations -- because you've just hinted that you're global... You call this pillar, I've been looking at my notes, 'global alignment', where you essentially say, look:
global optimum beats local optima. But at the same time, you have local operating units, and the German upper Mittelstand as I know it has essentially practised a model for decades
where local sites are meant to work independently, in whatever way suits them best.
They know the local market, and so on.
And you come along and say, no, we have to think globally.
We also need to standardise things across our various locations -- probably not identically, but similarly.
How does that fit?
The German Mittelstand tends to do it the other way round.
And you say, at Saacke, we're doing standardisation over localisation.
Could you put that in context -- the way you'll be creating value, across what I believe are twenty countries,
seventy locations? That's not exactly straightforward, particularly with China, Argentina, Croatia, Germany, et cetera.
Could you give us some orientation and perhaps resolve this apparent contradiction?
I grew up in corporate environments myself -- I started my career at ABB, specifically drawn to that topic. 'Think global, act local' was the theme that interested me.
But those were different-sized units.
I mean, the German subsidiary alone had, I can't remember exactly, tens of thousands of employees.
We have many sites with seven, eight, or ten people.
And for corporate governance, particularly for liquidity management but also for capital management, you need certain commercial and administrative capabilities and qualifications.
And how will your own operating model change, in inverted commas?
The way you operate -- if you still want to hold the same role as today, or what changes?
What I'm missing is simply that I can't spend enough time thinking about the future.
Especially in recent months, I haven't had the time.
I still need to take two or three steps in terms of building up the leadership structure and organisation, so that I can actually focus on the things that will make the company successful in 2030 and beyond.
Those two or three things -- could you name them briefly?
Yes, I need a proper leadership structure for the global business units.
For the onshore segment, and I need to start setting up these two sales themes.
So we're working on those right now.
They then need to be executed with the right people.
But initiating all of this is what I've set myself as a target for the end of Q3.
There's a rumour or myth that top managers are either good restructurers or good growth managers.
You can sense the provocation behind that?
How do you view that?
Well, I know I've managed to do both before.
That's
reassuring at least!
That gives me a certain confidence that I can do it again.
I think the question is always: why do you stay at a company for so long
when you came in as a restructuring manager?
You mentioned 2021 earlier.
Did you actually achieve all the targets?
Why didn't you just say, right, next one -- tick the box on your CV and move on to the next assignment?
Because that's just not what genuinely interests me. The turnaround work is only the first step.
I'm a great believer in the thesis that a restructuring has
a completely different root cause than what appears on the surface.
I believe in the strategic crisis and the earnings crisis.
Because I've seen it so many times.
And before that, there's a shareholder crisis.
There are almost certainly cultural problems beforehand too.
And I believe it doesn't help
if I just fix the liquidity crisis but don't address the other issues -- because otherwise, in two years, you're back where you started. And many people in restructuring management have experienced exactly that.
They come in and are presented with the S6 report or the predecessor reports from three previous managers, and you're right back in the same situation.
So the growth theme interests me enormously.
After a certain period, you know the company quite well, and from there you can develop a growth strategy.
And I find that exciting.
And the mindset?
Because you've said it yourself -- for years, in restructuring mode, you've had to focus inward, on yourselves, as you've described.
So the gaze turns strongly inward.
Growth requires exactly the opposite.
While continuing to develop operational excellence, your focus has to shift outward; you need to develop a vision.
You just said, self-critically, that you don't yet have enough time to think about the future.
Do you believe you can switch between these two mindsets?
Or what would you advise other CEOs?
How to manage it?
Because we do have a situation in Germany at the moment where quite a few larger Mittelstand companies are in crisis mode.
And I see that leaders who've been accustomed to growth often struggle with this and frequently act far too late with the necessary consistency.
What about you?
How do you do it?
Or can you try to offer tips on how people might switch between these two modes?
Or is it more of a sort of hybrid mode?
I don't know, but for me it's always been the case that when I start a restructuring, I still need to know where I want to be in three years, because otherwise I'll make wrong decisions from the very beginning.
So you always need that forward-looking view of what the company should look like.
Whether it actually gets there is another matter.
But I think that's often forgotten -- even in the S6 report, it always comes back to market and competition.
And where is the positioning?
And it's really important to think that through carefully.
So it's not that difficult from that perspective.
I actually see it the other way round.
The cost-cutting factor, the restructuring mode -- the personnel and internal focus -- is a means to an end.
It's not an end in itself. I don't cut costs for the sake of it. It's a means to an end, so that you can then push towards something else.
Along
the lines
of:
you can't
save your way to success? Exactly, and that's how I look at it. And I think that's why there's no contradiction for me.
I know that I'm not someone who could pull off those Silicon Valley growth strategies where you go all-in on one bet and treat it like a gamble. I don't think I could do that. I come
from a mechanical engineering background where I can develop growth themes step by step, spot market opportunities, and then align the organisation to actually seize them.
And for me, that's not so different in terms of modus operandi from a restructuring.
If I also have a goal -- but a goal in order to achieve something -- then for me, it very much comes down to being able to analyse a goal well, formulate it well, communicate it, and get the organisation behind it.
For those listeners who are in a phase of difficulty -- and we do have a structural crisis to manage in this country right now -- a tip from Debugged, or perhaps one or two questions to reflect on.
Take your time to reflect on this -- what would you say to them? They're probably not a restructuring case, but they're in a difficult phase.
EBIT has come down, perhaps revenue has dropped too.
What would you say from your experience?
Think about the following two or three questions -- or perhaps it's just one. What comes to mind?
Well, the first question I would always ask myself is: what does this company stand for?
And that's not easy to answer, because often when you go into a crisis, the company's original core competence has been buried under all sorts of things.
And I believe that's the first question. It's not one that you can answer as an outsider, as a restructuring manager.
It's a question where you have to talk to many people.
I think that's the question I'd always ask in that situation.
Even if you've already been CEO for three, four, five years -- you'd say take the time to talk to people about it?
Exactly, and self-critically ask
whether perhaps you've driven things in directions you shouldn't have -- because that happens to everyone.
You see a quick opportunity and think, we should do this.
It's not too far off the beaten path. But I think that's really important, because it's the most essential foundation for making good decisions.
Can you share how you answered -- or uncovered -- this question at Saacke back then? Did you work out what the company stands for, and what it actually stands for today?
Have you got a grip on it?
Well, I think -- why do I keep coming back to this? Probably because... there were always these phases of time pressure, and I probably didn't take -- or didn't have -- the time to really get to the bottom of it.
Because of course, the people who are already there keep giving you the same obvious answers, and perhaps I would have made some decisions differently if I'd truly got to the bottom of that question and really understood what I was being told.
I think we focused too heavily on the product.
Describing Saacke as a burner manufacturer is far too narrow, because the real strength lies in process engineering.
We deliver firing systems and perhaps more accurately, solutions. 'Solutions' is an overused term today, but the idea of pulling small-scale systems into this space where we differentiate through engineering know-how.
And there, I believe I lacked this strategic clarity. Those issues were simply missing, and it doesn't break anything, because you don't radically change such core themes overnight.
But I think we would have taken fewer wrong turns if that had been much clearer to us, and perhaps would have cut some things sooner.
When you say 'talk to as many people as possible' -- what's your practical tip?
Whom should I talk to?
I'm a Mittelstand entrepreneur.
My company's performance isn't exactly where I'd like it to be.
I'm picking up on your point.
Right, what's the core of this company?
What's the one driving force we should focus on?
What's your practical tip?
It sounds silly, but I think it's often about listening to the difficult employees within your own organisation.
It's a truism, I know.
Some have nothing useful to say, and you'll figure that out quickly enough.
But I think many of them, if you take the time, can tell you a great deal -- especially those who've been around a long time.
That's always been true in my case when I come in. Listening to them and distilling what they say.
That's really important, I believe.
And then corroborating the whole picture.
You can certainly commission a market study as well.
Talking to customers is also very important, in my view.
Why do you actually buy from us?
They've often been buying for twenty or thirty years, because these are capital goods companies, especially in mechanical engineering. And that's perfectly valid.
So really looking at it from multiple angles, to see: what does this brand actually stand for?
Yes.
Let's move into the fourth dimension before we come to the competitive environment.
We've talked about strategy, a bit about how you execute things, and a bit about the operating model. Culture, leadership -- what are the core values that are actually lived at Saacke?
Not what you might have plastered on the corridors, but what genuinely characterises Saacke in the way people work together?
Well, you described the picture from the international management conference.
This trusting, almost familial way of interacting is certainly something that people from outside always find remarkable.
I had a colleague who was supporting me, and after the first few days, he said the people are so kind to one another there.
And you can also see the double-edged nature of that, because then people don't quite challenge each other or give each other a kick up the shins.
But it's certainly something that's rooted in mutual respect and appreciation.
So...
Trust, respect?
Respect --
that's definitely there.
And the other thing is a genuine interest in working in an international company.
The experience of people coming from all over the world.
And it's a real joy to see them all, and everyone loves coming to Bremen.
Bremen isn't exactly the place in the world -- if you had your headquarters in Sydney, it'd be different.
But still, that's just how it is, because people feel at home there, they know each other well.
That I also find interesting -- and something that's definitely a positive -- is a pride in the technology.
Pride?
I'd say trust, respect, pride.
Yes, I think that's really important.
Fits.
I have to say, speaking of the management conference you mentioned --
I had the pleasure of meeting your two Australian colleagues about a month ago.
And you could genuinely see it in their faces -- they were delighted to be coming to Bremen, the proverbial eye of the needle of the world.
Sharing.
Your shareholders -- it is a one hundred per cent family-owned company.
Do they share these values, or are there also areas of friction, different perspectives?
No, I think these values are very much shaped by the family.
They're very personal things that have been passed down from the previous generation as well.
I think that's really deeply ingrained.
Genuine corporate culture.
Can you place Saacke in the competitive landscape of your three most important competitors?
Briefly.
So who are the three key players?
I've had a look at a few myself -- whether that's Honeywell, Weishaupt, and Caldera.
The latter is in the US, I believe.
Are those the right ones?
Where would you look?
Well, if you look at the marine business, there are essentially two key competitors.
I'd point to Alfa Laval -- they're a multi-billion corporation and a major ship outfitter, and in many respects they're also the benchmark in our space.
For us. In the onshore segment, the competition is somewhat more fragmented.
Huge competitors are emerging in China that are also technologically very strong.
There's a company called Ebico that we're watching very closely.
What's
the name?
Ebico.
They're very strong, with sophisticated technology and good emission values, but at very competitive prices.
Not cheap, mind you. We've always compared ourselves with Weishaupt, particularly in European export markets -- that was always the head-to-head.
But I think -- and this is what I was trying to get at earlier --
if you differentiate us at root level, they operate in a completely different competitive space.
If you look at how their market segment is structured, they supply high-quality, reliable products.
They're a product manufacturer with completely different volumes, different themes.
With a different ambition and different know-how in the sense that
they have a much deeper manufacturing know-how. For us, it's more about process engineering.
