An open culture of error and debate is something almost every leadership team claims to want. In practice, however, it remains the exception rather than the rule. The core obstacle is deeply human: we crave recognition and instinctively avoid situations that might trigger negative emotions such as shame, guilt or embarrassment.
The polite surface
When these protective instincts dominate a meeting room, the result is predictable. People hold back critical observations, sugarcoat setbacks and nod along with proposals they privately consider flawed. Genuine friction – the kind that produces insight – is replaced by a polite surface beneath which frustration quietly builds.
Productive friction as a source of insight
The paradox is that the very discomfort we try to avoid is exactly what drives progress. When a colleague challenges your concept, the first impulse is to defend it. Yet if you pause and ask, “What specifically makes you see it differently?”, something remarkable happens: the conversation shifts from positional warfare to joint exploration. Both sides learn, and the resulting decision is sharper than anything either person could have produced alone.
Consider a product team that discovered a critical flaw in its go-to-market plan only because a junior member dared to voice doubt during a review session. Had the team’s culture punished dissent, that flaw would have surfaced in the market – at far greater cost. The brief discomfort of an honest debate saved months of rework.
Building the culture step by step
Creating a genuine culture of error and debate does not require a grand programme. It starts with small, repeated acts: acknowledging your own mistakes publicly, responding to criticism with curiosity rather than defensiveness, and praising those who raise uncomfortable truths. Over time, these behaviours become norms – and the organisation moves from surface harmony to real performance.
A question for your next meeting: In the past quarter, when was the last time someone openly disagreed with you – and you thanked them for it?
Yours, Matthias Kolbusa