You surely know the old saying: “A horse only jumps as high as it must.” And you have probably experienced in both your personal and professional life that for many people this amounts to a golden rule. At first glance, this may seem beyond reproach, for what more can you ask than the accurate completion of assigned tasks? There would be little to object to if ambition and effort were in balance. If it were possible to define a job’s requirements so that they could be met with exactly 100 per cent effort, everything should be fine – or should it not?
What Are 100 Per Cent?
It is not quite that simple. First of all, we must ask what these 100 per cent actually are. Are they defined by objective physical and mental limits (which presumably nobody knows)? Or is it rather what leaders and employees – often in very different ways – imagine? We probably agree that the former is theoretically correct but not relevant because we have no access to it. We can only work with what we experience in others and in ourselves.
In practice, however, there is usually a great deal of room for improvement above 100 declared per cent of performance and results.
What you cannot yet do, you can learn. Failure to achieve something can be a question of lacking motivation but also of insufficient support from someone who believes they have already provided every conceivable form of assistance. In this way, being content with mediocrity becomes a syndrome that can easily infect an entire organisation. Everyone believes they are at their limit and they reinforce this belief in each other so regularly that they take pride in performance they could in reality significantly surpass.
The critical question, when the market starts getting tough, is always: “How do we get out of this mess?” And the calls soon ring out: “We need to become agile!” As if agility could iron out what a cultivated organisational complacency has caused. The opposite is true: the more self-organisation and self-responsibility a new method demands, the more the old deficits make themselves felt.
What Is Too Comfortable Is Not Good Enough
Of course, there is a great deal you can do to become a faster and more energetic organisation. As a first step, I propose a trivially simple-sounding approach – the answer to the critical question, so to speak: “Raise the targets, and raise them significantly.” I am well aware that this measure generates headwinds of force 7 and above. But that is precisely the point, because one thing is clear: if everyone in the company finds their workload comfortable and greets new strategies with enthusiastic flag-waving, the bar is set too low. An organisation may still be capable under those conditions, but it will always remain below its potential.
“And what do we do when employees groan that it is simply too much to ask?” you often hear from managers who can also see harder times ahead for themselves (because if others are to deliver more, they must invest more). My answer: “Then raise the bar again – but change your culture. Michelangelo is said to have stated:
“For most of us, the greatest danger lies not in aiming high and falling short, but in setting our sights too low and achieving them.”«
And he is absolutely right. The problem with targets set too low is that while they prevent poorer performance, they simultaneously ensure that despite the best opportunities, those targets are never exceeded.”
Management Is Like Sport
And who says 100 per cent must always be the measure of all things? In management, too, there are phases of sprinting and marathon running. When a 400-metre runner is on the track, he runs his lungs out even though he knows he cannot sustain it for a second lap. Why does he do it? Simple: because that is exactly what this moment demands and because medals and pride await at the finish line. That is precisely the point in an organisation as well: complacent satisfaction with the usual results must give way to pride in outstanding performance.
To that end, we may well demand more than can be delivered in order to draw out maximum performance. But not only for that reason: in times when we need disruption and strategic excellence because the conditions demand it, the old ways of thinking will not get us anywhere. Yet we do not need to think differently if we can reach the next targets through simple optimisation. Only when our goals – and thus the future we are striving for – reach far beyond the usual are we forced to create rather than optimise, and only then are we ready to accept the discomfort that comes with it.
It All Comes Down to Culture
So the lesson is clear: raising targets is not an end in itself and achieves nothing at all if missing them is penalised. What is needed instead is a healthy willingness to embrace imperfection that generates maximum commitment – in place of a comfort culture that merely pays lip service to excellence. Missing an extraordinarily high target is perfectly fine if we have given everything. After all, 70 out of 200 demanded per cent is significantly more than 100 out of 100.
Jürgen Klopp, former manager of FC Liverpool and previously the title-winning coach of Borussia Dortmund, has his own take on the horse proverb:
“I hate that saying more than anything. A horse should damn well jump as high as it can.”«
I have little to add to that. Let us raise the targets – and we will be amazed at what becomes possible.
Yours Matthias Kolbusa
Book Recommendation
If you are looking for more stimulus like this to make your management year as exciting, satisfying and successful as you wish, I recommend my recently published 55 Management Inspirations. Whether you implement them week by week or pull several levers at once: I look forward to hearing about your experiences and your feedback.
MATTHIAS KOLBUSA 55 Management Inspirations
Hardcover Published 15 December 2021
ISBN 978-3982163918 Price: EUR 19.90 / Kindle EUR 14.90 Information and ordering