If
it's not Weishaupt, then who would be a relevant competitor?
Well, in an international context, there's certainly Oilon from Scandinavia.
Interesting company -- they pursued a very good market development strategy early on, always leading with manufacturing plants.
But they also moved into heat pumps very early.
So that's certainly an interesting competitor who may be less of a threat to us in the burner market than they were two or three years ago.
And then, in the global competitive landscape, there are the Americans.
Siko and John Zink come from the same background -- both belong to an American industrial group, I believe.
Those are the ones you'd be looking at.
Which
of them scares you the most?
None of them really scares me.
Because I believe we have an enormous opportunity in China that we're currently not capitalising on.
So that's the important thing, and...
Where does that opportunity lie?
In growth -- simply selling many more burners.
We should be selling three to four hundred, and that's not something that takes ten years -- if we do it right, more like three to four years, because it's partly a reseller business.
And why is China so attractive?
Because Chinese boiler makers and system builders are expanding into Africa?
Is there something to that?
You mentioned earlier that you've deliberately chosen not to pursue electrification of the combustion business.
Some of your competitors are doing that.
Does it play a role?
Electrification --
is that something where you might say, well, that's a strategic bet, and you're saying no, we don't believe in it? You can tell where I'm heading with this -- what do you think?
Well, I firmly believe that electrification -- heat pumps, specifically -- are far more efficient than
any form of thermal combustion.
So I firmly believe that electrification and heat pumps will continue to gain ground, including for industrial applications.
It's a question of the energy mix, though.
I believe intelligent energy management will become essential for industrial companies, hospitals, large buildings -- the ability to switch quickly between sources.
So you'd always want the cheapest fuel available, perhaps with two or three boilers on three different fuels, and one of those might well be
an electric option -- that will certainly become standard within the next three to four years.
But for me, the important thing is differentiation.
What do we bring to the table?
Of course we could sell some off-the-shelf technologies.
We could buy something in, but we're not a trading house -- we see ourselves as an engineering and manufacturing business with plant construction expertise.
And that wouldn't be reflected
if I simply bought in a key component. So to be clear, I'm not ruling out that we'll supply these things, but we won't be manufacturing or developing them in-house.
We won't be developing within that space.
Do you see
a substitution risk on a large scale?
Absolutely. Among the classic strategic threats, that's a textbook one.
The market will shrink as a result.
And yet you still have to master profitable growth?
Yes,
and what gives you the confidence that this -- I don't know whether it's squaring the circle -- will actually work out in the end?
The fact is that many industrial companies still have enormous volumes of waste -- and difficult-to-dispose-of waste at that.
And since we can burn liquids, gases, and even dusts, I believe we're quite well positioned to help them in a completely different way.
They save on disposal costs, reduce their primary energy consumption -- they don't even need to buy electricity
if they burn their waste and use that to generate their heat energy.
So you're definitely thinking, if I understand you correctly, about new business models -- or markets you don't yet serve?
Exactly, and that's the most important thing.
I don't know if I'm imposing my own vision here, but I do think that... I worked for Veolia for a long time, and they're deeply involved in the disposal space.
Many of the issues that occupied us there keep resurfacing, and I believe they haven't been solved -- and they present huge opportunities.
And that's where I believe -- and this is why the advisory sales and plant engineering approach matters -- that we can advise customers on how to repurpose what they'd otherwise have to dispose of expensively, and use it to generate energy and heat.
Very, very exciting!
Christian, to close out this Debugged episode --
a final question: when you eventually step down as CEO of Saacke,
whenever that may be,
what would you like people to say about you and the time you spent there -- and I mean beyond any press releases?
What's the inner sense of legacy where you'd think, if people talk about me in those terms, I'd be pleased?
Well, I don't do many things just to leave a mark.
Having
spoken with you, I'm not sure about that.
I think you've already left quite a substantial mark.
Yes,
but I don't do it in order to leave one.
But
you do want to make a contribution.
Of course. I think one thing is certainly to have led a company through a very difficult period back into a good future.
That's perhaps one... The second is that I provided direction and brought people along -- that it was a collective effort.
I actually think that's important!
And that it was enjoyable -- I'd want to add that too.
That the collaboration wasn't deadly serious, but that despite all the stress and all the challenges, there was always time for a smile as you walked through the building.
Lovely. I mean, I can certainly sense that -- and I don't know you from ages past, but I know you fairly well -- that you don't take yourself or things too seriously,
as you've just described, and yet you're very clear and consistent in what you do.
Thank you so much for everything you've shared today. It's anything but a given -- this openness and composure, even with what you'll forgive me for being somewhat provocative questions and follow-up probes.
I think there's an enormous amount of valuable content in this.
For anyone who found this interesting -- do subscribe to the Debugged episodes.
Christian, a heartfelt thank you for being here. I wish you and Saacke all the best with the profitable growth strategy, and that you have a great deal of fun along the way.
Thank you very much!
Thank you for the conversation.
It was very interesting for me too, and I'd recommend to anyone who's invited to actually do it.
Alongside you, Christian -- a heartfelt thank you to all listeners and viewers of Debugged.
Don't forget to subscribe to the channel!
Debugged thrives on being shared as widely as possible.
If you have suggestions for guests or companies you'd like to see featured on Debugged, please send them in.
And if listeners have questions they'd like addressed that weren't covered today -- on strategy, execution, leadership, and culture --
just write them in the comments -- I'll see them!
And anyone who'd like to get in touch with me, simply email matthias@kolbusa.com.
Thank you very much for listening and watching.
Until
next time!
Industrial combustion technology may sound like traditional engineering, but it is a key sector in the global energy transition. SAACKE CEO Christian Ausfelder speaks about leading a turnaround without slash-and-burn tactics, finding the balance between human decency and hard decisions, and why green technology is not a contradiction to profitability (in German).
AI can be personalised, but it can't be personal.
Without saying that AI doesn't play a role – quite the opposite.
It helps us ensure that the adviser can focus on the topics where they make the
difference.
How many MLP advisers are there?
Twenty, thirty left?
Still two thousand?
If we do everything right, there'll be more.
Despite
AI.
Despite AI, yes.
Welcome to Debugged, our podcast with the top managers of this country. Today I have Jan Berg with me, whom I really like and respect, if I may say so.
What does MLP do?
What can perhaps other companies learn from you in the context of strategy, operating model, culture, leadership?
What's worked for you, what hasn't?
Where are you headed?
And then, with certainty, it'll also be quite fascinating to look at the broader environment.
You yourselves have made AI a major priority.
What does that mean for MLP?
What does it perhaps mean for you personally?
How do you view it?
Yes, and I'm simply looking forward to a good conversation!
Perhaps to get to know you a bit better.
On a personal level.
Last week – this happens to me about two or three times a year – I had a real low, both mood-wise, emotionally, and physically.
I know it's coming.
Have you learnt by now how to deal with it?
So I'm in a bad mood. It starts, in this case it was Monday, Tuesday.
Thankfully, nobody has to suffer through it any more, because I simply reduce communication to a minimum.
My wife and children know the score – he's just not in a great mood right now.
But nobody has to put up with it.
Then unfortunately I had commitments at the company last week – an all-staff meeting.
We do that every six months, so I still had to bring the energy and entertainment, whether it was for sales, development, or anything else.
Of course you can say the show must go on.
Do you know what that's like?
Or is it something you don't experience?
And you'd say no, actually I always run at a comfortable, steady pace.
Anyone who'd claim they're always at the same pace
would be lying.
Of course everyone experiences it, and the task is simply, in everyday life, not to let the fluctuations get too big.
There are always those moments, and the question is: what can I allow myself in which moment?
How do I manage to find distraction, and how do I then manage to refocus on what matters?
When was your last moment of that kind?
Can you remember?
Oh, that's not long ago at all – a few weeks back.
Not because something went wrong, but simply because it was a challenging situation. And when you're running at a high pace, when you have a tight rhythm of decisions to make, when you're facing big decisions, then you always need moments to step back. And I try to do that very consciously now – taking an hour, perhaps skipping a meeting, sitting out on the terrace
and
not sitting at the desk, or going for a slightly longer jog to think things through.
And from that everyday rush, stepping back and reflecting on where you actually stand.
I find that crucial, especially when you're making difficult decisions where there might be a different discussion, different viewpoints – to have a clear inner stance.
Then investing time in finding that inner stance means you can deal with many things.
So yes, those moments exist, but dealing with them consciously,
reflecting on where I stand and how I want to proceed,
is something I've tried to get better at over the past few years.
Whether it always works well is another question.
Would you like to share what decision you were wrestling with that was weighing on you?
We made some further changes to our sales structure, and those are always far-reaching decisions. From my perspective they were absolutely necessary, and on balance we've also received a lot of positive feedback. But naturally there's also been negative feedback.
It's also clear that you always get emotional responses, that you affect people in different ways and they're impacted in different ways.
And especially when you make decisions that affect many people, those are the ones I take home the most, the ones that occupy me the most. Because ultimately, it's extremely important to me to bring people along.
Ultimately, it's extremely important to me that people can accept the decisions you make.
That they're convinced the path is the right one.
But you also have to keep reminding yourself – in larger organisations, when you make decisions for, in our case, four and a half thousand people, or in this case for a little more than two thousand colleagues – there will never be unanimous feedback.
And it's naturally also the case, especially when you do things differently, that one person will think it's better and another will think it's worse.
And those are simply the moments that occupy you the most.
That's how I'd describe it.
Perhaps to make it concrete?
I can recall a decision of my own from September last year, where I'd opted for a substantial restructuring. The consequence was that an entire department was completely reorganised.
And there were quite a number of people there – no matter how much effort I'd put in, I couldn't have taken them along emotionally.
They simply weren't going to come along.
I always think the crucial thing is... I spoke about inner stance earlier.
One part of that inner stance must be: I'm doing this because I'm convinced, based on everything I know and after a professional discourse, that it's the best thing for the company.
And if it's the best thing for the company, then in the long run it's also the best thing for the people.
That's the first point.
And the second point is to say: I personally want to do everything to have the highest possible chance of acceptance.
Whether everyone can ultimately say 'I can accept this' is another question.
But I personally want to put a lot into the balance – listening, hopefully being empathetic, explaining things, providing context, but also simply taking time for personal dialogue, being able to put things in perspective. And very often it's the case that
you've just described a change process.
I think we all regularly go through change processes.
You have the proverbial reflection gap – you've thought about it, perhaps for months of preparation.
And then you share it with someone, communicate it to people, and they perhaps didn't know about it at all or are in a completely different place.
And then first closing that perception gap, understanding it rationally but also processing it emotionally.
That simply takes time, and you have to accept that.
So the crucial thing is always: am I convinced it's right, is it also right for every individual even if they might feel differently about it in the short term? And the other thing is simply seizing the opportunity to do everything to achieve exactly that acceptance.
And acceptance doesn't mean that you think everything is right.
Acceptance means I can accept that there were good reasons for taking this path.
We'll definitely come back to this when we talk about the organisation.
