Strategy Execution

Are Managers Allowed to Be Planless?

Philipp Detloff4 min reading time
Dürfen Manager planlos sein
Bildquelle: KI

When I tell a room full of managers that they must be “goal-oriented yet planless”, I usually get a grin about the “consultant nonsense” I am sharing. After all, everyone has absorbed with their mother’s milk how straight management works: develop vision and strategy, draw up a plan and work through it meticulously.

They Must – But Skilfully

Goal-oriented? Of course. But planless? What a hare-brained idea.

By “planless” I mean the crucial art of consistently focusing beyond the plan – before and during execution – on what truly matters: the result. Every strategy execution, every market launch and every customer acquisition is like conquering an unknown mountain. You cannot plan the ascent of a mountain you do not know.

The Summit Is Clear, the Mountain Is the Mystery

We always have our goal, the summit, in sight, but not the faintest idea what awaits us around the next bend.

  • A gruelling ascent?
  • Treacherous switchbacks?
  • Or a shady plateau?

Not to mention heat build-up and headwinds.

It is the same with our plans and their control: most of the time, all of that is a waste of time and energy because we simply do not know how things will unfold.

The goal, the result, is what counts – not the plan. This is a simple truth we lose sight of far too often. The temptation is simply too great. We frequently destroy the chance of genuine execution momentum – the point and state where intensive work happens, where the team makes outstanding progress and does not even find it strenuous – through the way we plan, control and manage.

1. Every Execution Is Uncharted Territory

Whether strategy execution, project or change – every undertaking is uncharted territory that nobody before us has entered.

Nobody has conquered the market with exactly this team or this product before, and nobody has built the wind farm where we intend to build it. We only know the summit we want to reach. For the mountain itself, there is no map, no standard and no best practice.

Are managers allowed to be planless
Image source: AI

2. The Courage to Stand by This Insight

I know very few people who consistently practise goal-oriented planlessness to turn their strategies into reality swiftly with genuine execution momentum. Most create plans and deceive steering committees and supervisory boards into believing they know exactly what will happen, when and how. A great deal of work is generated that has little to do with the actual result: achieving the goal and its execution.

In a large board meeting, a supervisory board member recently asked me: “What exactly is your approach?” My answer:

“I have no idea. We will see.”

Was that answer inappropriate? No, it was honest. And after I subsequently described the “execution triple jump” to him, we were fully aligned.

3. Management Discipline

With great discipline, we repeatedly rally our team around the result throughout the entire execution to prevent pure “input activities”. Let us forget off-the-shelf status reports that focus solely on activities and have no results orientation. But is the alternative not a dangerous mix of opportunism and activism – nothing but naive planlessness? No. Skilful execution management consistently eliminates everything that has nothing to do with achieving the goal. And that starts with fruitless planning and controlling.

The Execution Triple Jump

Only when the overall target state is clear, has been broken into components and the people responsible for these pieces clearly see their goal and how they interlock do we turn to the how. We expressly do not plan the big picture in order to then control a rigidly fixed path via activities.

Instead, we discipline ourselves with the execution triple jump. Every two weeks (the frequency can be set as desired or needed, but must be strictly adhered to), we sit down with the sub-project leaders – and they with their teams – and ask ourselves:

  1. What exactly do we want to achieve, and how do we know we are making progress?
  2. What makes us confident or uncertain that we will achieve what we intend?
  3. What specifically must be achieved next?

Essential throughout: we think and speak only in results, never in activities. With these few rules, we manage to handle every execution better. Let us enjoy making swift and steady progress from now on.

Yours Matthias Kolbusa