Since the ability to make decisions quickly and with follow-through is considered a vital competence in management, it is all the more astonishing how little clarity we have about what a decision actually is. While we wonder in private why our New Year’s resolutions come to nothing, we regularly discover at work that nobody adheres to the agreements that were made. Why is that?
A Difference with Consequences
With decisions, we cut a path through the jungle of possibilities. We usually expect them to clear up any confusion for ourselves and others and to set things in motion. So far the neat theory, which breaks down in practice, however, when we start making the same decisions again and again. Gradually, new paths become cemented routes with guardrails that allow no alternatives. The worst manifestation is stubborn dogmatism.
That is why not deciding can also be positive. Someone who does not decide remains flexible until a better alternative crystallises.
Eliminating ambiguity with a decision or instead staying flexible and avoiding dogma: that is the tension we operate in. Whether it is about exercising more or releasing several million euros for a project next year – what is usually overlooked: deliberately not deciding or not deciding just yet are always an option – and sometimes not the worst one.
My impression: we decide far too hastily far too often, when waiting and observing would be more advantageous. Because a good decision requires far more than merely choosing from alternatives.
A Decision Is Not a Resolution or a Wish
A decision is a commitment where you must be clear about everything that is necessary for an undertaking to succeed at all. A decision requires consideration of all relevant consequences and clarification of all necessary conditions. That is what distinguishes a decision from a resolution or a wish. The latter two merely contain the notion that their conditions and consequences have not been concretely thought through.
Resolving to spend more time with the family, then, has nothing to do with a real decision. Only when we address what must be in place for that – for example working less or playing golf less often – do we put ourselves in a position to make a conscious decision.
We can choose to fulfil all the necessary, now concrete conditions, or we can let it go because we believe, for example, that we cannot meet these preconditions.
With a provisional decision against something, we preserve the flexibility to reconsider the matter in a month or two. Too often, however, we find ourselves in a perpetual vicious circle: we cannot escape our own lack of clarity because we fail to recognise the connections described above.
Decisions in Companies Are Different
In a business context, a central component is added: decisions usually need to be supported by several people and then executed. Many managers are frustrated, for example, that the execution of a new investment programme is not bearing fruit. The reason is that often only a vague wish exists that does not clearly define what innovation means at its core, what its necessary preconditions are and how their fulfilment can be ensured. Not infrequently, such ill-considered decisions are even reached by majority vote rather than by consensus.
Majority decisions make sense in politics but not in companies. There, they invariably lead to no real decisions being made. Decisions in companies must be worked out by consensus, with all parties involved discussing what the necessary conditions are and whether they are met.
Only when that is clear do we no longer speak of a resolution or wish but of a genuine decision that we can be confident is the right one.
Yours Matthias Kolbusa