The low I had wasn't about a decision – it was simply being burnt out.
Do you experience that too?
Of course, everyone's been through that.
You know the feeling.
I can't think of a phase in my professional life where I'd say it lasted for a prolonged period.
But there are certainly phases where you consciously need to step back, relax a bit more, and give yourself a bit of space.
Those exist.
Sometimes it's simply because a year is ramping up, because there are lots of things going on.
The classic ones are the summer break.
But that also has something to do with knowing that a break is coming.
Then you just feel like you're done and need that break.
The second classic would be the Christmas break.
Just before Christmas there are always lots of events, meetings, sessions, celebrations
and so on.
That's also a classic phase in the year where you say, right, I need some air to breathe.
And that feels good. But of course it also happens in between... But I can't think of a phase where I'd say I felt truly burnt out.
But in the sense of needing to take my foot off the accelerator or simply putting everything aside for a weekend – that's part of it, and I think it's important.
Have you developed a fixed routine for yourself?
Something that helps you manage the high workload you clearly have?
For me, I've learnt that every three weeks I need four days off.
Usually Thursday and Friday. And precisely when I don't stick to it, as has been the case these past few months, that's when I pay the price.
Yes, I haven't quite managed to establish what you've just described. But I think you can also ritualise things in small ways. And for me, the ritual is, for instance,
I always go jogging in the morning when I'm on a business trip.
Why do I do it on business trips?
Well, A, it's naturally a framework for me, and it's clear – when I pack my suitcase, the running shoes are in there.
B, I also have a bit more time there than at home with the family and the children, where you naturally want to be there in the mornings. So it's a ritual that helps me. At the weekends, taking as much time for the family as possible, always doing sport at the weekends, and also letting it be a holiday of sorts.
The celebrations you mentioned are part of it too – the Christmas period. And you're also in an environment where you probably need to look after your sales structures quite intensively.
Do you enjoy celebrating at the company?
I don't!
I'm a trained extrovert.
That means anything I can avoid in terms of client dinners and networking events, I avoid.
What about you?
No, I don't avoid them. I enjoy going and I see it as a privilege to be able to look forward to seeing colleagues.
And that's the way it is at our company. I'll perhaps come to it later.
I've been with the company for many years, more than two decades. And the decisive thing for me has always been the togetherness, and that togetherness has been exceptionally positive.
That doesn't mean I never have different opinions, or that others don't see me critically, or whatever. But when you have a good rapport and look forward to seeing your colleagues, I find that's an incredible added value.
On the one hand, you stand for what the company wants to achieve, and on the other, you can identify with the 'we', with the people.
That's very pronounced with me.
That doesn't mean you always look forward to every evening event – one has to be honest about that.
Especially when you're in an intense phase, it would sometimes be nice to say: I'm not going to a networking event, whether internal or external. I'm simply going to put my feet up.
Everyone has that in life.
But I enjoy being with my colleagues. We have a campus in Wiesloch and there are often events there, and sometimes spontaneously joining in for a beer in the evening.
I do enjoy that!
And I believe, especially in a people's business – we don't manufacture anything – this togetherness, and I say this very deliberately,
talking about culture and talking with each other is hugely important for a company's success.
I'm really curious for later, when we talk a bit about culture and leadership.
Let's pick that up there!
Perhaps for anyone who doesn't know exactly what MLP actually does.
For our listeners who aren't in the financial services industry... Can you briefly describe, in simple terms shall we say, what does MLP earn its money from?
So what do you
actually do?
If I were to put it in one sentence, I'd say we help companies and people make better financial decisions.
And where do you earn from that?
In management speak, so to speak,
what's your operating model?
Can you put it in really simple terms?
I'm happy to break it down.
So our operating model is essentially advisory.
And advisory is remunerated in various different ways, and advisory for different client groups. MLP grew up and was founded in the classic private client advisory space.
It was always described as: academics advising academics at eye level on all financial matters.
And we've grown as a group in recent years.
But what unites the entire group is this common thread – delivering an excellent advisory service.
And if I look at the different client groups today, our private clients still have a strong focus on those with an academic education.
But also in other parts of the group – high-net-worth individuals at our sister company Feri, institutional clients, pension funds, foundations
and so on.
Corporate clients – essentially the entire German Mittelstand.
We have freelance professionals.
But also, beyond the core MLP organisation, there are intermediaries in the market whom we reach, for example through a subsidiary in Kiel, via corresponding coverage concepts in the property insurance space.
What's the typical MLP client in practical terms?
When do they become a client and how?
You'd
need to distinguish between the different client groups.
Let me start with MLP private clients. And that's also the core entity if you look at our group.
MLP Finanzberatung is the parent company – what MLP exclusively used to be.
Everything else has been added since. And I'm responsible for that entity as spokesman of the board.
And the classic route is still that someone gets to know us during their studies.
In the past, you'd meet physically at the university.
Nowadays you get to know each other through online contact, and we then hopefully demonstrate our competence through seminars and conversations.
We convince people that it's helpful to have someone at their side, and we start during their studies with the first financial questions.
People may have their first questions that can be addressed.
It starts with basic things like an account, a student account, a card, perhaps liability insurance.
First protection elements like disability insurance, which is simply important to take out early. Or a first savings component for retirement, or investments. And then ideally you grow with your client throughout their life.
And of course, as I said earlier about people's business, it can also happen that something in the client relationship doesn't work.
But the ideal model is genuinely that you get to know your client, the client gets to know their MLP adviser during their student years, and they're accompanied right through to old age – and not just as an individual but as a family.
That's why we don't count individual clients but family clients.
And if you consider that an MLP adviser on average has about one hundred and thirty, one hundred and forty family clients,
you can already see the level of advisory intensity that implies.
And throughout life, there are always new occasions to be in conversation.
It's important to meet at least once a year, and that's why we try to describe our services in the way that, from my perspective, they deliver the most value – namely being the go-to contact for all financial questions.
Financial and insurance questions, or just financial?
We subsume insurance under finance.
That's the MLP perspective, and when I look at it... naturally it's a view coloured by my own conviction.
It's clear, that's in the nature of things. But we also look critically at parts of the market because banking, insurance and investment are very often treated separately.
But at the end of the day, it's about my overall financial position. And these things flow into each other and depend on each other. Connecting them, creating a holistic concept, asking the right questions, enabling clients to make decisions.
They can feel confident because they're shown different options without having to be the expert themselves.
They don't start dealing with insurance in one place and investing money in another. When I invest money, when I invest in property, I also need appropriate protection.
I need to protect my family. And so these things are naturally closely interconnected, which ultimately feeds strongly into the topic of retirement planning.
So when I talk about financial planning for old age, I can't say: I have this here and that over there.
It always has to be an integrated concept.
And being the go-to contact for all financial questions – that's also what we'd describe as our USP, our distinguishing feature, our clear unique selling proposition.
Perhaps to make it tangible – our clients on average use at least three advisory fields with us.
That means we systematically connect the investment and insurance worlds.
And the industry is structured differently, because it thinks very much from the perspective of individual product providers.
There are the insurers, there are the asset management companies, and there are the banks.
And our task is to bring these different perspectives together, from a deep conviction that this creates more value.
Tell me, you're listed in the MDAX – and forgive me if I don't have all the figures in my head.
About half is in free float.
The other half is also held by larger insurance companies.
I recall Hanse-Merkur, can't remember the others right now – you'll know them.
It rather smells like you might have to serve your shareholders somewhat,
and push their products a bit.
Or would you say
absolutely not? If you give me two minutes – it might actually be three –
I'd like to explain the history a bit, and I think then you'll understand it better.
You've just made us a bit bigger than we are, by the way.
I only reluctantly correct you, but I also don't like being bigger than we are.
So – we're in the SDAX.
But we feel very comfortable there. We were in the MDAX before, and perhaps we'll get back there.
We were
even in the DAX once, I believe.
But that's a while ago now. And we were then in the MDAX and have been in the SDAX for many years now.
But to come back to the shareholder structure – the most important thing is that our founding family still holds just under thirty per cent of MLP, and that's truly what's decisive for us!
We can think and act long-term. We can build sustainable strategies. We can consistently implement our strategies.
We naturally have our own ambition for success, but we don't have the classic quarterly thinking. Instead we have conviction, we have what we stand for, our mission – and implementing it with all patience but also all consistency.
That's an enormous privilege!
Being able to think and act long-term as a listed company is genuinely something special and a privilege – and we owe that in particular to the ownership structure, to Mr Lautenschläger and his family. With just under thirty per cent, and this goes back quite some time.
There was a hostile takeover attempt by an insurer.
We carried out a capital increase at the time and were then able to count some product providers – insurers, in this case – among our shareholders for the first time.
That
was
Swiss Life.
Swiss Life – though it was actually the AWD they'd taken over at the time.
The then-AWD had been acquired by Swiss Life via a certain Maschmeyer, and Maschmeyer had bought the shares and passed them on to Swiss Life.
And we then essentially – I think the term today would be 'white knight' –
brought in various insurers with whom we work well and closely, as part of a capital increase.
Who
are they?
Hanse-Merkur?
Hanse-Merkur came in later, and I'd classify them differently.
They made a conscious decision to invest.
But it's primarily Allianz and the Barmenia Gothaer Group.
At the beginning there were also one or two others.
Some of whom subsequently exited again – for example AXA or HDI, who were initially involved. But Barmenia Gothaer and Allianz have been in from the start.
And the good thing is, they were already very good product partners of ours because they deliver good quality. And they essentially helped us protect our independent business model – where we select products independently – against a hostile takeover.
That was fundamentally the rationale.
But we also drew a clear line, and that line holds to this day.
It means no insurer may hold a stake of more than nine point nine per cent in MLP.
Why?
Because German intermediary law stipulates that from ten per cent, I'd have to disclose the shareholder in my initial client meeting.
That would contradict our self-image, our deep DNA of independent advisory.
So we've always said nine point nine per cent is the limit.
And almost everyone adheres to that, at least all those with whom we're in direct dialogue.
And we've never, ever experienced anyone wanting a seat on the supervisory board or wanting a say in product decisions.
Everyone understands that if you protect the model and deliver good quality in terms of service, processes and products,
that's the best thing that can happen. And so we feel very comfortable with this setup and with our shareholders.
You said yourself, you've been there twenty years.
You've also substantially transformed the business model over the past fifteen years – correct me if I'm wrong.
Previously, essentially with your then three thousand, with fluctuations now around two thousand advisers –
perhaps we can also discuss that in the operating model context – you essentially earned your money through new business and have completely turned that around.
I believe over seventy per cent of your revenue now comes from recurring business, from accompanying your clients over the lifespan you described.
Was that by chance?
No, it certainly wasn't!
When did you decide to do that, and how were you able to execute that pivot so consistently?
I can of course relate the history – I haven't had board responsibility for all twenty-two years, so I can share what my colleagues initiated at the time.
And how they implemented it. In recent years I've naturally been part of it too.
But just to say that upfront.
By way of context, there are two dimensions from my perspective.
