General

Flop Instead of Top: Five Management Rules That Are Worthless

Philipp Detloff3 min reading time
Flopp statt top

We all know the golden rules that young managers are inoculated with to guarantee their success. Unfortunately, most of these brilliant maxims come from great theorists who have no clue about real management life. And because these rules hardly ever produce outstanding results, legions of average managers populate the world while outstanding ones remain in short supply.

Five Management Rules That Are Worthless

If excellent management means executing initiatives with maximum efficiency, speed and quality, the golden rules quickly become nonsense advice that top managers must free themselves from as quickly as possible.

1. Turn Those Affected into Participants

Whatever you want to change or develop in management: involve as many affected colleagues and employees as possible in the deliberations to have a broad base.

Nonsense. Make sure you have only a few people on board – but ones who are true believers, who are crystal clear, who put pressure on the foot-draggers and who simply get things done instead of just talking.

2. Set Fixed Targets

If you want to cut costs by ten per cent, state it clearly and demand solutions for how to achieve it.

Nonsense. Let your people think about what maximum savings are possible under what conditions instead. You will find that your employees can squeeze out far more than ten per cent. The problem with fixed targets is that they may be met, but they are never exceeded.

3. Give Every Meeting a Clear Agenda

Schedule three hours for a particular meeting, for example, and define exactly who gets which time block for what. That way you have a clear structure and none of the participants can step out of line.

Nonsense. Meetings and workshops can always be shorter than they actually are. You just need to think about what exactly needs to be clarified and decided.

Flop instead of top
Image source: AI

Make this unmistakably clear right from the start. Then push forward and focus exclusively on the stated points. Meetings do not need agendas – they need results lists.

4. Make All Decisions by Consensus

Only decisions made by consensus are sustainable resolutions that will be executed by everyone involved.

Nonsense. Before every decision, clarify: who owns the decision? If you have set a two-thirds majority for the question of whether certain customers should be dropped for profitability reasons, the doubters must get on board too. Unanimity only dilutes. Then follow through on what has been decided with full consistency. If someone is still spreading bad feeling in the canteen afterwards, you need to have a conversation.

5. Plan and Structure Your Projects Thoroughly

When a CRM implementation or the conquest of a new market has been decided, develop a comprehensive plan and do everything to hit your fixed milestones with pinpoint accuracy.

Nonsense. Plans do not create productivity – they create unnecessary complexity. Instead of chasing activities, plans and milestones, define how you can tell that you are genuinely getting closer to the result. Track those indicators instead of comfortably managing activities that are often helpful but rarely necessary. Because that only makes you busy, not productive.

Yours, Matthias Kolbusa