General

Predictability: Weakness or Virtue

Philipp Detloff3 min reading time
Berechenbarkeit
Bildquelle KI

“Why should I be predictable?” an astonished board member asked me during a management sparring session. “So that your people know where they stand with you,” I replied, adding: “And so that your team does not waste time reading tea leaves, hoping to work out what their boss needs in which form at which moment for an important decision to be made swiftly and soundly.”

Admittedly, that is a somewhat complicated answer. But no less complicated than the diffuse challenge that the staff of unpredictable managers face every day. Like the CIO who explained to me during a phone call the other day that he had not yet been able to raise a certain matter with his CEO because he first had to wait for the right moment. I call that a “leadership farce par excellence”.

Inconsistent behaviour is one of the greatest scourges of management and occurs at every hierarchical level. Worse still: many do not even see it as a problem but rather as a sign of strength.

Certainly: anyone who enjoys power games and wants to spread fear and uncertainty through unpredictability can extract the odd advantage from it.

For employees, colleagues and thus the company, however, this becomes a serious disadvantage in the long run, because everything revolves around moods rather than substance. That is why I say:

Unpredictability is a weakness. It is an expression of lacking professionalism and an immature understanding of values when our reactions to the performance of others are determined by our mood and our form on the day.

Imagine your judgement of an innovation depends on the person presenting it. That means it is primarily a matter of personal sympathy whether a proposal receives support or not. This not only delays decisions; it also makes them significantly worse. On top of that, moody divas are highly susceptible to manipulation.

The more frequently their behaviour shifts unpredictably, the more their environment will try to steer them subtly to create the desired predictability. Instead of genuine competence, manipulation skills are rewarded.

Predictability
Image source: AI

If we want a truly productive organisation, we must be predictable and respond consistently to every type of request and decision requirement, entirely free from any current mood. Everyone involved must have complete clarity about what a manager expects from them in which form, what performance satisfies the superior, and when they begin to get frustrated or disappointed. Only then can an organisation develop in which every cog can rely on the next and in which it is predictable at all times who will behave in what way and when.

In private life, it is no different. Our children, partners and friends expect us to be predictable. How else are they supposed to trust us? What would my son think of me if I suddenly allowed him to play on the iPad for all eternity – free access to the chocolate supply included? Of course he would seize the opportunity. But if I only allowed it because I had just won a wonderful contract and was in an especially good mood, my otherwise sensible rules would lose their meaning.

My deeper conviction that both pleasures should be enjoyed only in moderation would no longer carry any weight in his eyes. I would no longer be credible to him. As a role model, I would have failed.

Yours, Matthias Kolbusa