One dimension is the one we briefly touched on – the question of how broadly diversified we are in this market.
Do we go beyond our original core business of private client advisory?
That first gave us this breadth and stabilisation, and then within the actual private client business, a further broadening.
And both have led to a significantly larger share of recurring revenues.
Indeed, as I mentioned some figures earlier, in 2005 that was around thirty per cent.
Now we have around seventy per cent recurring revenues, and that comes precisely from these two movements.
Why did I pick the year 2005?
Because it was essentially the starting signal for the evolution.
In 2006 we made our first acquisition – Feri, a leading bank-independent asset manager in Germany, one of the leading asset managers, whom we brought into the group.
And the idea behind it has always been: every business model we add must stand on its own, have its own market, and achieve a leading position in that market. And at the same time, it must deliver added value for our core business.
And if I illustrate that with the Feri example, then Feri has its high-net-worth clients,
its institutional clients, as I briefly mentioned earlier.
And at the same time they help us with expertise, capital market expertise.
They help us with fund selection, they help us through their chief economist to always have good market insights.
They also help when an MLP client reaches a size where the MLP adviser says, well, that's not something I deal with every day.
So when I'm talking about investment sums of three, four, five million euros, the MLP adviser can bring in a Feri colleague.
And through that model alone, we've collected more than a billion in inflows, or rather assets under management, in recent years. And those are funds that, in my view, we would never have gathered without that expertise.
That means we live this idea of the group network, and through complementary strengths we're competitive in areas where we previously weren't competitive on our own.
And we've continued down that path – further acquisitions have been added, particularly in the corporate client segment.
That's how the two of us got to know each other. And more besides, which is why the group is simply much more diversified now.
We're active in the mortgage space, we operate as a managing general agent for property insurance and protection concepts, and that all balances out.
For example, when interest rates fall, we benefit in the property segment but naturally have a bit more of a battle in the banking segment, and vice versa.
Or it's very common for corporate clients to have different economic cycles than private clients. And that's the balancing mechanism. And it's clear that through the acquisitions and by strengthening this business – because all the companies we've brought in have grown significantly within the group, since we were able to invest and open up new possibilities –
they contribute to us building our assets under management further,
which generates recurring revenues, and our portfolios in property insurance.
So that's the group-level view.
And the other perspective – what's happening at the level of our MLP advisers and clients – is simply that what MLP has always stood for, namely advising clients holistically,
we've implemented much more consistently in recent years. Because we've brought in expertise in this area, placed a stronger focus on banking and wealth management topics.
But also because clients naturally always have evolving needs.
A young academic entering the workforce has a relatively homogeneous set of needs at first.
They get disability insurance, as I mentioned earlier, a first savings component for retirement.
But as they get older, it's about financing questions, about property questions.
And of course, increasingly about investments.
And that's why we've succeeded in recent years in serving clients much more broadly. Or let me put it another way – when I joined MLP, we were making just under ninety per cent,
or just over eighty per cent of our revenues in the insurance segment alone.
And now wealth management has become the strongest area we've built up.
And that's something that meets client needs.
That's always the decisive factor, and at the same time it then contributes to us being much more stably positioned as a company.
If I read between the lines correctly, the MLP adviser is both crucial for your sales effort
and you've found it difficult to recruit advisers in the volumes you'd perhaps have liked in recent years.
So you're now at around two thousand.
I'd understood there was certainly an aspiration to recruit more.
Has that been a bottleneck for you?
Will it be one in the future?
Why is it like that?
And what does, let's say, MLP do about it?
Now perhaps aside from the other business areas you've outlined – in the private client business.
Essentially you need to demonstrate recruiting excellence.
And why aren't you managing to scale that up further, the way you perhaps once intended?
There are many dimensions to it, and I think the decisive point is this:
We want to recruit as many as possible who are the right fit for us.
I would never drop that qualifying clause. Because in our business model, which has a clear quality strategy, it would be wrong to focus solely on quantity. We need people who fit with us, who embody what we stand for, who share our attitude and our mission, and who make it tangible for the client.
So you've had higher targets regarding the number of advisers?
Why haven't you reached them?
What makes it so difficult?
It wasn't really targets as such.
When we talked about three thousand, that was a phase that's already quite long ago – more than twenty years. And after that we very deliberately recruited far fewer advisers for many years, because we were also repositioning the company under the leadership of Uwe Schroeder-Wildberg.
And we were on a deliberate quality course.
And there were certainly one or two conscious decisions along the way, which is why we deliberately consolidated in this area for several years.
In recent years, the goal has been to recruit more colleagues again, particularly in the young segment, among university students and career starters.
We're doing fairly well there and growing year on year.
But it's also true that because we didn't recruit as many young advisers for some years – and that's why I bring the two dimensions together – we naturally have a demographic challenge.
That's why in 2017 we essentially created our own segment.
We gave the young advisers their own sales organisation.
We call it our university segment, because this area has a stronger focus on recruiting but of course also on preparing young advisers well for the work that lies ahead.
That's been going well since 2017 and getting better each year.
By the way, two or three years ago we also adjusted the entry model to include a trainee model, so that you first have several months to get a feel for the role.
You can complete all the legally required qualifications in that time, focus on your training, and then subsequently switch to self-employed status.
And it works very well.
In recent years we've recruited over two hundred colleagues per year. That's certainly not the limit of what's possible, and we have significantly higher ambitions for the coming years.
Why is it so difficult?
I said earlier that the qualifying clause about quality was important to me.
We need people who fit our business model, and of course the role they're stepping into isn't one that suits everyone.
We're talking about a self-employed role – an entrepreneur within the company.
We're talking about a sales role. And that too in the financial sector.
It's not easy. I have the greatest respect for what my colleagues achieve every day.
Because, as I don't need to tell you, the presumption of innocence doesn't quite apply to the financial industry.
Whether that's fair or not
is an entirely different discussion.
In many respects it's not fair and far too generalised.
But the general public perception of the financial industry isn't a good one, to put it very mildly. And so this kind of role isn't necessarily always well regarded in a young person's social environment or family. That's the first point.
Second point.
Perhaps
you have a follow-up question?
I think I partly understand.
Has MLP itself contributed to this overall impression that's been building in recent years regarding the financial industry?
Our aspiration is to do everything to achieve the opposite. And I'd say with some confidence that I could – without boring you now, we can perhaps do that later or not –
give you many examples showing we do exactly the opposite. That we invest a great deal of energy in the areas where we want to be different, making deliberate decisions that differ from the rest of the industry.
We've confidently moved in that direction.
But it's naturally also the case that roles like ours are polarising in public perception. And as I said, this is a people's business.
When people come together, it can always happen that someone is dissatisfied, even though from our perspective we did everything right.
So yes, there will be such cases.
What's always important to me, though, is that in many instances where we've seen things in the industry that we felt weren't right, we've deliberately taken a stand against them.
For example, what have you done?
Yes, without going into too much detail – there are examples in the industry where contracts are churned, where things are offered that from our perspective aren't always client-oriented.
What
is that?
Can you make it tangible?
Certain products that have a form of remuneration
where we said, that doesn't fit for us.
Those were, for instance, structured fund savings plans and one or two investments that were high-risk.
We've always been very cautious with those, placing great value on ensuring that in our product selection, every product passes all quality criteria.
That doesn't mean there aren't occasionally things that don't work out.
Yes, the crucial thing is always: I do everything to have the highest possible probability of quality.
But of course there have been cases in recent years where clients invested, for example, in care home property
that didn't work out for various reasons – the interest rate environment changed, then there was Covid, and so on.
And they're understandably dissatisfied.
And when there's already a negative public perception, there's naturally a spillover effect.
So you can systemically ensure that you have a high-quality service – and we do that, for example by investing enormously in training and further development.
But that doesn't mean that when an individual experiences a disappointment, whatever the reason, they might not still feel dissatisfied with the service.
And that then takes place within a context that's already not a positive one.
You can see it in the generally high staff turnover in the industry.
Not at your company specifically, but overall – and how high is it at MLP in terms of advisers?
Can you put some numbers on it?
With
the industry, it's always a bit tricky.
Define industry, define competition – I'd rather talk about us!
We have single-digit attrition figures.
I
actually thought it would be higher among the advisers.
It's not higher among the advisers. What is true – and this perhaps goes back to the question from earlier,
and I wasn't quite finished with my answer, so I'll take the opportunity now –
is that when young advisers start with us, the attrition probability in the first two or three years is significantly higher.
But once you've successfully made it into the fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh year, it's very, very low. And overall it's in the single digits.
Jan, what do you base it on, whether someone makes it past three or four years? In other words, if I were to start as an adviser with you now,
keen on financial services, up for sales, and even keen to do it as a self-employed person – I have a question about the leadership model that I'll park for a moment –
how many leave in the first three years?
And perhaps you can share what determines whether someone actually achieves a successful ramp-up.
Very often it's not our decision.
It's also the adviser who decides, and this is the bridge to what we were discussing earlier.
They simply say it doesn't suit me.
In the first three years, how many is that?
Who say, well, it's not what I expected?
Yes, it can certainly be that around twenty per cent per year leave of those who
started.
What's their main reason?
They earn too little?
Or... well, I think
it's simply that you then realise that something you thought in theory might suit you doesn't quite fit in practice.
So you said earlier: I'm keen on finance.
I'm keen on sales and self-employment.
Yes, I'd assume that for everyone who starts with us.
But when you actually begin and perhaps discover that acquiring new clients is harder than you thought – that's one reason, for example, why someone says: I won't be sufficiently successful in this role. Because I need to be proactive in acquisition. And there's nothing harder than going home in the evening with a 'no'.
You've done everything, made a value-adding proposal for a client.
But the client still says no, I don't want to go ahead with it, for whatever reason. And that's to be respected.
That's also right.
But for someone building their livelihood, those are naturally setbacks.
And you have to be able to deal with them.
That
also costs you money.
Essentially you're training people, investing energy and time, and naturally you want as many as possible to stay the course.
In other words, with the volume of sales structure you're building and managing, I'd assume you've got a few key learnings.
That you could perhaps share for other industries too.
What can people learn from MLP and your decades of experience in building sales organisations?
Can you elaborate? You're obviously very much at home in this, that's clear after twenty-plus years.
But do you have learnings that others can draw from?
Whether they're in B2B sales, mainly, whether that's in mechanical engineering, automotive, or anything else... Can you try to distil it?
I can
try to break it down.
But I have to say at the same time, as with our discussion just now,
it doesn't always work.
When we lose people in the first years, I believe it's partly unavoidable, because there are aspects you can describe in advance
but you have to experience them to truly take them on board. And you asked about benchmarks earlier.
We're very much in dialogue with other IFAs – independent financial advisory firms – worldwide. And the fact that attrition in the first years is higher, and at similar levels to ours in comparable business models,
is something you'll find regardless of country, regardless of organisation.
It comes with the territory. That doesn't mean you can't keep optimising, and we do continuously. But that caveat aside,
what can you learn?
Firstly, I think it's extremely important to be very transparent in the recruiting process.
