No reorganisation project where the topic of abolishing hierarchy is not on the agenda. Perhaps eliminate a few management layers? A bit more project organisation or more network? More swarm intelligence? Or hip and fluid, entirely without structures?
From a management perspective, the aspiration is clear and entirely sensible: as little organisation as possible. Every additional interface creates coordination effort, carries friction potential up to and including pointless silo behaviour, or causes losses in value creation.
Does that mean there is nothing to counter the cry of HR pioneers to finally abolish all forms of organisation? No – that would only be the case if we assumed that all people, and thus all members of an organisation (leaders, who would no longer exist in the traditional sense, as well as all employees), behaved maturely. For me, being mature means having the follow-through and courage to always do the right thing. And the right thing is to benefit more people than you harm with everything you say or do.
If we were all mature and courageous in this sense, we would need no superiors, no rules and regulations – at most a few well-thought-out processes to keep certain things running smoothly.
Unfortunately, This Beautiful Dream Has Two Catches
The first is our base motives and needs:
Instead of doing the right thing for the organisation, we act anything but maturely: out of greed, the need for power, envy, desperation, malice or feelings of inferiority – to name just a few components of our dark side. We cling to our budget instead of releasing it for priorities. We leave sales out in the cold after a marketing blunder – and if they cannot fix it, we blame the salespeople. Or we kill a project simply because it offers us no stage for self-promotion.
The second catch is our comfort-seeking:
We surrender without resistance to the human tendency to avoid difficulties. Why struggle unnecessarily? Unfortunately, it is precisely the meaningful and uncomfortable things – in exactly that combination – that drive our organisation forward the most. Can I improve revenue and margins by sitting in the comfort zone and doing a bit more of the same? Never. Our revenue does not skyrocket just because we have even more coffee with customers who always order the same monthly volume.
“What Got You Here, Won’t Bring You There”
If we truly want more than just scraping by, we must do something radically new, even if that means replacing a sleepy field sales team with an alert and motivated partner sales force. Does that take effort? Does it hurt? Is it worth it? Is there no other way? Yes, yes, yes and yes. Unfortunately, most of us never manage to overcome this comfort-seeking and small-mindedness.
Immanuel Kant recognised this long ago:
“Immaturity is the inability to use one’s own understanding without the guidance of another. This immaturity is self-incurred when its cause lies not in a lack of understanding but in a lack of resolve and courage to use it without the guidance of another. Laziness and cowardice are the reasons why such a large proportion of people, long after nature has freed them from external guidance, still gladly remain immature throughout their lives; and why it is so easy for others to set themselves up as their guardians. It is so comfortable to be immature.”«
Translated to our companies, this means: we need almost mathematically exactly as much organisation as there is immaturity to compensate for. And much as I would wish for more fluid network organisations, my consulting experience in companies of all sizes shows me that it does not (yet) work without hierarchy. Nevertheless, it works far flatter and simpler than we believe. Many high-potential people in countless companies already possess the necessary maturity. We just need to get rid of the narcissists who, together with their cliques, have become the mould in management.
Beyond that, we can work deliberately on our maturity. Each one of us, individually. And you must tackle the root cause if you want more effective, flatter organisations. Anyone who believes they can achieve higher productivity solely through a new organisational structure is treating the symptom and will be bitterly disappointed.
Yours Matthias Kolbusa