When I am asked “Mr Kolbusa, if we could change only one thing to boost our performance, what would it be?”, my answer is clear:
“Stop always needing to be right.”«
Most managers can scarcely imagine that behind this exceedingly common, all-too-human and almost uncontrollable phenomenon lies one of the greatest brakes on execution of all. It is almost unbelievable how much mismanagement and unproductivity arise from the need to be right alone. Besides the habit of always wanting to be right, there is hardly any other mechanism in management teams that so reliably leads to:
- people feeling miserable during and after meetings,
- internal battles being fought that escalate into wars,
- revenge being taken – whether on a small or large scale,
- excellent ideas either failing to gain traction or never being voiced at all,
- employee satisfaction declining,
- collaboration – especially across departments – becoming conflict-ridden and unproductive.
The path to getting this problem under control begins with awareness and with recognising and experiencing the incredible effect of genuine collaboration – instead of perpetual competition. The challenge: you have to steel yourself and simply start by no longer insisting on being right at all costs. It will probably be a bit of a two-steps-forward-one-step-back affair, because at the beginning people readily fall back into old patterns despite everyone having pledged to do better. That is human and should be met with understanding – yet fought consistently nonetheless.
But what can we do in practice to stimulate the power of exclusively healthy competition alongside maximum cooperation in management? First, we should be clear that giving up the constant need to be right by no means means giving up the right to hold a clear opinion. The most important elements on this new path are genuine openness to other viewpoints and the real insight that you do not, as the saying goes, have all the answers.
Kolbusa’s “Right or Wrong” Everyday Rules
The following everyday rules make an excellent starting point for a new era in management. Over time they will produce a shared spirit and eventually a genuine culture of success:
1. We keep reminding ourselves that it is not about right or wrong but about gaining insight.
2. When someone says “I see it this way,” we do not start a playground argument with an undifferentiated “Well, I see it differently!” The only legitimate response that shows genuine interest is: “Please explain how you arrived at that.” Only then can either I learn something, or my counterpart, and sometimes both of us.
3. We consistently eliminate conversational killer phrases. These include:
- “Yes, but …” Because every “yes, but” is a lie.
- “They” in the sense of “the others”: it is about working together, not against each other.
- There is no “opposing side” – we are one.
- “My position is …” Because there are no positions we want to enforce – only insights.
4. We learn dialectics through what I call “flag-planting.” Here is an example:
- We place a thesis at the centre, for example: “Sales performance can be increased by 30 per cent.” This happens regardless of whether it intuitively meets with resistance from some participants. With relevant topics that is almost always the case.
- We then discuss under which necessary conditions this thesis could hold. “If this and that are given, then …”
- The art lies in identifying all the necessary conditions. Even with very complex topics there are usually only between six and ten.
- We then check whether these conditions (possibly including second-order conditions) can be met.
- If yes, we get started on making sales performance fly.
- If no, our iron rule applies: if even a single necessary condition cannot be met, the topic is off the table. Necessary conditions that cannot be realised are killer factors.
The origin of this dialectical flag-planting is attributed to Plato. Its advantage over classic brainstorming is that no unfounded ideas and assumptions fly around the room, because the focus is exclusively on goal-oriented and constructive contributions.
Yours, Matthias Kolbusa
Book Recommendation
If you are looking for more inspiration like the one you have just read to make your year as a manager as exciting, satisfying and therefore successful as you wish, I recommend my recently published 55 Management Inspirations. Whether you implement them week by week or pull several levers at once: I look forward to every experience report and your feedback. Good luck!
MATTHIAS KOLBUSA 55 Management-Inspirationen
Hardcover Published 15 December 2021
ISBN 978-3982163918 Price: EUR 19.90 / Kindle EUR 14.90 Information and ordering