It doesn't help if someone perhaps doesn't yet understand something or has the wrong expectations.
You need to come in with the right expectations.
In terms of what, specifically?
What the role involves, but also what the challenges are and what you need to develop into.
I gave examples just now – how hard it is to deal with rejection, that my task in the first years is to build a client base. Once I have close client relationships and clients contact me of their own accord,
that's something different.
But at the beginning, it's hard graft. And that's a task
that not everyone finds easy – approaching people openly.
So transparency and clear expectation management are, from my perspective, an absolute key factor.
The second thing I'd always say is that personality should take precedence over technical expertise.
What matters is finding the right people who enjoy working with others,
who enjoy developing themselves,
who take pleasure in winning clients, who take pleasure in creating positive client experiences.
I find that more important than technical knowledge.
The technical side you can teach, and that's how it works for us.
Our focus with an adviser is that they have an academic qualification.
At least a bachelor's degree, without specifying a particular subject.
And we say: we'll teach them the rest.
We can do that at our Corporate University, which is a major focus for us.
Of course, if someone has previously studied business or something else in finance, it may come more easily to them. But that wouldn't be the decisive factor.
So I'd look more at personality.
I'd look more at attitude than at technical qualifications.
And the third thing, from my perspective, is that you absolutely must provide excellent support in the first months and years.
And that doesn't work just through good training – it also requires a good interplay between local team leaders who accompany the individual.
If I only say: I'll deliver top training, it can still happen that the individual doesn't get into action.
And if I only focus on the practical side, perhaps the theoretical foundation is missing. Getting that interplay right, achieving a good balance – that's a critical success factor from my perspective.
How important, in the whole topic of sales generally,
and naturally from your perspective and specifically at MLP, are bonus and incentive models?
That's naturally important – having the right models. And it's especially important because you need models that align with what you want to achieve
and what you promise the client.
Otherwise you end up in a schizophrenic state. These things need to be aligned, and that starts not just with the remuneration system but also with reporting and management systems.
If I translate my conviction, if I translate what I want – my mission – into the right set of metrics, then things work in harmony.
If I have glossy slides stating what I want to be for the client, and then lists measuring something completely different, I become unbelievable and would ultimately tear the company apart.
And we've developed significantly as a company in recent years on that front. That would be the decisive point for me.
Just one more point on reporting – the remuneration systems logically follow from that.
What were the key
developments there? You say you've evolved significantly.
What would you say were the
two key learnings where you said, right, we need to adjust this?
I'd reduce it to one key learning, and that one learning is: if I say what I want to stand for,
then everything I steer by and everything I reward must be aligned to that.
And for us, that's the question of how our mission statement connects with performance targets and activity targets.
So we don't steer by an outcome metric – there are companies that do that in sales.
You sell X, and if you manage that, you're successful!
We talk about the activity level.
We talk about wanting every adviser – to give a simple example – to see every client at least once a year. And then it's clear: if I see someone, I lay the foundation for my personal success, and everything else follows from that.
And you're also incentivised at MLP to meet exactly that metric?
We steer by it, we monitor it.
We evaluate the whole thing.
It's not that I get paid for making the appointment. The remuneration arises from the appointment.
But the mindset isn't to say:
we're talking about achieving X in production.
Instead we say: we want every client to be seen every year. And we expect that in around seventy per cent of cases, clients will be seen each year.
And it's also important to then achieve the breadth of offering with those clients.
That becomes the recurring revenue model, ensuring every client actually experiences the full breadth of our offering.
That means – yes.
And I don't want to dispute it, even if I'd sometimes wish it were otherwise.
All bonus and incentive systems in sales, and elsewhere too, tap into human desire for gain.
If we look at it emotionally – does it have to be that way, is there no other option?
How do you view that?
I'm not sure 'greed' is the right word.
Greed would be too negative for me.
At the end of the day, I think – completely independent of sales, in every job, yours and mine and every other –
if you do a good job, it should be appropriately remunerated, however you define 'appropriate'.
That's a basic factor, it's part of it. But it's not the be-all and end-all. I personally tend to divide it into:
hard factors, which include income, and many soft factors within the company.
That includes the culture.
Perhaps we can come back to that later – learning from each other, learning with each other.
Meeting people at eye level.
Do I have something to say?
Do I look forward to meeting my colleagues for a beer in the evening, or is it more of a chore?
From my perspective, that also has great value. And it naturally has a spillover effect too – because when I feel comfortable and I'm in a harmonious environment – and of course that also carries a danger, I realise that –
but when I'm in a harmonious environment, it also has positive effects on earnings.
But it's also clear that you can't compensate for everything with these softer factors when someone says the hard factors are lacking.
And beyond that, I believe that in such a hopefully coherent overall picture, you can certainly set incentives through remuneration components.
Everyone experiences that. But nothing more than that, in my view. Or let me put it the other way round: if the conviction within you isn't there, and if you don't know how to tackle things, then clever incentivisation only helps to a very limited extent.
If you look at the non-sales areas –
you certainly also have something like product management.
You have an HR department, an IT department
and so on.
Are leaders in those areas also paid variably?
Do they have a variable remuneration component?
Would you say that's helpful?
I sometimes get the impression that these variable remuneration systems cause more harm than good – not always, but because they create complexity.
Depending on the company culture, you agree annual targets, attach a variable component of ten or twenty per cent – you can tell me how it works at your company – and then at the end of the year you realise that reality had already overtaken everything by Q2.
Meaning the agreed targets no longer bear any relation to what actually happened, and then you essentially say: well, the target was more or less met, and that's that. Perhaps a bit of an exaggeration.
What's the point of it all?
Could you spare yourself this circus and just focus on the work, with a fixed salary and that's it? How do you view it, aside from sales?
Well,
if it were as you describe it, then you could indeed spare yourself the circus.
At least when it comes to the individual bonus.
Here's how I see it.
We've structured it at our company so that for employed leaders, simplified, the bonus splits into two parts.
One depends on the company's success.
I think that's important in terms of collective alignment and naturally the breathing in the P&L. And the other is the individual bonus.
And I know the debate, I've had it myself. If you approach it dogmatically, agree on something – then of course it can also be a misdirection.
And we all know you can't plan a year in every detail.
We all know the unexpected happens!
We all know we have to adapt. And if targets lead me to invest marginal energy in the wrong things, it becomes positively counterproductive. And one should try to avoid that together.
But that's precisely why there are leaders, and that's why we talk to each other.
And if I know I have a target agreement and something changes, then I need to have that conversation.
And then, as the person with the targets, I'll make transparent why I'm reprioritising.
And as the person deciding, I'll be able to assess whether that makes sense.
Or conversely, I'll have questions!
If no feedback comes about needing to reprioritise targets, that's also a conversation topic – because then clearly a development has been overlooked.
So I believe, in the proper sense... if I don't bind myself too tightly to what's on the piece of paper
but instead start the year saying, ceteris paribus, these are my priorities, with the mutual understanding
that I always act in the best interests of the company – then I get into productive discussions. And those can be very productive.
And would you say money is a necessary condition for these targets to be achieved?
Or would you say, actually it's good leadership –
clear targets, the right conversations, adjustment and support
and so on –
and you could actually do without variable remuneration?
What's your position?
My position is that the decisive thing is good targets and clear goal-setting. Variable remuneration can reinforce that.
I find it quite positive, especially when building something new.
But it alone isn't sufficient – the target is always what matters.
Briefly, in the context of the operating model.
You said the financial industry has suffered a bit in public perception, that it's sometimes viewed askance.
Now the WISO magazine from ZDF gave you an additional bashing.
Would you like to share what the topic was, and what you can understand, or where you'd say it was unfair?
Yes, there was a great deal that was unfair about it. And you know I have a journalism background myself.
So one can always understand...
Perhaps for the listeners,
can you briefly summarise?
You can do it better than I can.
What was the point that such a programme
made?
It was essentially criticism of how we approach people at universities.
That we acquire new clients at universities. And through examples, they showed – or tried to show – that the advice didn't lead to the outcome that the WISO editorial team considered the right one.
But rather?
What was their point?
That you do the whole thing only in order to...?
Well, at the end of the day, the implied accusation is always that you want to maximise your gains, your commissions.
In very general terms – you can take the WISO programme or any number of other examples, and it's not
in the client's interest; the client should have been offered something different.
And there were simply factual errors.
That's the case.
What
would you say the factual errors were?
Simply
incorrect calculations were made.
Things weren't understood. And what personally bothers me – and I'll be candid here because we're all open to criticism.
I talk to consumer advocates, my colleagues talk to consumer advocates. We seek feedback, we talk to politicians, we discuss alternative perspectives.
And it's our job to hold up a mirror to ourselves.
But when someone comes along with blanket criticism, and when they simultaneously ask us questions, we give answers, but those answers aren't even engaged with – when from the outset they say, regarding the calculation in this example – it was about a product – there were errors in the calculation, and they don't even engage with that, and then present our counter-statement in a heavily truncated way.
Then I simply have to say: I don't think that's clean journalism.
And I'll take the liberty of saying I know something about this. And there are very few areas where we actually say: we're going to push back.
In this case we did, because it triggered a deep sense of injustice in me.
One can tell it struck a nerve.
It's simply – we were just talking about young advisers.
These are people building their livelihoods.
And yes, it can always happen that someone makes a mistake.
In this case, they didn't.
But it can always happen that someone makes a mistake, or that people simply don't click – a client-adviser relationship that isn't at eye level.
It can also happen that things intended one way are perceived differently, or that someone communicates clumsily.
Anything can happen. But things that are factually verifiable – calculations, for instance, or the question that's often debated about which product combinations are advantageous or disadvantageous –
there's an objective basis for that. And then I expect at a minimum that the counter-perspective is given appropriate space.
Otherwise it's sensationalism, and a public broadcaster isn't fulfilling its remit.
Let's shift our focus towards forward-looking strategy. For the uninitiated,
briefly and concisely – you know the drill from our work together – as precisely as possible.
What's the strategy going forward?
What is it looking like by 2030, 2035, as you prefer?
What are MLP's corporate strategies?
Are you looking at the overall company now, or – since we've just been talking a lot about the advisers – I just want to draw the distinction clearly.
Happy to do both if you like, and of course for the publicly prominent private client part.
We will – and this may sound boring, but – we'll continue ploughing exactly the same furrow.
Continue leveraging this group network.
We'll continue expanding the breadth of our offering.
And especially in the corporate client segment... You've
got essentially three pillars?
Is that right, can I say that?
Put simply, business areas.
We essentially have key areas of focus going forward, and those are in particular assets under management and the corporate client topic, which will also be strongly reflected in property insurance portfolios. And we've set very ambitious targets for 2028.
And we'll continue down exactly that path – positioning the company even more broadly, further leveraging the opportunities within the group network, in order to be recognised as a leading independent wealth manager, as one of the leading providers in corporate clients, and to continue developing these markets.
So there's nothing revolutionary about it, but it builds on what we've done in recent years. And as I mentioned at the outset, the role of AI is of course important going forward – but always from the conviction that personal advice will definitively continue to deliver added value in the future.
