General

Do You Have Five Minutes? – No

Philipp Detloff5 min reading time
Haben Sie mal fünf Minuten

Does this sound familiar? An employee comes to you and signals their need for a conversation with the words

“Do you have five minutes?”

As an understanding boss who always has an open door, you say:

“Yes, of course, come in.”

What follows is a detailed account of the context. The events surrounding a particular project over the past weeks are described, the factors that play a special role are explained, and how colleagues have been behaving on this topic – until the employee finally gets to the point and says: “And now the question is how we should deal with this.” You then develop various approaches in a dialogue with them, contribute your experience and distil the best option for the way forward from a wide range of perspectives. The employee leaves your office satisfied, you feel good, and everything carries on as normal.

What Just Happened? You Were Simply Taken Advantage Of

Taken advantage of, because someone else was too lazy to think precisely about a problem beforehand, to develop specific alternatives, and was also too comfortable to make a decision about the way forward. This happened out of the fear of potentially having to take responsibility for something that was well within their own remit. It is a phenomenon I encounter again and again in many organisations: the “I have a problem” phenomenon. And whether out of pure good nature or because we know our way around the specialist domains and feel comfortable when confronted with technical questions, we throw ourselves into this phenomenon with gusto. That we are hardly making our employees self-reliant and independent by doing this is, of course, not something we are aware of in the moment. It is also comfortable and feels good. After all, this is what distinguishes our team – that we are always there for each other. But this is a misunderstood sense of team spirit and leadership.

Laziness Is the First Component Behind This Phenomenon

As a rule, people are too lazy to think really deeply about what the problem actually is. Instead, they like to use others either to work out the precise difficulty during the conversation or to let others figure it out entirely on their own. This is why one of my fundamental principles is that when someone approaches me and says they have a problem, I am of course available as a sparring partner.

Do you have five minutes
Image source: StockAdobe Sergey Nivens

However, if the conversation opens with long-winded explanations instead of a precisely defined problem, I become sceptical. As soon as someone starts describing the context around the problem, I ask: “What exactly is the problem?” Not infrequently I am told: “I need to explain the context first.” There is only one answer to such a statement: “No. You do not.” Is that rude? No. If someone is unable to formulate a problem in a single sentence, they have not engaged with it sufficiently beforehand.

What exactly is a problem? A problem consists of a subject that represents the matter at hand, a target value that this subject should have, and a deviation from it. Nothing more and nothing less.

Therefore, sentences like “Sales are not moving forward at the moment”, “We are in danger of falling behind with the project” or “We have a problem with key account XY” are imprecise waffle. Most complex issues contain not just one problem but several. The first task, then, is to separate them cleanly. In the example where sales are not moving forward, problem statements might include: “The number of customer enquiries for follow-on projects has declined by 20 per cent year on year for the past two months” and “The hit rate in region ABC is 30 per cent lower compared to other regions”.

Until someone delivers truly clear problem statements to me – and you can see that, when properly thought through, they can always be expressed in such sentences – I will not start a conversation. But there is more. Every problem has its causes – causes that represent changes before the deviation from the target value occurred. Anyone who cannot offer me at least three or four thoughts on what specifically changed, and thus what might be the lever to get the problem under control, will be sent away by me with that very task.

When the sales manager comes back and explains that he has identified possible reasons for these two problem statements and is now unsure which is actually the root cause and which of his measures is the most effective, then I am happy to get involved and be his sparring partner with pleasure.

Before that, however, the rule is: think for yourself and formulate precisely. I can only advise every manager to educate their employees in this direction, because it increases productivity enormously. Is it pleasant? Will you be loved for it? No, but you will be valued – even if that appreciation comes later, when employees are proud of having solved problems skilfully on their own.

The Second Component Is Cowardice

The second component of the “I have a problem” phenomenon is the cowardice of taking responsibility for a specific course of action. Employees are all too happy to shift responsibility – understood here as the decision on how to proceed – onto their boss. In the sales example, I therefore do not take responsibility for what happens next. I am merely the sparring partner, and the decision on how to proceed remains with the person I am speaking to. If that were not the case, one of us would be redundant.

So help your employees arrive at good approaches, be a reliable sparring partner for them and let them decide. Even if you feel a mistake is about to be made: what else is there to learn from?

Yours, Matthias Kolbusa