We'll perhaps come back to that later.
Now demographic change means you perhaps can't grow as much as you'd like.
Does that play a role?
At the moment we're... we just touched on it, and we're quite satisfied with how we're recruiting young colleagues.
But of course, when I look at our advisers, they're on average around forty-eight years old.
Of course there's a certain ageing process, and especially in the coming years some people will be reaching retirement.
And that's why it's even more important – and it's important regardless – that people are deployed where they make the difference.
That's the decisive success factor. And that means at the points where things are repetitive, where things are simpler to implement, where it's more of a commodity – that's where I'll make greater use of technology. That's one perspective. And the other is that you should also leverage complementary strengths within the company.
The classic image of an MLP adviser when I became a client
– twenty-two years ago – my colleague, now my current one, back then said to me: I'm your single point of contact and I'll take care of everything.
Would they say it differently today?
They'd say to me: I'm your point of contact. And whenever you have any financial question, you just need to have my number and call me.
But I'll bring the right experts to the table for all your questions.
If it's about a will, I'll bring the solicitor to the table.
If it's about property questions, I'll bring the property expert to the table.
And if perhaps it's about a larger estate, I'll bring the wealth management expert from Feri to the table.
And if you, in your entrepreneurial role as managing director, HR head, or board member, have questions in that sphere, I'll bring in our corporate client specialists. And that's already an evolution – moving towards being more of a relationship manager and networker who brings things together without doing everything themselves.
And so it's a two-pronged approach: leveraging technology on one side, and appropriate division of labour on the other, as a way to address something like demographics.
So that means, purely from a market strategy perspective, you don't want to or won't do anything fundamentally different. But what you describe as the internal transformation – starting with the evolving role you've just outlined –
is significant.
And the evolving role is precisely the transformation I described earlier when we talked about the revenue distribution.
It's a development we've had for years now, one that will continue.
Why?
Because we have ever more expertise within the group, because a different picture is emerging, and because there's simply a level of complexity now where I can't expect one person to do everything.
If I imagine my private client is simultaneously in a finance function at a company, and I'm looking after their occupational benefits,
which might involve fire protection, to take an extreme example.
I can't expect the same person who knows private finances inside out to also handle that. But they need to know someone who does,
in order to deliver a superior service.
And that's what's grown within the group in recent years, and it needs to be developed further.
There's naturally also
or precisely
as you were speaking about forward-looking strategy, there are new fields emerging as well.
And this is something we've been building in recent years but are now accelerating further.
A strong term for us is 'digital ecosystem'. That means we have several companies that we've either invested in, built up, or are just launching, through which we offer adjacent services that the adviser could never be the expert on, but that deliver added value.
I'll give a couple of examples in a moment.
That's probably a bit abstract for now – services that deliver added value for the client and simultaneously allow us to go even broader.
That takes us to the topic of recurring revenues, to stability, and to growth.
And those are the ambitious targets we certainly have towards 2028 in terms of results and revenue. And these are topics that will be added.
Let me give a concrete example.
We've just founded a new GmbH near Munich – Prex Easy GmbH.
It acts as a general contractor for doctors, handling all the organisational and business management questions
that prevent a doctor from simply being a doctor and focusing on their patients.
Now you could ask, what's that got to do with MLP?
Medical professionals have been one of our core target groups from the very beginning. And we've always advised them both in their private sphere and in their professional sphere regarding practice establishment.
We know from our advisory work that the business and organisational side of running a practice is one of the biggest pain points.
You can solve that through an investor model – selling to private equity and becoming a salaried doctor. But most don't want that.
They want to remain self-employed and put their heart into what they studied – their patients.
And so it's about solving these organisational questions.
Now I wouldn't think of doing that within the core organisation. Instead, because it's a very digital business model, it's good to build it as a speedboat alongside the main ship – but not detached from the organisation.
Rather,
the good relationship with the doctor, maintained through the MLP adviser over years and decades, is naturally always there.
Now I have the opportunity to offer a supplementary service on top of what I already provide for the doctor through fees and so on,
something that takes the doctor further.
And I think it's self-evident from the outside that this relates to our core service, but is something adjacent. And when I take such examples, it naturally allows me to deepen the value chain.
More value creation for the client.
And a different value chain for us.
Or another example.
In the corporate client segment, some years ago we co-founded a company with an entrepreneur – he brought in some capital,
we brought in capital too – in the area of corporate benefits: salary sacrifice, job bikes, and so on.
We come more from the classic occupational pension provision, occupational health insurance.
We're the largest broker for occupational pension provision in Germany. But we believe the client interface is becoming increasingly digital, and that things like corporate benefits – in terms of employer attractiveness, adding value for employees, showing appreciation – will keep growing in importance.
When I already look after companies in occupational pension provision, I now have the ability through a very digital business model to offer these services too.
I don't have to be the expert myself, but for the client there's the value of everything from one source. And naturally that opens different value creation opportunities for us.
Continuing resolutely down that path is absolutely crucial. And those were just two examples of several.
So
if we look again specifically at the private client segment – will the MLP adviser even still exist in five years?
Or will I have an MLP AI bot?
They'll still exist, and they'll still exist in ten, fifteen, twenty years.
I'm very convinced of that.
But the role keeps evolving.
It's already changed in recent years – I've given examples. From the one person doing everything, towards a networker and relationship manager who brings in experts. And even today, it's not as if we're not already digital.
I believe I can say with some confidence that we've taken major strides in digitalisation.
Our clients do a lot digitally with us too.
In their financial home, they have the ability not just to see overviews but, for instance, to add funds to their investment portfolio.
We naturally do that already. And that's a different role from twenty years ago.
And that role will continue to evolve.
I said earlier: people operate where people make the difference.
That means there'll be more and more simple tasks that are AI-supported.
To give an example – our motor insurance service centre was almost completely switched to AI support last year.
It's a learning curve, not everything works perfectly straight away. But that's an area where you as a person don't make the difference.
But when it comes to complex retirement planning, inheritance questions, complex investment questions – that's where people make the difference.
What is the difference?
In my words, perhaps:
It's empathy, the ability to listen, awareness of the world, and connecting the individual topics.
And we mustn't forget... let me stay with the motor insurance example.
That's fairly straightforward.
You buy a new car and need motor insurance.
Right, that's a need you want to meet.
And you want good value for money by your own criteria.
You can objectify that!
And in a certain sense, it's interchangeable.
That's not the decisive factor. But there are many other topics
where I have a latent need. And that latent need only surfaces
because I have someone who knows me, who knows my life situation, who asks me questions, who gives me perspectives I perhaps didn't have before – which then make me think about
how I could develop my financial position further.
And that's a completely different thing from the immediate need you had in the example with buying the car.
And meeting that latent need, asking those questions, engaging at eye level, having someone at your side – call them a coach, a companion, we call them the conversation partner – that's where we differentiate ourselves.
But it's also of course an evolution, and it demands a lot in terms of personal competencies.
Two questions about that.
The first – how many MLP advisers will there be?
Twenty, thirty left?
Still two thousand?
If we do everything right, there'll be more.
Oh, really? Despite AI?
Despite
AI, yes.
We'll always be operating in a defined market through our client focus on academics. And we'll never break open our business model
towards the mass market. A few strategic guardrails for us.
We'd never open up our business model towards the mass market, and that's not a value judgement. It's perfectly fine that there are people and companies operating in the mass market.
We'll always have our sweet spot, because we simply believe we can deliver the service we provide much better at eye level, much more customised – and naturally we also see advantages in that for our business model.
Will there still be two thousand in 2035?
Or do you believe AI will develop to the point where it can genuinely provide intelligent advice?
Not just in your area but also in legal, tax?
What's your assessment?
I'm very convinced that AI can be personalised but not personal.
That's an important distinction for me, and I think it sometimes gets muddled in the debate.
I believe we all need to be honest.
When I look at the developments of recent years and extrapolate them, none of us can yet imagine everything that will be possible.
We have to be that honest.
But I carry within me – and we all carry within us – the deep conviction that especially in the business we're in, which is fundamentally a trust good, there will always need to be people.
In terms of specific numbers, I'd find it difficult to say how many there'll be in ten years.
Because
there are so many variables.
I'm only expressing
a trend.
What I want to say is: we want to grow in adviser numbers.
We're convinced that especially within our client segment, with our standards and what we stand for, we'll continue to need people. Without saying that AI plays no role – quite the opposite.
I said at the beginning, we deploy AI in many places.
It helps us not just with efficiency and automation questions.
It helps us with quality at the client interface.
It helps ensure that the adviser can focus on the topics where they make the difference – so it also creates space.
By the way, it's also a client expectation nowadays.
No matter where I go – whether it's Amazon or whatever – I experience AI being used everywhere. And that alone is already a prerequisite.
And it also doesn't mean that we're being complacent, thinking everything will always stay the same.
We're engaging with it.
We're looking closely at what others are doing.
We're naturally also examining where we could be attacked.
And we're asking ourselves how we can use it within our business model to move forward, but also to push into boundary areas.
Great bridge for me!
That's the internal AI perspective we've been discussing.
Now – and I'm probably not the perfect example, but picking up this trend nonetheless.
Over the past eighteen months, we've completely reorganised our finances at home, turned over every stone.
With massive use of AI.
Looking at where the money actually sits.
Who's actually earning what, where?
What?
How?
The result is that our personal banking adviser has become thoroughly fed up.
Because we've pulled everything out of privately managed arrangements and it's now all AI-managed in various ETFs at fintechs we all know – Trade Republic and the like.
And nobody's earning anything any more from it, at least in our private wealth management.
That trend would ruin you if many people did the same.
Plus, perhaps, if what I'd call financial literacy and sovereignty – because the fintechs have certainly achieved that to some degree –
they've at least created a certain openness among the younger population towards the idea of investing money.
In whatever form.
Whether their philosophy or ours is the right one is another matter.
But it could lead to the next generations not wanting or needing an adviser at all.
Because for me personally, AI played an enormous role in this process – essentially throwing everything into Claude: bank statements, documents, investments – and then working through it in dialogue.
What's your assessment of that?
First, regarding your personal situation.
The decisive thing is always that I need to feel added value.
And the aspiration must be –
now I don't know your bank adviser.
Perhaps you should get to know my MLP adviser! But I don't want to turn this into an advert.
But you have to be able to feel that added value.
So that's one thing.
Perhaps you're also not entirely representative, because you engage intensively with these topics, you're someone who makes their own decisions, and you have needs.
Could be, based on what you've just said.
But I don't want to give advice here.
I'm also not a financial adviser, so even if I'm only optimising costs,
at the end of the day it's about value for money, and it's not just about maximising returns but also about being balanced in terms of the risks involved and the risk protection that comes with it.
So it does help to have a holistic view.
But again, I wouldn't presume to judge what you've done.
The decisive thing is always that I feel added value.
Yes, I'd happily pick that up as a trend – people who are a bit more advanced in age, now around fifty, saying: I'll manage it myself.
Coupled with the trend – and behind both is the AI topic, which made it easier for me. Where previously you'd have had to laboriously analyse things in spreadsheets.
Which I never fancied doing – I'd basically not engaged with my finances for the fifteen years before that. Money comes from the cash machine, like electricity from the socket. But then also the younger generation – when I look at my own children, in their early twenties, dabbling with ETFs and Trade Republic.
I can barely imagine them going to a financial adviser.
The decisive thing is always knowing what your USP is and being convinced that it's a value-adding service.
If you say the market is changing radically –
what's your assessment?
What's changing in the short term, and especially in the medium term?
One thing is exactly what you've addressed – that there are more and more digital offerings.
Meaning access is far more low-threshold.
Information asymmetry is essentially gone already.
And if I then combine that with AI, you have a completely different level of market transparency and completely different possibilities to do things yourself.
That would be the basic tendency.
And at the same time, it's naturally the case with the tech providers, the fintechs
and so on,
that they're going to market with large advertising budgets.
So that's the starting point.
And specifically looking at current developments – from next year there'll be a retirement savings depot.
Something like that used to only be accessible through personal advice.
The legislator has now designed it so that it can also run via corresponding platforms.
That changes the market. And simultaneously, through generational shifts.
You just spoke about your children. I don't actually know exactly how old they are.
But if I look at Gen Z today – your children are probably Gen Z – or mine, who are Gen Alpha, the ones coming after – they naturally interact with their media differently from how I do. And they're naturally closer to a neobroker at first than to personal advice.
The question is always: is it only a risk?
Or is it possibly an opportunity?
Where does the opportunity lie
for me?
Young people engaging with financial topics quite early and in a low-threshold way.
Perhaps differently from how it used to be. And then the question is: can I succeed
in getting into contact with these people and creating the added value I mentioned?
Or not?
And do young people stay at the assumption that a well-thought-out financial concept consists of – and I'm exaggerating now – a few cryptocurrencies, one or two individual investments, and an ETF?
Or do they at some point realise that it's also sensible, when moving towards starting a family,
or even earlier during their studies, to have things properly organised overall?
And what we're seeing today – and that's why I spoke of opportunity – is this:
if we succeed – and again, not in the mass market but in our target group of academics –
if we succeed in building a contact with these academics.
And if we succeed – and I'm always speaking about the typical case, it's naturally not so in every case –
if we succeed in sitting down with them, or very often these days at a virtual table or in a virtual consultation, and getting into conversation – then we succeed in a good proportion of cases in conveying that added value.
The risk could be that you can no longer reach the young person at all. We're not seeing that at the moment.
But we naturally have to be watchful, and we're working on having the right offerings.
Let me give one or two examples.
We've deliberately decided, for instance, to offer cryptocurrency self-trading on our own platform.
A few years ago, one might have said that had nothing to do with the core business model. And it still doesn't today.
But if it's important particularly for young people, and I'm the go-to contact for all financial questions – as I've said three or four times now – the question is: can I leave that aside or not?
And the answer is no.
I can't leave it aside.
We've invested heavily in modernising our systems.
That's important.
If I have an app that seems outdated to a young person, I haven't got a chance of competing.
So we have to be careful to present a coherent framework, and always ask ourselves: are we succeeding
in reaching the students, the young academics along the way?
What we're seeing – and you can read this from many individual examples but of course also from the overall figures – is that when we do succeed, that added value is still needed.
You could also pose the counter-thesis.
You could argue that precisely in a world where everything is low-threshold, people need even more orientation.
If you look at
what drives a typical client of ours,
it's essentially two things.
They have little time – you described that for yourself.
You can't be bothered with all the spreadsheets and the terms and conditions and so on and so forth.
So that's the 'delegator' type – which I am too.
I have neither the inclination nor the time to deal with my finances.
And at the same time, I want to feel confident!
I don't simply want to feel that something's being done somewhere... I want to understand what decision options I have. And if someone prepares those for me and gives me the occasional nudge, that has incredible value. To believe I always know what's generally good and I'll just pick the cheapest product
is a bit short-sighted, in my view.
I'll say that now – you could argue he would say that, being a board member at the company.
I believe in it, I believe in it deeply. But conveying exactly that is not easy, and that's our challenge.
It will be.
What just shot through my mind – and you deliberately quantified it a bit in your introduction by saying 'just a few cryptos and buy something somewhere'.
But there are genuinely now, without claiming to be an expert, serious platforms, YouTube channels, Finanztip, financial gurus
and what have you.
Ones that, beyond the 'I'll make you rich in three years' nonsense, seem to deliver very credible advice, at least to my eyes.
And is that competition for you?
It's competition insofar as it's within our target group.
Yes, because you've formulated it exactly that way, saying you're the go-to for all financial questions. That's what made me think of these platforms.
They seem to have that aspiration too.
If I understand these platforms correctly, they don't have the holistic aspiration we have, and they can't have it.
Because when I bring together the private client and corporate client worlds, the investment, banking and insurance worlds – I don't know any platform that does all of that. It's always focused on a single topic.
What's true is that bringing financial streams together is something you can do in those places.
But from my perspective, that's something different. But of course, yes, it is competition.
I'm often asked: who are your actual competitors?
There isn't just one, because we're in a specialised market with a specialised business model.
But of course, anyone who wants to advise or advises our private client target group of academics on financial matters is naturally a competitor.
And if you'd asked me five, six, seven, eight years ago, I'd probably have said: the high street banks, the Sparkassen, the Volksbanken, where young people also open accounts. But in recent years it's naturally become increasingly the neobrokers and other platforms.
But they're not competitors in the sense that they have the same business model and we're competing for exactly this holistic approach for the client. Rather, they represent one part of a target client's financial setup.
How do you
use social media?
Whether that's YouTube, TikTok, Instagram... I genuinely don't know, this is a sincere question.
Those
are different levels, and the question is: whom do I address on which channel?
First it's about general awareness, general visibility.
But it's now also the case that we very deliberately target Gen Z through exactly these media and channels like Instagram or TikTok. And every company needs to learn on that front.
There's always a tendency at the start to broadcast from inside out.
We'll explain what matters to us, because that's important.
But at the same time, you need to understand:
you need to understand what drives that generation.
And what we think can be technically solid, interesting and important,
but it may completely miss the trend that's currently running in those media.
You can tell there are trends, and you need to understand them.
You need to understand the algorithms in order to occupy topics and perhaps send less and simply present topics more broadly. Because the aim isn't to educate someone on such a channel.
It's about generating a certain baseline of attention and setting anchors.
And sometimes those can be small anchors – what service is available – and thereby generating interest.
That's one area we're active in.
We've intensified that significantly and put it on a different footing – less generic, more focused on sitting in the shoes of the person we're targeting, and then shaping the content accordingly.
The second thing – I used the term 'digital ecosystem' earlier.
We have a stake in a company in Dresden called UniNow.
They're building the largest student platform in Germany, with benefits in many areas – content for theses, printing of coursework, a brilliant student benefits platform. And we contribute very transparently with financial content, through which we get to know young people who then say: yes, I'd be interested in attending an online seminar from MLP on financial education.
And naturally our hope
and our goal – though ultimately the participant has to decide – is that they say: yes, I'd like a consultation. But we get there through visibility within the target group, through competence, and that's how we build our relevance. And for that, you do sometimes have to be a bit louder or quirkier than I personally would normally be on social media.
Does it follow from what you're explaining, Jan – your philosophy of always seeking personal contact
and conveying your knowledge and added value that way –
have you deliberately decided against something else?
Because when I personally looked at what's out there in terms of financial knowledge, wealth and insurance content – both dimensions – I stumbled across Finanztip, Finanzguru.
I didn't stumble across MLP on social media.
Is that a deliberate decision, or is it a blind spot?
That you wouldn't perceive MLP as someone that young people with their first financial questions would encounter at that point – that hasn't happened for me.
I'd say our system has worked quite well then, because you're not exactly the classic young target group.
That was said with a wink.
Yes, that naturally hurts, but...
Don't take it the wrong way!
Of course, it's also targeted outreach.
So it is an important channel for you – I simply hadn't noticed.
It is an important channel.
In terms of broad impact, as I just said, we've intensified that significantly.
Especially Instagram, TikTok
and so on.
But particularly when it comes to
targeting specifically for seminars about financial education, about basic financial knowledge.
That's something we've been doing professionally for many years, but we try to reach the target group specifically and not through broad-brush approaches.
What we've also done in recent years are classic marketing campaigns.
Those still take place in traditional media for us, but increasingly and more and more online too.
And what's helped us enormously there in recent years, including with young clients, is letting real client examples speak for themselves.
And I believe that's very authentic, and that's precisely the difference.
Because a lot of what you find elsewhere is simply a competition over conditions, or a utility promise aimed at making something easier in the short term through gamification.
When it comes to this particular quality – this USP I've been talking about – you have to find ways to make it tangible, including through social media.
And taking examples from the generation, letting clients describe this added value in their own words –
that's an effective approach, from my perspective.
When you look at the competition, which two or three competitors do you personally always have on your radar?
You've said it yourself, there isn't one single competitor.
But when you look at the landscape, who do you actually notice?
I have different categories, and I already said there's no one with our exact business model. If you can think of one, do say.
Then we'll discuss it.
Because holistic financial advice, independent, self-employed, and then for a very specific target group – I don't know anyone else like that.
It's always about partial competition, as I defined earlier.
In recent years, I've focused strongly on the neobrokers and the usual names everyone knows. But I naturally also watch what's happening in other parts of the market,
in sales organisations.
You need to understand how they're operating, how they're developing.
So
you mean the insurers themselves?
Insurers,
there are broker platforms and so on and so forth.
And the third area would be the classic banks, which are naturally also trying to develop further.
So take the neobroker topic and look at what the Sparkassen and Volksbanken are all doing.
They're trying to get a foot in the door too, moving away from the classic model
where someone comes in and buys a security through their personal adviser.
Instead they're trying to take the next steps in online brokerage
and so on.
And observing all of that is extremely important, and what's always very helpful,
from my perspective, is stepping a bit outside the usual bubble and looking at other markets, at companies with similar business models in other markets, to develop an understanding of how you can evolve.
So it's a mixture, depending on where the focus is.
But everything has its place in a competitive analysis – and yes, to your point,
the neobroker and pure online provider topic has naturally gained significantly in importance.
One more point in the context of the environment and market development.
You mentioned that you've also been offering fee-based advice for some time, even if the share – shall we say for the prototypical adviser earning a hundred thousand –
might be around ten per cent, perhaps less for newcomers.
And politics keeps revisiting this discussion about whether there might be a ban on commissions for financial products.
I don't know the current state of play – you'll probably be better placed to assess that than I am.
So is it real?
Should it be taken seriously?
And if it happened, what would it mean for MLP?
Every discussion should be taken seriously.
This one was once much more advanced, based on our observation, and it's not currently in the foreground or being actively pursued.
There was another push from the EU...
But you did think it was serious?
Four or five years ago, there was a deeper discussion in Germany, and two or three years ago there was a more far-reaching discussion in Europe.
There was a proposal from an EU Commissioner who wanted some form of commission limitation.
That discussion has, for good reasons I believe – and I'm not saying this to protect a business model but because there was a lot of ignorance in the debate, a rather politically motivated reaction because the topic was uncomfortable –
but that's my personal assessment.
Was the topic much more prominent?
At the moment I'd see the probability as very low. Which doesn't mean you don't have to engage with it.
And naturally we have, and continue to do so.
And if you look at our business model, we'd be the ones least affected.
Because we're so broadly positioned.
But for the adviser it would be catastrophic for the... well,
it's always the question of how remuneration would then be structured.
But in the
status
quo?
If you look at it statically in the status quo, it would be unfavourable.
That's right, although it was always only about certain areas. And it's not absolute – depending on the state of the discussion, there was also legislation in Germany about certain quality components you receive if you meet certain criteria.
In that case, we'd have been quite confident.
At the same time, the discussion in Germany was primarily about the insurance sector.
But we're also very broadly positioned – that was your opening question – in wealth management, which others aren't.
We already deliver fee-based elements in many areas and could naturally expand that if necessary.
But nonetheless, it would initially represent a market disruption.
However, it doesn't help to treat some theoretical scenario now. It'll depend on the specifics.
Our energy goes more into constantly explaining everywhere why it's helpful
that the system is set up as it is. And at the same time, showing openness to the fact that – and this must always be the decisive thing –
where it's accepted or even demanded by the client, we're open to going different routes too.
How high do you estimate the probability
that such a commission ban or restriction might come at some point?
You know how it is with political majorities.
They can shift relatively quickly, and we all know that sometimes topics are raised again simply for tactical negotiating reasons.
At the moment I'd consider the probability very low. If you ask me again in five years, after another general election and a newly constituted EU Commission,
that would be a bit like reading tea leaves.
It's a topic that keeps coming up.
And therefore, once again: we need to explain ourselves well. And the decisive thing is, if you offer a good, value-adding service, you have fewer of these discussions. And at the same time, feeding good arguments into the debate.
But right now I see little movement that should make us nervous.
Let's perhaps take a brief look at MLP's culture.
I myself had the opportunity to support you in developing strategy for one of your business areas and bringing it to implementation.
One piece of self-criticism you offered at the time was: we need to become more consistent in what we commit to.
Fundamentally, that's something embedded in MLP's culture.
But you described it – things are very collaborative, even friendly.
I observe that your culture is caring, considerate – meaning people enjoy working together and value each other. Which could potentially lead to a feel-good harmony culture.
Do you have that?
And do you manage to find the edge needed to drive change consistently?
And how would you assess it?
And that's not necessarily a bad thing.
I think a need for harmony is actually something positive, because it ensures a decent social interaction.
But you perhaps know what I mean.
I know what you mean, although a need for harmony and friendliness and therefore no change wouldn't be the right frame.
The frame would be: a good rapport as the basis for success. But then also as the basis for change. And that's how I'd always try to classify it.
One could argue that the closer you are to each other, the harder it is to step out of the comfort zone, to provoke, to challenge each other, to envision different futures beyond the status quo.
But that's then our job as leaders – to do precisely that.
Tell me about
the last time you had to make a decision that was truly difficult for you.
Professionally right, but humanly hard!
Many come to mind. One was four or five years ago.
It was a personal decision regarding a colleague. It wasn't that it fell hard, exactly, but I did invest a great deal of energy – we invested a lot of energy together – in finding the right path. And we were well aware that such changes would preoccupy many people.
And that's not long ago – just a few months.
But at the end of the day, you face such decisions almost daily.
They tend to be on a smaller scale. But then there are the big ones over the years that you always remember.
Perhaps coming back briefly to what you raised.
If a good rapport were to become a brake on consistent future-shaping, then a company would have a very big problem.
And
do you believe you have that problem, or might you?
In general, no, I wouldn't say we do.
But it can naturally happen in individual contexts that people act differently because of it.
But I think that's the case in every company.
I can recall what you're referring to.
We were trying to bring separate parts of the company together into a shared strategy. And at the time I described how we'd somewhat let it run because it was happening in different entities, and that we now wanted to bring a different level of consistency – because we wanted to unlock the shared potential and would do so.
And from my perspective, that's the real challenge we have – not excessive closeness that prevents change, but rather the question: how do you succeed
in focusing on the essential topics, tackling the right ones, and then actually scoring the goal?
Many companies probably face this. But whenever you sit in a strategy session, there are a thousand possible avenues for development. And then having the courage to say: there are two or three strategic initiatives and we're leaving the rest alone, without having expectations on those either.
That, from my perspective, is an extremely fine line that many companies walk, and we do too.
And that was a topic we discussed at the time.
I believe it's worked well within each area individually, but the shared element between the different entities perhaps hadn't yet been given the space and priority it deserved.
What I wanted to express at the time was: now is the moment to work out together where we want to go.
And when we do that, we'll implement it with full consistency.
That must also be the expectation of everyone involved.
And I want to lead by example, as the one who ultimately bears the responsibility.
That's why I raised it.
But to come back to the core point – the question of which initiatives I focus on and then actually bring to success.
That, from my perspective, is one of the decisive levers any company has.
You've just had a board offsite.
We're sitting here in Hamburg at the OMR Studios. You were at Timmendorfer Strand. Were there one or two aha moments or insights you took away from the offsite?
Or would you say it genuinely helped you strategically?
Or was it simply a pleasant get-together?
It was significantly more than a pleasant get-together, and I don't think 'pleasant get-together' would describe it well in a business context.
I find it extremely important to have a good rapport.
As a basis – we've already spoken about that.
But the decisive thing is making progress together. And it's always the question of saying: once or twice a year,
which is how we do it via strategy offsites, you step back and take another look.
And the good thing – one or two insights.
It's often initially a nice confirmation. Because when after a year – that's the usual cycle – I look very consciously at topics and see what's moved, it confirms the path.
I was speaking earlier about strategy in terms of continuity.
You experience that continuity at these moments too, and you experience a lot of confirmation.
Did you discuss anything where you thought: that's really been a development this past year that we hadn't quite seen or appreciated to this extent?
There are developments where you're perhaps positively surprised by the speed.
We were also positively surprised by the AI topics, as an example.
When I look at where we were a year ago and how much movement has come into the organisation,
from my perspective that's very positive.
What specifically pleased you there?
What
pleased us greatly, when we look at it – firstly,
I always distinguish between everyday AI – what everyone uses – and what we do centrally for the company, for example for the adviser workplace. Both have developed well. And particularly with the things we're doing centrally to evolve the workplace,
we've taken intermediate steps that I wouldn't have been sure a year ago we'd manage so quickly.
What is
that exactly?
For example, the automated reading of documents, the construction of a multi-agent system that helps an adviser pull information about the client's situation from different target systems in order to advise the client as precisely as possible.
That's progressing incredibly quickly.
Or another example – we're doing this together with... we're here in the north, as you just said... together with a sister company in Kiel, the DomCura. There's an automated process where the client simply uploads an insurance contract with a phone photo, and everything is automatically optimised by AI in the background.
Those are big leaps taken in a very short time.
Some of which are also being publicly highlighted very positively in the industry, particularly by the tech companies.
And
we're quite satisfied with that. And on the other hand, also positively surprised by how quickly the organisation has adapted. Because with AI topics, you initially come very much from a sense of urgency, from a kind of rallying culture. But then you face the challenge of actually getting into action. And this getting into action and creating concrete experiences – we're satisfied looking at that.
But we're not complacent or thinking we can sit back. Rather, maintaining and further building that pace
is the next step.
The DomCura example in Kiel –
these AI topics weren't born at the Wiesloch headquarters but outside.
Is that something you'd recommend to other companies from your experience – that it's difficult to push forward innovatively with AI from the established headquarters, and it's better to find people through what's essentially a satellite that can then carry it into the centre? Can anything be drawn from that?
That's right – DomCura was and is a frontrunner, though it's also important for the business model itself.
And it's very much helped us.
At the same time, it always helps to initiate such things in several places. And it always helps
when you have someone who goes first, because others look to them and they can pull the others along.
From my perspective, it has a very motivating effect. And if I may step away from AI for a moment,
more generally – I was talking about how we've also founded companies and invested in companies, described as an ecosystem.
Those are very deliberate decisions.
We're an organisation of nearly five thousand people when you add it all up. That's not a huge organisation, but it is a large one.
And we naturally also have, as you do in larger groups,
regulatory requirements, reporting lines.
That's different from a start-up, by its very nature.
We're small enough to be fast.
But of course, as in every company, there's always the risk of being too slow. And then making the very deliberate decision to say: where do I also outsource things?
For example, into a company or investment that can think much more freely,
that has much more of a green field,
that has far less legacy, that perhaps has completely new management,
a completely fresh approach – that's an extremely important tool, from my perspective,
for
developing companies further, particularly in those areas that are adjacent. And at the same time, always keeping in mind the image of the speedboat alongside the tanker, but in the best sense – bringing the learnings back.
And I do think that's a smart approach, and one we pursue happily and, I believe, quite successfully.
To close, a personal question that probably gets on your nerves because I think it gets asked here quite often.
Are you curious?
Is Jan Berg the next CEO of MLP, and is that being prepared and developed?
You always deny it when asked by the press and say nothing. And you're welcome to say: I can't hear this question any more.
I haven't actually been asked this question that often, and I don't occupy myself with it either.
But it's not a deliberate succession plan that you've already pre-programmed?
It wouldn't be my job to prepare such a decision.
As you know, we briefly touched on it, but I've been in the role of spokesman for a year now.
I very much enjoy it. I've been with the company for more than twenty years and I'm driven by the content of what I get to do.
I see it as an incredible privilege to take on responsibility, and I've said yes to every responsibility so far and would say yes to any other responsibility too.
But it's not my job to discuss that or to assess it. And it's not something that occupies me on a daily basis either.
But if you're asking me the question, it's naturally flattering. But it's not something on my active
agenda.
Thank you so very much for the conversation.
I've taken away some great food for thought for myself, especially when we talked about sales topics and structures.
Many thanks above all for the reflections on possible developments, and for enduring what was probably at times some rather uncomfortable probing.
And I noticed – you're rarely emotionally visible given your professionalism – but one could tell that the WISO sting really does sit deep.
To all listeners of Debugged, I hope you enjoyed this episode.
Do like it and subscribe!
And a big thank you to you, Jan.
We'll stay in touch.
Thank you.
Many thanks for the great
exchange.
We'll stay in touch.
Thank you.
Many thanks for the great
exchange.
The finance and advisory industry is facing a tangible upheaval: between digital neo-brokers, AI assistants and rising client expectations. MLP board member Jan Berg has been shaping this transformation from the inside. He speaks about why the human touch cannot be replaced, the art of building trust in a digital age, and the leadership lessons learned from decades in financial services (in German).
Listen to DEBUGGED here (in German):
